Almost a dozen parents and community members on Monday spoke out about the Pittsburgh Public School District’s proposed 2024 budget, calling on administrators to create a cost-savings plan that does not include closing school buildings.

Concerns expressed during the afternoon budget public hearing ranged from fears that the district could close Pittsburgh Woolslair PreK-5, a STEAM — science, technology, engineering, arts and math — academy in Bloomfield, to dissatisfaction with the spending plan many suggested lacks transparency and sufficient community input. The hearing came almost two weeks after the district proposed a $713.9 million operating budget that includes a $29.6 million deficit. The board is expected to vote on a final budget this month.

“We have a lot of issues around transparency when it comes to this budget,” Angel Gober, executive director of the advocacy group 412 Justice, which fights for educational, environmental and economic rights, said during the hearing. “We are hearing rumblings around school closures, which is super problematic. We don’t understand why we haven’t been engaged as a community when it comes to understanding the budget.”

District officials first introduced the preliminary budget in November. At the time, the proposal included $684.2 million in revenues and $713.9 million in expenditures. Under that plan, district officials would use the fund balance to cover the expected deficit, dropping that budget line to an estimated $45.4 million, and causing the fund balance to no longer adhere to the board’s minimum 5% fund balance policy.

Advertise with us

That means the board could not rely on that money to balance its 2026 budget if there is a deficit. It would also continue a year-over-year decrease since 2021, when the fund balance totaled $86.6 million.

Given the potential deficit, school officials have been working to reduce expenditures moving forward. One option being considered is consolidating school buildings to account for declining enrollments. As things currently stand the district’s school buildings have room for 40,000 students. Today the district enrolls around 19,000 students. Potential plans for consolidation could be presented at the start of the year.

But for many parents attending the public hearing, school closures are not a viable option.

Several suggested that school closures in the past have disproportionately impacted students of color while creating “trauma” for younger learners as they fear leaving other children and teachers they have known for most of their school careers.

“Closing schools does not work,” Valerie Webb-Allman, a district parent, said. “We cannot put our capacity in our classrooms at 80%, 90% like what was proposed in the school plan meetings that the superintendent did earlier in the year. That’s a nonstarter. Our kids can’t learn in that kind of setting.”

Advertise with us

While specific plans for possible school closures have not yet been released, several parents were fearful the district will target Woolslair, which teaches 179 students, 62% of whom are economically disadvantaged. The school was previously considered for closure in 2021, along with five others in an effort to modernize the district’s footprint.

“It always seems to be a topic of discussion to [close] Woolslair,” parent Jazlynn Worthy said. “Why?”

She said the STEAM school has been “a village,” helping to raise her three children and creating an atmosphere that makes kids excited to go to class.

Parent Annette Hall said her two daughters who wrote statements to the board are “petrified their school is going to close.” One statement read by Ms. Hall was written by her 10-year-old who said Woolslair has inspired her to be an astronaut while helping to improve her grades. Ms. Hall’s second grader said she wouldn’t like school if she “couldn’t do engineering things” such as building robots and debugging computers.

“Every parent wants this for their child and Woolslair has this,” Ms. Worthy said. “I implore you to change your mind. Dig deep and know that the bright future on the horizon for our students lies in the palm of your hands.”

Advertise with us

Instead of closing schools, Emily Sawyer, a parent of five Pittsburgh Public students, said the district needs to stop investing in “expensive, dehumanizing and discriminatory school policing” that targets Black and brown students. She said the district should instead focus on creating “life-affirming, joyful schools” by hiring school climate coordinators, increasing the number of counselors and social workers and investing in paraprofessionals.

“Let’s get brave and try something different,” Ms. Sawyer said. “We can only do that if we spend our money differently.”

Other speakers said the district needs to create a more transparent process when considering the “people’s budget” for the upcoming fiscal year.

Noel Webb, operations director at 412 Justice, said the budget is “an accounting of how you’re going to spend our tax dollars equitably and it must be transparent so we can see where the money is spent.” Ms. Webb said she wants to see budget hearings take place earlier in the year rather than a month before school directors are set to vote on a final budget while holding community input more frequently to ensure constituents’ opinions are heard.

Those methods, she said, will lead to “more equitable, innovative solutions” that could strengthen relationships between young people and local leaders. The current process, Ms. Webb said, “freezes out community engagement.”

Advertise with us

Sandra Woolley, a district resident, agreed. She added that the current budget shows a “lack of visionary planning” and does not look into potential solutions facing the district in future years.

“It’s important that we care,” Ms. Woolley said. “We think that public schools are essential for our democracy and we want PPS to be successful.”