After graduating with the highest honors last year from Oakland Catholic High School, Lilliana Steich was set to spread her wings at Loyola University in Chicago when her plans took an unexpected turn.

Her father was laid off from his job and the family had to quickly shift gears and choose a more affordable college route. So she enrolled at the University of Pittsburgh and decided to live with her parents in Regent Square to cut down on expenses.

“Even with a $25,000 scholarship, Loyola would have still cost $45,000 a year to attend,” said Ms. Steich, who just completed her first year at Pitt. “There’s obviously some days that I wish I was waking up in a new city with new friends and a new routine. But for the most part, I’d rather live at home and be as debt-free as possible.”

She’s not alone.

Advertise with us

As the cost of higher education soars, Ms. Steich represents a growing trend among college students nationwide.

A recent survey by the Washington-based College Savings Foundation found that the highest percentage of high school students ever plan to live at home while pursuing their college dreams to cut costs. The annual survey of high school students across the nation found that 68% of college-bound students plan to live at home — up from 61% last year — with the vast majority of them (78%) doing so to save money.

“The fact that more students are willing to live at home while attending classes shows how determined they are to reduce costs, avoid debt and invest in their education,” said Chris McGee, chair of the College Savings Foundation.

The CSF survey found students are taking charge of their higher education costs, saving more money on their own and intending to work while at school.

“Significantly, when we see a quarter of students planning to work full-time, we know that they are serious,” Mr. McGee said.

Advertise with us
Lilliana Steich stands in her Regent Square home in front of a photo of her as a baby. A recent survey by the Washington-based College Savings Foundation found that the highest percentage of high school students, including Lilliana Steich, plan to live at home while pursuing their college dreams to cut costs. (John Colombo / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

‘A break for the family’

Financially, the Steich family is back on track, now that Michael Steich, 55, has landed another IT job.

Mary Lynn Steich said she is grateful she encouraged her daughter to also apply to the University of Pittsburgh as she also applied to Loyola.

“She was accepted at Pitt, too. We knew that,” said Ms. Steich, 58, a real estate agent for Re/Max Realty Brokers. “Luckily, my husband’s layoff happened before the deadline for response was necessary for both universities.”

Lilliana Steich is majoring in psychology, which she knows will require advanced degrees and a significant amount of money — another good reason to minimize her student loan debt at the undergraduate level.

Living in Regent Square, she can ride public transportation to and from Pitt’s main campus in Oakland. And she gets a free bus pass, thanks to her Pitt student ID. She drives a 2006 Toyota Corolla, which she inherited last year from her grandfather, to and from the job she recently started at Millie’s Homemade Ice Cream in Shadyside.

Advertise with us

“Her living at home is a break for the family,” Mary Lynn Steich said. “Her working gives her the opportunity to put gas in her car and use it whenever she wants to. Also, it helps her with books and lets her go shopping when she wants to.”

Lilliana’s routine hasn’t changed much. She rides the same bus line to Oakland that she rode in high school and is still living in her room.

And although she’s on track to earn a four-year degree, she has some regrets about missing out on the traditional college experience.

“It’s definitely a lot harder to socialize, especially like on the weekends, and making plans and everything,” she said.

Study groups aren’t as hard to participate in, she said.

Advertise with us

“I just have to stay a little bit longer on campus on weekdays,” she said. “But I’d say, for the most part, socializing and planning weekend activities are a little difficult.”

On-campus or commuter students?

Yet, living at home is a choice that’s saving her family thousands.

At Pitt, average annual room and board costs $13,420, and tuition for in-state students is $21,524 a year, according to College Navigator, a website run by the U.S. Department of Education.

The average cost of room and board nationwide for 2023 to 2024, according to the College Board, was $12,770 a year at a public four-year in-state college; and $14,650 at a private non-profit four-year college.

While Chatham University in Shadyside consistently has about 90% of its first-time, first-year students live on campus, that percentage can vary widely at other local colleges.

Advertise with us

Point Park University, located Downtown, had 2,439 commuter students out of 3,299 total students for the Fall 2023 semester, said Louis Corsara, a spokesman for Point Park University. At Point Park, “commuter” simply means the student does not live in campus-offered housing, Mr. Corsara said.

“We have a number of students who live Downtown in nearby apartment complexes, some of them just a block or two from campus,” he said.

He added that the “overwhelming majority” of Point Park students are not traditional commuter students, but that “we just don’t have an official way of tracking that number.”

More than a third of Duquesne University’s undergraduate student body commutes to classes. In the fall of 2023, 1,912 of 5,265 total undergraduate students (36.3%)  were commuters, according to Rose Ravasio, media and communications manager at Duquesne.

“Duquesne has long supported commuter students with excellent services and scholarship support, including commuter support grants and PHEAA matching grants for new students,” Ms. Ravasio said.

Advertise with us

‘In the thick of things’

Living on or off campus can affect classroom performance, according to studies.

Graduation rates for students who live on campus are better than the graduation rates for students who live off campus with their parents.

According to the 2021 book “Who Graduates from College? Who Doesn’t?”, by Mark Kantrowitz, 51% of students who live on campus graduate with a bachelor’s degree within four years compared to 20% of college students who live with their parents.

But it’s not entirely clear why that’s so, said Mr. Kantrowitz, a Chicago-based expert on college funding.

“It could be that students who live at home with their parents are having financial challenges and that may affect their ability to graduate,” he said. “There may also be other distractions like siblings creating noise and having a harder time studying. ... “They may have other chores instead of just focusing on their education. They might be working to bring in some money.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Kantrowitz said he understands the dilemma. His parents lived three miles away from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology campus when he was an undergraduate student there. But he chose to live on campus.

”I could have commuted,” Mr. Kantrowitz said. “I decided to live on campus because I’d be in the thick of things.

“I worked on the student newspaper, and there were many times after we put the newspaper to bed, we’d stay up all night playing bridge,” he said. “That couldn’t have happened it I was commuting.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 312-779-5834