A nearly four-hour Pine-Richland school board governance meeting Monday went over suggested changes to the district’s current library book acquisition policy, which was met with dissent from board and community members alike.

Policy 109.1 currently allows school librarians to select materials for the district’s libraries, which are then subject to the approval of the superintendent. Books can also be reconsidered through a complaint process through the school board, with the superintendent deciding whether the book is removed.

The proposal, referred to as a redline by board members, aims to have the school board select materials instead, as well as removing books with “sexually explicit content,” and other themes. Monday’s review sought to make changes to the proposal before being considered at a public board meeting.

But school board members and the community felt the redline was sprung on them, with some calling it a “political agenda.”

Advertise with us

Amy Terchick, vice president of the school board, said that the redline was completely out of left field. She added that the updated policy being written by only two board members, Michael Weithorn and Christina Brussalis, was distressing.

“I would also like to go back to the original policy. We had a lot of book challenges, it took some time, but when it was presented to us as a board no one spoke up and said it needed to be changed in April,” Mrs. Terchick continued. “This is an attempt to stifle dissenting members of the board’s speech…This is an abomination.”

The meeting used a different format than usual, going through the policy line-by-line and only allowing members to speak twice on each section, which created frustration among the board members.

Superintendent Brian Miller was in charge of reading 14 books during a months-long review process — the first time the process was used — to determine the appropriateness of the novels that were first challenged last October, when a group of community members pleaded with directors to remove books from school libraries they deemed to be sexually explicit and obscene. Mr. Miller ultimately ruled in April that the books will remain in the district’s libraries.

Mr. Miller said Monday that the redline did not follow the typical protocol for policy changes, which involves a thorough review by senior leadership and staff members who have subject matter expertise, and that he felt the proposed changes raise “significant concerns.”

Advertise with us

“I do not understand, without fully knowing where this came from, what the intention is,” he continued. “There are plenty of books that are Pine-Richland approved that do not comply with this policy and I struggle big time in terms of implementation. What I do understand is the value of some of those works to our student body and for optional reading in the library.”

Mr. Wiethorn, who board members said is responsible for writing a majority of the redline, said that every school board in Pennsylvania has the authority over what materials come into the district, and that previously, the board did not have any say in what came in.

“This policy puts the power back in the board as it is under the commonwealth rules,” he continued.

As the night went on, multiple members of the board tried to amend language that felt limiting, as well as taking away the board’s proposed authority over the selection process. One section said that libraries should provide “age appropriate” content for each student, which some board members felt was not inclusive.

Board member Ashley Fortier tried to change the language, asking Eden Hall Upper Elementary librarian Elizabeth Shenefiel what she thought. Mrs. Shenefiel agreed it needs to work for each student.

Advertise with us

“We cannot determine what is age appropriate for every single parent in our district, we can only say what is relevant to our students, what we see from knowing our patrons,” Mrs. Shenefiel said. “We cannot determine what a parent deems age appropriate for their child.”

Finally, almost three hours into reviewing a portion of the proposed redline, the board decided to pause and move on to public comment. They did not announce a date to finish the review.

Brianna Bear, of Richland, said during public comment that the board reviewing the library policy was “absurd,” considering that the district had multiple threats and had to go into lockdown last week.

“The timing for your performative nonsense could not be worse,” she continued. “We’ve had multiple school safety issues in the last two weeks and those teachers who kept the students calm through those horrible hours are now 85 days without a contract, yet here you are playing political games. Our kids and district deserve better. The books are not the threat here today, you are.”

Community member Scott Gigari talked about how he worked in the last school board election where people were voting on the topic of book bans. He claimed that after showing voters what books were inside the district’s libraries that they supported the ban.

Advertise with us

“I can tell you the people are against these just grotesque books in our libraries,” he continued. “The community is not for this garbage. When the community realizes what's in these books, they’ll be behind what this board is doing.”

A parent of two students at Pine-Richland, Sarah Irwin, said that the way the meeting was held was an attempt to stifle other board members. She further said the board has been “hijacked by extremists attempting to push their political, religious and ideological views on our community and our students.”

“The vast majority of parents do not agree with what you’re trying to do with the library policy,” she continued. “Pine-Richland parents do not want incompetent, unqualified elected officials to decide what books can be in our libraries and our classrooms. They [the board] seem to be actively ignoring the wants and needs of parents and students, and the expertise of hired professionals.”