This story is a collaboration between Inside Climate News and the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Story by Kiley Bense, data analysis and visualization by Peter Aldhous.

The Pittsburgh Botanic Garden property has led many lives: coal mine, farmland, resurrected forest. But inside the southern boundary, in acres of dense woods off-limits to the public, the relics of a less-remembered chapter litter the landscape.

Overturned tanks. Stained sheds and tangled, broken pipes. The creek gurgles, a sulfurous smell hanging in the air. Rusted pumpjacks guard the scene from a ridge; one wears a metal tag stamped with the name of a woman who lived here more than a century ago.

Jane McGill #1 is a leaking abandoned oil well, and this is an oil field graveyard.

The well is one of hundreds of thousands of oil and gas wells left unplugged across the state. Some leak methane, a highly flammable gas and climate pollutant, and other chemicals like cancer-causing benzene. Abandoned wells have been linked to home explosions and implicated in water contamination.

Jane McGill #1 is an abandoned oil well drilled in the 1890s, during the height of one of Pennsylvania’s biggest oil booms. (Scott Goldsmith/For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

For decades these wells went largely unnoticed. But as suburbia sprawls into what used to be open space, forgotten oil and gas wells now lurk near and even beneath shopping centers, schools, homes, backyards and public parks.

They may no longer be marked — the only sign a patch of dead grass, bubbles surfacing in a pond or an unassuming hole in the ground.

“It’s not a situation that we want to leave unchecked,” said Seth Pelepko, acting deputy secretary for the Department of Environmental Protection’s Office of Oil and Gas Management. Plugging these wells “is a critical first line of defense for ensuring that the environment’s protected and public health and safety is protected.”

Is There an Oil or Gas Well Near Your Home?

Use the map below to search for the oil or gas well nearest to addresses in Pennsylvania. The map will display information about the well, including inspection photos where available. You can click on other wells in the map view to see information for those sites.

Exercise caution if you think a well is nearby; some may be hazardous, and many are on private property.

The well information is maintained by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), which is responsible for data accuracy. If you have concerns about a well, contact the agency directly through this form or by calling the agency’s oil and gas office in your area.

We simplified the DEP’s descriptions of well status into four categories:

Active/Other. These are mostly wells that are still producing oil or gas. However, the DEP’s active category includes wells with no other status description, which means some disused wells may be mistakenly included. We have also included a small number of wells with “regulatory inactive status,” which allows an operator to shut down production for up to five years without having to seal a well.

Plugged wells are recorded as sealed. Most were plugged by contractors hired by their former operators, but some were plugged by the state. Plugging may fail, so some of these wells may still leak gases.

Advertise with us

Abandoned/Orphaned includes abandoned wells, which have been out of production for more than 12 months, and orphaned wells, for which no responsible operator or owner exists.

The wells are an enduring legacy of Pennsylvania’s long history of drilling, which began with the country’s first commercial oil well in 1859.

In Western Pennsylvania, the American oil industry’s boom-and-bust business model was born, a cycle of rapid growth and desertion that would be exported to Texas, Oklahoma and eventually around the world.

“Pennsylvania’s energy story is absolutely essential. It’s really where we learned for the first time as a society that if we wanted one thing, we were willing to make a mess of everything else to get that one thing.”

Brian Black, a history professor at Penn State Altoona who wrote a book about the 1860s oil rush

This pattern explains why so many wells were abandoned here—one analysis found that Pennsylvania has more documented orphaned wells than any other state but Ohio, which doesn’t account for the possibly hundreds of thousands that Pennsylvania hasn’t officially documented. It may also explain why the abandonment continues today.

“The actual area that produced the oil was an afterthought, and Pennsylvania is one of the first examples of that. It defined how those places were treated afterwards as well,” Black said. “This was the first place left behind.”

Advertise with us

Somewhere hides a well

This summer, a team of environmental advocates went in search of what remains of the wells in the back section of the Botanic Garden property. The group is part of a statewide effort to speed up the process of finding lost wells using artificial intelligence, drone flights, community outreach and historical maps. They’ve knocked on doors, held town halls and peered into the past, studying hand-drawn paper maps from the state’s archives.

To reach the wells, the group carried heavy equipment for more than an hour, wading through tall grasses and across the creek on a rotting makeshift bridge, pushing through thorny brush and climbing a steep, muddy embankment.

Hundreds of thousands of wells remain remain like ghosts of previous oil and gas booms.

“It’s not an easy area to get to,” said Melissa Ostroff, Pennsylvania policy and field advocate at the environmental group Earthworks.

“The first time I saw it was like, ‘Oh, this looks like a little seesaw or something.’ It’s almost cute. It’s very different than fracking operations, where it’s a huge rig,” Ostroff said. “It’s easy to just kind of lose them in the middle of a forest.”

Ostroff used an iPad with mapped coordinates to navigate to Jane McGill #1, where it sat in a nest of pipes, tree branches, weeds and tanks, an orange ribbon tied around the pumpjack.

Advertise with us

Ostroff set up a tripod with a type of infrared camera that allows her to see plumes emerging from oil and gas wells.

“All right, I see a leak,” she said, peering through the viewfinder. “It’s less bad than I thought, but you don’t want to be over there because it’s coming out that way.”

She motioned for the group to move away from the well and opened a pop-out display screen on the camera. It recast the pump in otherworldly colors, with bright orange spots where sunlight was heating the metal pipes and the dead leaves on the ground through a break in the tree canopy.

The screen captured what was otherwise invisible: a small but steady cloud wafting upward from the structure.

How many are leaking?

In recent years, scientists have tested more wells like Jane McGill #1, trying to better understand how many are leaking and how much those leaks are impacting the climate, environment and public health.

Advertise with us

“It’s estimated that about 10% to 20% of them have some emissions at the surface,” said Nick Gianoutsos, a physical scientist at the U.S. Geological Survey who helped create a federal database of documented orphaned wells.

Those emissions include methane and, in some cases, other chemicals called volatile organic compounds, or VOCs.

Melissa Ostroff of Earthworks walks with a special infrared camera used to detect plumes related to the oil and gas industry. (Scott Goldsmith/For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A 2023 study analyzed 48 abandoned wells in Western Pennsylvania and found that many were leaking VOCs like benzene. A smaller number of unplugged wells were emitting carbon monoxide and hydrogen sulfide, both deadly at high enough concentrations.

In 2024, a government inspector detected methane leaking from Jane McGill #1 at 6,235 parts-per-million-meter, a measure of gas across a column of space. “That indicates that quite a bit of gas is leaving the well,” said Seth Shonkoff, one of the authors of the abandoned wells study and the executive director at PSE Healthy Energy, a research institute based in Oakland, Calif. That reading “is a really strong indicator that there is a significant problem.”

The risks are much higher from wells beneath or close to buildings, Shonkoff said. The study found that nearly 25% of abandoned wells in Pennsylvania are located within a few hundred feet of a building.

Advertise with us

His research turned up wells near houses, schools, daycare centers and nursing homes, Shonkoff said.

When a building is constructed on top of a forgotten well, gases can get trapped indoors. If odorless, colorless methane builds up inside, it can trigger an explosion before anyone notices the leak.

“Since Americans spend 90%-plus of their time inside, the exposure potential to those types of chemical constituents is actually quite high.”

Seth Shonkoff, one of the authors of the abandoned wells study and the executive director at PSE Healthy Energy

Scientists are also studying how these wells could be affecting water quality; just down the ridge from Jane McGill #1 and three known wells runs a stream.

“Abandoned wells are frequently drilled through groundwater resources,” Shonkoff said. The older the well is, the more likely that the casing meant to keep the borehole sealed underground has corroded, rusted or failed completely.

“Nothing lasts forever,” Shonkoff said.

Advertise with us

‘Almost like Swiss cheese’

Pennsylvania has a high number of households that depend on unregulated private water.

Two years ago, the state plugged an orphaned well that had contaminated a family’s water well in Clarion County. Pennsylvania’s patchwork of abandoned coal mines, hidden oil and gas wells and ongoing fracking, often in the same place, can increase the chances of groundwater contamination.

“The subsurface almost looks like Swiss cheese,” said Joshua Woda, a hydrologist with the U.S. Geological Survey who worked on a 2025 study about the risks orphaned wells pose to aquifers.

Nationally, he said, “Pennsylvania stood out.”

Old wells can be especially hazardous to water supplies if companies drilling for gas don’t know where they are. In New Freeport, Pennsylvania, a new gas well that accidentally connected underground to an abandoned well was blamed for water contamination in dozens of homes; methane was found in more than 50 water wells.

Advertise with us

Because so few abandoned wells have been officially documented compared to the total and far fewer have been tested, “considerable uncertainty” remains about how much they are contributing to U.S. greenhouse gas emissions, according to U.S. Geological Survey scientists.

But preliminary numbers are startling.

In 2022, the Environmental Protection Agency estimated that leaks from abandoned wells make up about 4% of total emissions from the American oil and gas industry. That’s the equivalent of the carbon pollution created by 1.8 million gas-powered cars in a year.

‘Monuments to dead hopes’

Jane McGill #1 was named for the owner of the farm where it was drilled during one of Pennsylvania’s biggest oil booms.

“There has been nothing like the present activity in the history of the business,” The Pittsburgh Dispatch declared in October 1891. “Such gushers as are now being struck were never known before. They are the wonder of the age.”

Advertise with us

At its height, the McDonald oil field produced between 84,000 and 96,000 barrels a day.

Wells were everywhere: in front yards, backyards, graveyards and onion beds, “some of them scarcely a yard apart,” not just in the country districts but many within town limits.

“Everyone wanted to try to get into it, so they were just plopping down wells everywhere they could,”said Vinny Curtis, co-director of a local historical association in Washington County. “Because there was so much oil in such a short amount of time, it actually caused the price of oil to crash.”

In Oakdale, just up the road from McDonald and near where the Botanic Garden is today, the population tripled, dozens of new buildings and shops went up and a local returning from California refused to get off the train because he no longer recognized his hometown.

A bird's eye view of the town of McDonald in 1897. (Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division)

The heyday of the McDonald oil field didn’t last long.

Advertise with us

Production declined in 1892, and by 1906, a visitor to the field found that “bleak and weather-beaten derricks … stand like specters,” the frenzied moneymaking of the rush replaced with a scene as silent as the grave. Some of the wells had been dismantled or destroyed by the elements and others held on “like monuments to dead hopes.”

McDonald and the surrounding area never recovered economically, said Curtis, of the historical society.

“It’s a common story,” he said, one that is echoed in the fates of other places in Western Pennsylvania, like the Mon Valley after the decline of the steel industry, “where you’re left with these towns and cities along the river that are shadows of what they once were.”

The death of the oil rush ushered in decades of coal mining that left this region even more scarred. When strip mining ended, some of the land was unusable, as farmland or anything else.

Curtis, who grew up here, believes this legacy of neglect has a way of getting into people’s minds—shaping what they think is and isn’t possible for themselves and their children.

Advertise with us

“That land has sat like that, abandoned and useless, for 50 years. You’re living there and driving past it every day, and it’s just like barren, slate-covered land. Nothing can grow on it.”

Vinny Curtis, co-director of a local historical association in Washington County

He hopes that teaching history can break this generational pattern of assuming “this is what happens here.”

Black, the environmental historian, said the early oil booms created an “ethic of extraction” statewide. When fracking was on the rise in the 2000s, Pennsylvania could have chosen, like New York, to ban or seriously curtail it. Instead, the gas industry was welcomed.

Who pays?

State officials now contend with the problems they inherited. More than two years ago, the government issued a notice of violations to the operator of Jane McGill #1, alleging that he failed “to ensure that the integrity of the well is maintained and health, safety, environment and property are protected” and “to plug the well upon abandoning it.”

In the summer of 2026, the well was still leaking. Ostroff believes it’s stranded in legal limbo, a common obstacle to well-plugging. Landowners are not necessarily the owners of wells drilled on their property; Jane McGill #1 sits on land owned by Allegheny County and leased by the Botanic Garden, but its last recorded operator appears to have died in 2025.

The Department of Environmental Protection did not respond to questions about the ownership or status of the well.

Advertise with us

Such details matter because well-plugging is expensive.

A 2026 report found that the average cost to plug an orphaned well in Pennsylvania was more than $100,000, about $30,000 higher than the number across six states that have received federal funds for well-plugging.

A rusted tank stands in the woods on the back property in the Pittsburgh Botanic Garden. The tank is an example of the detritus left behind by drilling. (Scott Goldsmith/For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The age of the wells is one reason: The average well plugged here is more than a century old, and older wells are typically more difficult and costly to seal.

If the state can find a responsible owner to pay for plugging, it has an obligation to try every avenue to do so.

“We want to make sure that we pursue all assets that an operator may have,” said Pelepko, the state regulator. “That’s a time-consuming process.”

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania could be doing more to ensure that companies drilling stay on the hook for costs associated with inactive wells rather than passing that burden to taxpayers, experts say. For non-fracked wells, operators must set aside $2,500 per well. Costs for fracked wells depend on the specifications of the well and how many the operator is responsible for; those bonds start at $4,000 per well. This year the state has issued more than 400 violation notices to operators for abandoning wells.

It’s unlikely that the state is going to find a responsible party to deal with most of the oldest wells, said Daniel Raimi, a fellow at Resources for the Future in Washington, D.C., who recently co-authored a report on the progress made by the federal well-plugging program.

“But what we really need is reforms to state policies to reduce the likelihood of additional wells becoming orphaned,” Raimi said. “This should not be the responsibility of taxpayers. This is an industry problem.”

The story of the land

Unlike the slice of land that is open to the public, the part of the Botanic Garden property where Jane McGill #1 awaits its fate has not yet been remediated. It is marked with the artifacts of centuries of use and abandonment, from the rusted oil equipment and leaking wells to lumps of bituminous coal and a pit created by a mine collapse.

“The whole past land use history is there, and all of the ecological stories are there,” said Sue Myers, the horticulture and conservation director at the Botanic Garden. “It’s almost like a manuscript that you just have to learn to read.”

This land was swept up in an oil rush and dotted with derricks; flattened for a strip mine; timbered, excavated and cleared. Generations of farmers tilled the hills. The fossil fuels beneath the surface are clues to a distant past, remnants of an ancient sea.

This story is written on the land. But its ending is uncertain.

“Sometimes it feels like it’s too late to correct a lot of it,” said Nate Reese, the site’s associate communications director, of the layers of pollution and damage left behind.

“In reality we’re actually just at the beginning, and all of this land is still extremely usable. I think it’s going to be an incredible landscape that hopefully I get to see.”

Today, in the shade of tall trees protected by the garden’s borders for decades, the temperature drops, and the creek runs slow and cold.

Wild raspberries grow in the bramble. Frogs croak, insects hum and a turtle sleeps in a pocket of sunlight. The trees rustle with birds. The muddy creek banks are inscribed with the footprints of deer and racoons.

Myers, a botanist, sees resilience in this landscape of ruins.

“That’s one of our most biologically diverse areas,” she observed.

Someday, after the wells are plugged, Myers imagines the back section of the property and its wreckage starting a new chapter — as a living map that shows not only how to heal the wounds of the past, but also how to write a different future.