Trevor McGlynn shot his hand into the air one day last week while sitting in a third-floor Allderdice High School classroom. The 16-year-old junior was eager to give his take on an 1829 speech calling on slaves to demand their freedom. 

“I think one of the important things that I saw was the question that he asked, ‘Do you believe that this assertion is swallowed by millions of the whites,’” Trevor said while reading from David Walker’s 1829 article “Appeal," which argued that Black people do not have an opportunity for advancement within the current society so those who are enslaved and free should find another country where they are welcome. 

His comment kicked off a back and forth between the 22 students in the Advanced Placement African American Studies class, one group of whom read from “Appeal” and another that read from the 1843 “An address to the slaves of the United States” by Henry Highland Garnet, which stated Black people have been in the U.S. for generations so they have a right to stay. 

“This is their land more than Africa is their land,” 17-year-old senior Akiua Weinkle said of Garnet’s speech. “Yes they’re descendants from people from Africa and their ancestors who were brought here were brought from Africa but they have no connection to that land physically. It’s been over 10 generations since they were brought here.”

Advertise with us

The discussion that took place minutes before the bell rang and class ended, wasn’t a debate between students; rather, it was an analysis of two well-known speeches written by Black men years apart that called for the rebellion of Black people living in America after years of slavery and oppression by their white counterparts. 

The speeches were part of an ongoing lesson on radical resistance — or how Black people began pushing back against systems of oppression — taking place in teacher Brian Nolte’s AP African American Studies course last Tuesday, a class that has sparked national attention after some Republicans accused it of being “woke” and indoctrinating students. At least five conservative states are currently limiting its implementation.

Lundyn Harvey, 16, center, and her classmates read about approaches to addressing slavery in pre-Civil War America during Brian Nolte’s AP African American Studies at Allderdice High School in Squirrel Hill on Tuesday, Nov. 21, 2023. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Eruptions over the class and its coursework, which aims to “explore the vital contributions and experiences of African Americans,” according to the nonprofit College Board, the developers of the course, comes during its pilot phase where it is being tested at around 800 schools across the country. 

But that number is nearly twice the total schools that were originally planned following a surge in demand as the course continued to make national headlines. The increase in interest came after last year, when 60 schools including Allderdice participated in the first year of the pilot. The course will be open to all districts in 2024-25.

“It’s a good course,” Mr. Nolte said. “It’s something that’s worth it. It’s worthy of being taught, it’s worthy of being discussed. I’ll never back down from that perspective.”

Advertise with us

According to Mr. Nolte, AP African American Studies is like a U.S. history course but it “takes into the life, the perspective, the ideas that African Americans would have going through the Civil War, going through slavery, going through the Great Depression, going through any one of these events that you could think of that would encompass U.S. history. It’s just from the Black perspective.” The idea, he said, is to incorporate viewpoints that have been left out of history “because all stories deserve and have a right to be told and be heard especially when we’re talking about learning.” 

He used the speeches by Walker and Garnet as an example of telling the story of American history through the eyes of two Black men.

“The only thing that really gets put into history books in a typical classroom would be the idea of what are we going to do in terms of moving Native Americans or how are we going to expand westward as white pioneers venture off into this unknown land,” Mr. Nolte said. “Instead we talk about it from a real perspective of enslaved and freed Black men and women here in the United States.”

AP African American Studies came to the Squirrel Hill school last year at the advocacy of social studies department chair Michele Halloran. From there, Mr. Nolte was chosen to lead the course because he had studied similar topics before and previously taught a non-AP African American history class. He also underwent additional summer training that focused on how to present information covered in the class.

Trevor McGlynn, 16, center, discusses a primary source addressing approaches to resisting slavery in prep-Civil War America during AP African American Studies at Allderdice High School in Squirrel Hill on Tuesday, Nov. 21, 2023 (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

At Allderdice, 111 high schoolers are enrolled in the class, up from 72 last year. Mr. Nolte noted that Pittsburgh Public has been “very supportive” of the course so far. 

Advertise with us

But controversy around AP African American Studies came to a head in January when Florida officials rejected the AP course based on their reading of preliminary documents, saying it “lacks educational value.” Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis called it “woke” curriculum and an example of progressive “indoctrination,” The Washington Post reported.

And in February, the College Board finalized a plan for the course, which omitted some left-leaning figures included in the original draft such as Kimberlé W. Crenshaw, a scholar and writer on civil rights and critical race theory, and Angela Davis, a political activist and academic who is known for her membership in the Communist and Black Panther parties. 

The College Board denied watering down the course; instead, they said changes were in the works prior to pushback from conservative lawmakers. 

But since then, several conservative states have taken a stance against the AP course.

Arkansas in August decided to drop the course, saying it does not comply with the classes they want to offer. In North Dakota before a school district can offer the class it would have to review course materials to see if they conflict with the state’s law and rules that restrict how topics such as critical race theory are taught. Officials in Mississippi and Virginia also questioned the course, but the Virginia Department of Education this month said that a stripped-down version of the class can be offered to high school students. The decision came after Gov. Glenn Youngkin ordered a review of the class after banning the teaching of “divisive concepts.”

Advertise with us

At the same time,  New Jersey and Illinois, both Democrat-led states, emphasized the need for AP African American Studies.

“I think it’s flat out racism,” Sadie Primack, a 16-year-old  junior, said of lawmakers limiting access to the course. “I think that it is important that we have this class. It’s a rebellion.”

Haydon Aiello, also a 16-year-old junior, added, “I think it’s better to have the class. I don’t think there’s a single reason I can name not to have it.”

AP African American Studies

One by one, each of the 22 students stood up from their seats during last Tuesday’s class, each holding a poster designed to reflect resistance in any form. 

Some posters were bright orange with flames, a symbol for the burning of homes. Others depicted broken tools, an effort by slaves to slow production on plantations. A few students pinpointed specific moments in history including the 1739 Stono Rebellion in South Carolina, the largest slave revolt ever staged in the 13 colonies.

Advertise with us

The 30-second speeches were some of the first steps Mr. Nolte is taking to prepare students for a formal presentation that will be part of the AP test at the end of the year. This is the first year that students can earn college credit through the test; last year, the College Board required all students enrolled in AP African American Studies to take the test, but they did not earn credit. 

“It’s now high stakes and it matters,” Mr. Nolte said. 

But for teens who chose to take AP African American Studies, information they’re learning is invaluable and is giving them a new perspective on history. 

“I have never heard of a lot of things we’ve done in this class,” Sadie said. “I feel like a lot of curriculum through middle school and high school is just repetitive of what happened in the Civil War and that’s great and important that we talk about it but we have skipped over … tons of events that need to be talked about.”

For Trevor, who was quick to dive into difficult discussions during the class, AP African American Studies is vital for everyone to learn regardless of their own backgrounds.

“It’s important for people to learn and it’s important for everybody to have this availability of information because it teaches students about either their history or their peers’ history and even their country’s history as a whole,” Trevor said. “It’s history that students need to know regardless of who they are or where they came from.”