After five years of state oversight, the Penn Hills School District has exited Pennsylvania’s financial recovery program.
The Pennsylvania Department of Education this week officially approved Penn Hills’ exit from the program it has been in for the past five years after the district found itself $172 million in debt. Department officials, including Pennsylvania Education Secretary Khalid Mumin, announced the accomplishment at the district’s middle school Thursday morning.
“This is an outstanding accomplishment,” Mr. Mumin said. “This is really, really a big deal. … Today’s announcement is a testament to the great things we can do when we work together.”
The announcement followed years of work by district administrators who recently presented the state with five-year budget projections showing finances have stabilized while also focusing on educational opportunities, which were laid out in a three-year comprehensive plan approved by the school board in March.
“When we first embarked on this path, the challenges seemed insurmountable,” Superintendent John Mozzocio said Thursday. “Our district faced significant financial deficits, dwindling resources and an uncertain future. But through resilience, dedication and an unwavering commitment to our students, we did not only overcome these obstacles but emerged stronger and more united than ever.”
Penn Hills, teaching 3,026 students, is now the third district to exit financial recovery. York City School District became the first Pennsylvania district to make it out of the program in 2022. The Scranton School District exited the program last year. Locally, the Sto-Rox and Duquesne City school districts remain in recovery.
Read More
But the decision at Penn Hills came after years of struggle in the suburban district. In 2007 officials were about $400,000 in debt and unable to pay bills.
At the time the state appointed a consultant who recommended the district scale down its 218,000-square-foot high school by nearly 5%. But Penn Hills instead chose to hire Architectural Innovations for $11 million to design a new elementary and high school. The designs included high-end materials such as chandeliers, floor tiles imported from Italy and a white roof at the high school instead of a cheaper black one.
The projects, paid for with bonds, quickly added up to millions of dollars and ultimately increased the district’s overall debt to nearly $6.5 million. On top of that, Penn Hills was improperly reporting interest payments from the construction period. As a result, the general fund balance was overstated by $11 million between fiscal years 2010 and 2012.
In response to the worsening situation, district officials received another state consultant who recommended budget cuts and a tax hike.
But after the consultant left, believing the 2015 budget would be balanced, the district backed off the measures that would have made it solvent. Instead, officials took out a $12 million short-term loan that had to be repaid when tax revenues were collected.
“I can't even tell you how horrific it was because there was no cash, bills are behind, reports are behind and we are scrambling for survival in that moment,” Nancy Hines, who was appointed interim superintendent in 2015, told the Post-Gazette. Ms. Hines was officially named superintendent later that year and held that position until she retired in August.
Ms. Hines tightened the ship. She went through different business managers and human resources personnel. Ms. Hines also weeded through financial documents that showed alarming purchases: a pair of shoes for a teacher and a Home Depot credit card used to buy a residential water heater.
Despite Ms. Hines’s efforts, Pennsylvania in 2017 placed Penn Hills on financial watch, allowing the state to provide the district with an extra $2 million during two school years.
But the situation worsened a year later when then-state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale issued a scathing report citing a “total breakdown” in oversight and a “shocking” $18.8 million deficit. The report focused on former business manager Richard Liberto, who was fired in 2015 amid accusations that a bus contractor stole more than $260,000 in district fuel. In that time tuition payments to alternative schools were under-budgeted and Mr. Liberto failed to properly oversee district credit cards. Mr. Liberto denied any wrongdoing.
That report was reinforced in 2019 when an Allegheny County grand jury report was released, detailing how board members, district leaders and vendors made decisions that showed a lack of understanding of future costs and obligations related to the projects.
That same year, state officials placed Penn Hills in financial recovery, seizing control of the district’s finances and appointing a financial recovery officer to form a financial plan.
Road to recovery
When Daniel Matsook, the chief recovery officer, came to the district in 2019, Penn Hills was facing a negative fund balance. Officials were taking out loans over the summer to pay teacher salaries, and those loans were paid back in September when tax money was received. That meant the district was running out of money by the spring and forced to ask the state’s education department for its subsidy early.
To help reverse those numbers, Mr. Matsook and the school board created a plan to cut staff to match declining enrollments and froze salaries. In all, between the 2018-19 and 2023-24 school years, the district saw a reduction of 57 employees.
“It was tough to hear, but it was also like, well, how can we make it better so we're not continuing to just spiral out of control,” Kristin Brown, the elementary principal, said in March.
The district also raised taxes by a total of 2 mills over five years and worked to reduce the number of students attending charter schools — districts have to pay charter school tuitions under state law — by knocking on doors of families attending those schools in an attempt to get them to return to Penn Hills.
By May 2020 Penn Hills received its first round of Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief, funds given out during the COVID-19 pandemic. In all, the district received $18.1 million in pandemic relief funds, used to cover building maintenance costs and to bolster its fund balance that at the time only totaled $600,000. Today the district has a $12.1 million fund balance, the proposed 2023-24 budget shows.
But ESSER funds are ending in September, meaning district officials will have to “regroup and figure out what we need to do in order to continue to sustain ourselves to be able to balance budgets,” John Zahorchak, the district’s business manager, said. The district will see a decrease of $3 million in ESSER funds in the upcoming budget.
And the district is waiting on the state budget, the proposed version of which shows Penn Hills receiving an additional $6 million. If that proposal comes to fruition, Penn Hills will have a $3 million surplus. But if the state budget does not pass as proposed, Penn Hills could be facing a $3 million deficit. The budget, which has received pushback from Republicans, was proposed by Gov. Josh Shapiro in February and must be approved by June 30.
“When you have a $6 million difference, how do you plan for that?” Mr. Zahochak said.
For now, officials are celebrating Penn Hill’s exit from the recovery program. The district will move into a five-year monitoring phase to ensure it stays on the right track.
“This district was probably hit as low as it could possibly be by the mismanagement that happened,” Mr. Matsook said. “To their credit we’re up on our two feet and we’re breathing. We’re looking forward to a brighter future.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.