As contentious debates over what’s taught in K-12 schools continue to roil the country’s education landscape, Pittsburgh Public is at the forefront of a new course that will diversify history lessons taught in the district’s high schools.

The ethnic studies course, which will be fully implemented in the 2025-26 school year and will be a graduation requirement starting with the class of 2028, will focus on racial, ethnic and cultural groups of people from around the globe who are not typically the focus of social studies courses. Discussions will center on issues that society has faced over time.

The course, a yearslong initiative that mirrors similar movements taking place across the country, will help students develop deeper understandings of different cultures.

“Students will be empowered to engage socially and politically and to think critically about the world around them,” Ann Fillmore, executive director of literacy and library services for the district, said during an education committee meeting earlier this month.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Public will be the first district in the region to offer the course, Ms. Fillmore said. But once it comes to fruition, the course will be similar to several offered in different states.

Since 2019 — partly in response to the 2020 death of George Floyd, a Black man, by a Minneapolis police officer, which sparked nationwide protests — several states have created ethnic studies courses, The Washington Post reported. Those include Connecticut, where Black, Puerto Rican and Latino studies must be included in all public school curriculums; Delaware, which mandates that school districts offer Black history courses; Maine, which states Black studies and the history of genocide must be included in state testing; and Rhode Island, where schools are required to have a unit on African History and Heritage. California in 2021 also approved ethnic studies coursework for K-12 schools.

The movement — initially born in higher education in the late 1960s — comes as ethnic studies courses have been shown to have strong positive impacts on students, increasing school engagement and the probability of graduating and enrolling in college, a 2021 study from San Francisco Unified School District found.

Pittsburgh Public’s decision to join those states in offering the course brings Pennsylvania’s second largest school district “in line with … these other places that are really trying to develop curriculum that really honors their students’ identities,” Wayne Au, a dean and professor in the University of Washington Bothell’s School of Educational Studies, said.

But while the movement has been years in the making, it hasn’t been without pushback.

Advertise with us

California’s law passed after four years of debate, with advocates saying anti-racist teachings are critical for students while opponents pointed to what they said was critical race theory, a graduate-level academic framework for examining systemic racism in American institutions.

That mirrors national trends where opponents to diversity, equity and inclusion programs have raised concerns that some lessons and materials are indoctrinating students and contributing to racial prejudices.

And while controversy around DEI programs has been heavy on college campuses and in the workplace, it seemingly came to a head in K-12 schools last year when Florida officials rejected an AP African American Studies course — PPS implemented the Advanced Placement course in 2022 — saying it “lacks educational value” and is an example of progressive “indoctrination.” Several Republican states since then have dropped the course or chosen to offer a stripped-down version of the curriculum.

“Ethnic studies courses challenge white supremacy, they challenge settler colonialism,” Mr. Au said. “They challenge privileges due to power and status within the society and any time you have that, then those who have privilege and power will push back on it in various forms. We're seeing that everywhere there's been ethnic studies.”

Pittsburgh Public

At Pittsburgh Public, diversity and equity efforts have been underway since 2019, when district officials unveiled the “On Track to Equity: Integrating Equity Throughout PPS” plan.

Advertise with us

The 97-page document, which seeks to reduce racial disparities and elevate the achievement levels of Black students, came after a 1992 racial discrimination complaint, filed by parents and educators from the group Advocates for African American Students, who cited inequities between white and Black students in academics and discipline. The case was settled in 2006 when the district, admitting no wrongdoing, agreed to more than 70 terms.

By 2019 PPS presented the On Track to Equity Plan, which highlighted 27 action steps, including the creation of ethnic studies. Three years later an ethnic studies advisory committee was formed and in 2022 the school board approved ethnic studies as a graduation requirement for the class of 2028 — students starting that year will be required to take ethnic studies or African American history to graduate. Both courses will be part of the core curriculum.

Since then, district officials have been researching ethnic studies courses and looking at curricular revisions across all grade levels.

For high schoolers, the ethnic studies course will heavily focus on those of African, Asian, Indigenous and Latino descent. It will also include populations represented at Pittsburgh Public, where students come from 57 counties and speak 95 different languages. Of the district’s student body, 52% are Black, 31% are white and 9% are multi-racial.

And the course will highlight several themes of study including power and oppression, joy and resilience, social movement and resistance, human movement and interactions, and contributions and expressions over various time periods throughout history, although the emphasis will be on the 2000s to present day. Because some of the content will be difficult to learn, Ms. Fillmore said, officials are focusing on psychological safety in the classroom.

Advertise with us

“It’s important that that is established in order to be able to dig into the content of an ethnic studies course,” Ms. Fillmore said.

District officials are also reworking the district’s K-5 social studies curriculum to increase exposure and practice of core geography skills. And sixth and seventh grade curriculum, which focuses on world geography, is being tweaked. Now, sixth graders will learn about the eastern hemisphere; the focus will shift to the western hemisphere in seventh grade. Similar tweaks could be coming to the eighth grade.

The changes, according to Ms. Fillmore, will allow students to focus “on people and cultures of the world in each hemisphere, but also more specifically to move away from memorization of dates and events and more into a study of people in those spaces.”

As changes are made, Pittsburgh Public teachers will go through professional learning focused on “culturally responsive pedagogy and part of that is identifying your own biases as an adult,” Ms. Fillmore said.

District officials are now putting together focus groups and are working to fully develop the course’s curriculum.

Advertise with us

School board President Gene Walker applauded the course, noting that “a lot of the stuff that’s happening” today is coming “from a place of non-understanding,” meaning people pick sides because someone told them to rather than making an educated decision.

“Hopefully by the time … our kindergarten kids are in high school,” Mr. Walker said earlier this month, “they are just in a much better place to respond to some of the things that are happening.”