No concerns were voiced during the first public review period of library books the Hempfield Area School District plans to purchase next week, a move that comes almost a month after school directors changed the district’s book policy.

The extensive list of books were placed on a 30-day review last month meaning that book titles, a short description of what it’s about and which school the book will be used in were listed on the district website. A separate form was provided where residents could submit any concerns about the books and how they might go against the district’s policy.

It was the first public review period after school directors in August passed several revisions to the district’s policy for selecting resource materials. The biggest change requires librarians to submit a public list of requested books and permit the public to voice any concerns about the titles before they can be purchased.

Superintendent Tammy Wolicki confirmed Friday that the district had not received any challenges to the books that will be purchased Monday.

Advertise with us

Amendments to the district’s policy came after a year-and-a-half debate about library books that was sparked after a small group of parents voiced concerns over what they called sexually explicit materials in the high school library.

Discussions started in March 2022 when the parents questioned “All Boys Aren’t Blue” by George M. Johnson, which chronicles the author’s journey growing up as a queer Black man. “The Black Friend: On Being a Better White Person” by Frederick Joseph was also challenged. The book discusses Mr. Joseph’s experiences with racism.

Since those initial challenges, the board’s policy committee has worked to create a plan that would satisfy parents with differing opinions while ensuring students have access to necessary materials.

Decisions made in August were the first major changes to the district’s policy since discussions started.

Under the updated policy, any concerns expressed about the listed titles would be reviewed by the librarian who submitted the book for purchase, the building principal, a subject area teacher and the assistant superintendent, the policy reads. The assistant superintendent would then share if the challenged books would be purchased.

Advertise with us

The resident who submitted a concern would be informed of the outcome and could proceed with an informal challenge process if they are not satisfied with the decision.

Other changes to the policy included defining sexual content as “offensive representations or descriptions of ultimate sexual acts, normal or perverted, actual or simulated,” as well as ethnic intimidation, the policy reads.

Titles that will now be purchased following the first review period include several children’s books such as “All Are Welcome” by Alexandra Penfold, which was questioned by a Norwin school director last year, along with bestsellers and award-winning novels.

Other books are listed for public review, including ones that will be purchased on Thursday as well as books that are being donated to the district.

A full list can be found on the district’s website.