More than 100 charter school students who live in the Penn Hills School District will take public transit this fall after district officials approved changes that will save nearly $411,000 in transportation costs.
In all, 145 students in sixth through 12th grade who attend Environmental Charter middle and high school, Propel Andrew Street High School, Propel Braddock Hills middle and high school, LIFE Male STEAM Academy and Westinghouse Arts Academy will be given a district-purchased bus pass to get to and from school starting in the 2024-25 school year.
Students in grades K-5 who attend those schools will continue to ride a district school bus, as well as those attending Penn Hills schools, more than 40 other charter and Catholic schools, and those enrolled in special education schools.
The district announced the changes last week.
“Ninety-seven percent of our students aren't going to experience a change. … There's always going to be, whenever there's change, some pushback from a smaller group of people, but the district is doing its best to get the information out there as early as we possibly can,” Sarah McCluan, spokeswoman for the Allegheny Intermediate Unit, which represents the district, said.
According to Ms. McCluan, discussions around transportation costs started in May when Penn Hills officially exited Pennsylvania’s financial recovery program. The district at the time was incurring higher transportation costs than most other Allegheny County schools, and in 2022 had spent $7.4 million to transport more than 3,000 students.
Because of that, Penn Hills conducted an analysis of all district bus routes with the goal of determining if any cost savings could occur from adjusting bus schedules.
Officials ultimately chose to outsource transportation for students at the seven schools, meaning that the number of bus routes operated by the district will drop from 92 to 87. The decision, officials also said, will help efficiently manage taxpayer funds while addressing the ongoing bus driver shortage.
Pennsylvania for the past few school years has been grappling with a shortage of school bus drivers, a problem exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, causing students to learn remotely or requiring parents to drive their children to school. Locally, some districts had issues providing busing for students attending charter and private schools as required by state law.
“They were able to essentially find a sweet spot, and this spot is where there is maximum savings, minimal disruptions and still has student safety at the forefront of everything,” Ms. McCluan said of the Penn Hills decision.
In all, K-12 students attending one of the district’s schools will ride a traditional school bus, operated by Krise Transportation. All students in grades K-5 will also ride a district bus regardless of if they attend a Penn Hills school or a charter school.
For sixth through 12th graders attending one of the impacted charter schools, monthly Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus passes will be distributed, which can be used to get to and from school and to attend events such as after-school activities or work. If a student in grades 6-12 has a younger sibling who rides the district bus, the older student may ride the bus with them.
Other districts, including Wilkinsburg, also use public transportation for charter school students.
But at Penn Hills, some parents are concerned about the changes.
Corinne Carroll’s 14-year-old daughter is going into her freshman year at Westinghouse Arts Academy this year. But the family recently found out she’d have to take a PRT bus.
“My initial reaction was, ‘I pay enough in taxes that even though my kid doesn't go to Penn Hills, my tax dollars should be going toward transporting my kid,’” Ms. Carroll said. She added that the changes are “an unfair way for the school district to save money.”
Ms. Carroll, who plans to attend the district’s next school board meeting, is now hoping “there’s enough stink blown about this” that the district will reverse the changes. In the meantime, she said her daughter has mixed feelings about the change.
“She’s excited but she’s really scared at the same time,” Ms. Carroll said.
More information on changes can be found on the district’s website. Officials are also planning a coffee and conversation event at 9:30 a.m. Friday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.