The Pine-Richland School Board on Monday tabled a potential review of a policy surrounding library books, a decision that came less than a month after some community members raised concerns about novels they deemed to be sexually explicit and obscene.
School directors unanimously voted to table further discussions around the policy that determines the procedure for when books are challenged until newly elected school board members are seated next month. At that point, the board can decide if they want to move forward with any changes.
“There are a number of legal issues that surround this policy that were discussed with our solicitor,” board president Greg DiTullio said during the meeting. “I think that information was very useful. I think at this point my opinion would be that there’s not anything to vote on. … This would be something the new board could tackle again with some of the legal information that we now have.”
Conversations around library books in the district started last month when a handful of residents questioned why certain novels such as “All Boys Aren’t Blue” by George M. Johnson, “The Handmaid’s Tale: The Graphic Novel” by Margaret Atwood and Renee Nault, and “Push” by Sapphire are available to students. The comments, which were met by applause from almost 50 people in attendance, suggested the books were inappropriate for high school students.
At the time, the district had received challenges to 13 books.
In response, school directors said they would look into how books are chosen for student access and reexamine the current policy. Because that process could take months, the board also planned to consider a resolution to notify parents if their child checks out a book that is going through the review process.
Those decisions will now be passed on to new board members. According to election results, Republicans largely swept the Pine-Richland School Board race during last week’s election, with four Republicans and one Democrat winning a seat on the nine person board.
Still, the decision to hold off on a vote was largely met with applause from several residents in attendance Monday night. Unlike last month’s meeting, many of the speakers on Monday were against removing books from the school library, suggesting that they need to represent everyone and that one group of people should not be able to make the choice for all parents about which books are appropriate. They also said passages can’t be “plucked from a book” without any context.
According to the American Library Association, there were 695 attempts to censor library materials nationally between Jan. 1 and Aug. 31 along with challenges to 1,915 unique titles. That’s a 20% increase from the same period last year, which saw the highest number of book challenges since the ALA started compiling the data more than 20 years ago. And of those challenges, the vast majority were books written by or about a person of color or a member of the LGBTQ community.
Nationally, the Scholastic Book Fair is separating dozens of books focused on race and LGBTQ themes, allowing elementary schools to decide if they want to offer or exclude the novels from book fairs. And across the country over the past few years lawmakers in Texas and South Carolina have called for investigations around “pornography” in schools while a Kansas district in 2021 froze library checkouts of 29 books including “The Handmaid’s Tale” and “The Bluest Eye” by Toni Morrison.
Locally, Hempfield Area School District in Westmoreland County revised its policy for selecting resource materials to require librarians to submit a public list of requested books and permit the public to voice any concerns about the titles before they can be purchased. The change came after a small group of parents challenged “All Boys Aren’t Blue,” which chronicles the author’s journey growing up as a queer Black man, and “The Black Friend: On Being a Better White Person” by Frederick Joseph, which discusses the author’s experiences with racism.
The Blackhawk School Board in Beaver County last month voted to amend their policy around library books to allow students and parents to “reject the use of resource materials that are incompatible with their values or fundamental religious beliefs,” the policy reads. It also specifies the process for how books will be reviewed, with a final determination on if a novel can remain in the school library made by the school board. It also includes definitions for child pornography and obscenity while describing how library books could be harmful to minors.
At Pine-Richland, it was not immediately clear if new board members would resume discussions around library books. In the meantime, any book challenges will follow the current policy that’s in place, which states that challenged materials will stay in circulation until the complaint is reviewed by a committee made up of community and staff members. The committee will then submit its recommendation to the superintendent, who can direct “questionable materials” be placed on a limited access shelf pending a final determination. The superintendent’s decision is final.
But since this is the first time in recent years the district has received a book challenge, a committee is not in place to review challenged materials. Mr. DiTullio said “things are being formed as per the policy” including the committee.
“The board has business to do with respect to this policy,” school director Marc Casciani said Monday. “The fact of the matter is the policy exists. Even though it needs to be tweaked a bit because it’s being tested it’s still a policy we can follow right now and we will do that.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.