When Sue Mariani took the helm of the Duquesne City School District in 2018, the community had one goal for her: bring seventh through 12th graders back to the small, suburban district.

And for the past six years, Ms. Mariani has taken that goal to heart, successfully reintegrating seventh and eighth graders and taking necessary steps to phase high schoolers back after they were moved to East Allegheny and West Mifflin school districts in 2007.

But last week Ms. Mariani received devastating news: the Pennsylvania Department of Education denied the district’s plan to restart the high school program.

“There’s really no words,” Ms. Mariani said in an interview Tuesday. “It really was heartbreaking to hear that answer.”

Advertise with us

The decision, according to a department of education spokesperson, was based on finances.

Once the district approached PDE with a request to restart the high school program, the department in partnership with Public Financial Management conducted an in-depth analysis of Duquesne’s finances and projected financial scenarios, including potential facility and operational factors associated with reopening the high school.

But the projections “show that operating a high school program would require long-term revenue commitments that the District’s current financial status will not be able to support,” Khalid N. Mumin, the Pennsylvania secretary of education, wrote in his rejection letter to Duquesne.

The letter did not detail the district’s finances or the projected scenarios, but Ms. Mariani said the long-term projections created by PFM “just look bleak. And that’s what they’re going off of.”

“Although PDE has determined that it is not financially feasible for the District to reopen its high school beginning with the 2024-2025 school year and I cannot therefore approve the District’s request, I greatly appreciate your dedication to your students and staff,” Mr. Mumin wrote.

Advertise with us

Ms. Mariani noted that it could now take two to three years before the district can revisit the idea of bringing high school students back to Duquesne.

Duquesne City’s high school officially closed in 2007, with significant pushback from the community, following longstanding financial problems stemming from a declining tax base and shrinking enrollments. At the time, state officials said the high school program was failing its students because of a lack of Advanced Placement and honors courses, as well as few athletic opportunities and no extracurricular activities.

But despite moving some students from the district, problems persisted.

Five years after the high school closed, district officials were forced to cut its middle school because of continued economic and academic problems. By 2013 the state officially put the district into financial recovery, seizing control of the district’s finances and appointing a recovery officer to form a financial plan. And later that year Duquesne was assigned a receiver — who still directs the district today — to take the reins from the school board to carry out the proposed recovery plan.

In 2018, Duquesne hired Ms. Mariani. At the time, she said residents of the Mon Valley community made it known they wanted to “restore” Duquesne, which to her meant reverting the K-6 district back to a K-12. Three years after her appointment, seventh graders returned to Duquesne for the first time since 2012, a decision approved by the state after district officials wrote an amendment to their recovery plan, showed financial projections and detailed educational programming. Eighth graders followed a year later, making Duquesne at the time the only district in Pennsylvania to reopen its middle school after closing it.

Advertise with us

Since then, district officials have been working to bring back high school students.

The main problem, Ms. Mariani previously said, was finding a new school. The remaining Duquesne City school building, a three-story red brick structure built in 1913 that sits on Kennedy Avenue, once housed the district’s K-12 students. But much of the building has been repurposed, making it impossible to add in students in ninth through 12th grade.

Under the proposed plan, ninth and 10th graders would have moved back to the district in the fall. While the building currently holds 492 kindergarten through eighth grade students, there would have been enough room to house ninth and 10th graders for a year. Eleventh and 12th graders would have followed in 2025. Ms. Mariani said the district is working with a developer to identify a space that could be used in the future for high schoolers.

But for now, the district is focused on showing the state positive financial projections.

The city of Duquesne, which has struggled since the decline of steel mills, has a low tax base. The city has more than 5,200 residents with the median household income hovering around $41,000, census data shows. And according to the 2023-24 budget, the district only collects $1.2 million from real estate taxes, something Ms. Mariani attributed to a large number of renters and few homeowners.

Advertise with us

School districts rely on local revenues to bolster their budgets. In all, 53% of school district funding in Pennsylvania comes from local taxes, 36% from the state and 11% from federal shares. That system was ruled unconstitutional last year by a state Commonwealth Court judge based on its reliance on property taxes, which deprives lower-income schools of educational opportunities.

According to Duquesne’s 2023-24 budget, the district is expecting a total of $22.2 million in revenues, $2 million of which was from local funds, $16.8 million from the state and $3.3 million from federal dollars. Expenditures are expected to total $22 million and its fund balance totals $1.5 million.

The community’s tax base could soon see a boost after the Union Railroad Co. purchased 13 acres of land at the former Duquesne Works from the Regional Industrial Development Corp. for $400,000. The company plans to build a rail-to-truck and truck-to-rail transloading facility.

“That could potentially change the tax base of Duquesne for the future,” Ms. Mariani said. “And so we want to revisit this in the future if we can show that the long-term financial commitment by the district is solid.”

She added that officials with the education department did not “ask us one question” about the academic plan for high schoolers. She declined to go into detail about what that plan entails.

Advertise with us

Ms. Mariani said now the district is going to keep a watch on the budget and enrollments and “keep reevaluating every year until we can show that this is a viable option” for Duquesne.

“It's still a drive,” Ms. Mariani said. “It's still a drive of the administration of the faculty, and it's because of the students and the families. They believe in us, and they believe in what we're doing. And so we're not going to take this decision lying down, we're going to continue marching forward and try to find every avenue available to show a funding stream that is positive and will reflect the financial success of the district.”