Allegheny County Common Pleas Senior Judge Lester G. Nauhaus is described as sensitive and caring. He also can be unpredictable and demeaning.

He is diligent in defending individual constitutional rights and takes pride in the defendants who complete his drug court program. But he is also known to berate attorneys and made former state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin pose in handcuffs to be photographed as part of her punishment for a corruption conviction.

Everyone agrees on one thing: the judge speaks his mind.

Today, the question of whether he spoke improperly regarding a case before him will be scrutinized by his colleague. Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning will preside over a hearing to determine if Judge Nauhaus engaged in improper conduct involving the criminal case of former county councilman Chuck McCullough, who was represented by Jon Pushinsky in a nonjury trial earlier this year.

Advertise with us

Megan Will, who now represents the former councilman, filed a motion asking Judge Nauhaus to remove himself from her client’s sentencing scheduled for last week. In it, she alleged, among other issues, that the judge relayed to Mr. Pushinsky through a mutual friend that he should ask for a nonjury trial. Ms. Will claimed that her client wanted a jury trial, but he relented for fear he would be punished if he didn’t follow the wishes of the judge.

She alleges Mr. McCullough was denied due process, and that the allegations against Judge Nauhaus are sufficient to establish bias, prejudice and/or unfairness which warrant his recusal.

The prosecution, which requested the hearing, said that if no improper communications occurred, then Judge Nauhaus should remain on Mr. McCullough’s case and handle his sentencing on the 10 criminal counts for which he was found guilty.

•••

Judge Nauhaus, who did not respond for comment, joined the public defender's office in 1972 and took over as head in 1978. He remained in that position until being appointed to a seat on the Common Pleas bench in October 1994. He ran for his own 10-year seat a year later, but lost in the general election. He ran again in 1997 and won.

Advertise with us

Judge Nauhaus, 72, is known for doing the unexpected.

In the Melvin case, the state Superior Court threw out the requirement for the former justice to send the photographs to judges across Pennsylvania, finding that its purpose was to humiliate her. The apology letters, however, were deemed to be an acceptable part of an attempt to rehabilitate her.

“That was classic Lester. It was justice. It was rough justice,” said Bruce Ledewitz, a law professor at Duquesne University and colleague and friend of the judge. “It was unusual. It had all the earmarks of his creativity and was not something other judges would do. He was always a maverick. Lester is a guy who would rather be right than correct.”

Mr. Ledewitz was hired by Judge Nauhaus in 1979 when he was at the Allegheny County Public Defender’s office. He remembers his first conversation with him.

“’I can’t hire anybody who isn’t an attorney in Pennsylvania and wasn’t approved by [county commissioner] Tom Foerster,’” Judge Nauhaus told him. “Then he looks at me and says, ‘Oh, what the hell.’”

Advertise with us

•••

During his retention campaign in 2007, Judge Nauhaus faced a challenge from city of Pittsburgh police officers, who led a movement against him.

Retired Pittsburgh police Lt. Bill Mathias served as a spokesman for the effort because he did not regularly appear in court.

It started out as an impromptu effort by narcotics detectives and sergeants who were frustrated that Judge Nauhaus often suppressed evidence that they felt should have been admitted in their cases.

The effort gained momentum, Lt. Mathias said, receiving donations from members of the district attorney’s office, some defense lawyers and even other judges.

Advertise with us

Lt. Mathias was willing to help in the effort, he said, because of his own interactions with Judge Nauhaus. In 1994, while in the police academy, Lt. Mathias said Judge Nauhaus, then still in the PD’s office, taught a law class to the recruits. The first thing he said when he walked in was, “’How are all my little piglets doing?’”

“We’d come in, and he’d berate us and tell us how stupid we all were,” Lt. Mathias said.

As a young recruit, Lt. Mathias felt there was nothing he could do about it. But later, during the retention campaign, he was happy to help, especially given what he’d seen of Judge Nauhaus on the bench. The judge would cross-examine the officers during their testimony if he thought the defense attorney didn’t do a good enough job.

Lt. Mathias felt Judge Nauhaus was biased against the prosecution and police officers.

But Paul Boas, a long-time Pittsburgh defense attorney, said that Judge Nauhaus doesn’t show bias -- he’s just being fair.

Advertise with us

“In my opinion, there are a lot of judges who are prosecutorially oriented. I firmly believe there are no defense-oriented judges. There are fair judges.”

Mr. Boas called Judge Nauhaus an “intellectually honest judge,” who is not results-oriented.

“He had the guts to make a call even if it wasn’t particularly popular,” he said.

Mr. Ledewitz agreed, saying he would be shocked if Judge Nauhaus was involved in anything like case fixing.

“I’ve never hear a word uttered about Lester Nauhaus’ integrity,” he said. “It would be utterly inconceivable.”

Advertise with us

Judge Nauhaus served in the criminal division until 2010 when he was moved to orphans’ court and has since returned to criminal court.

William Pietragallo, who practices civil law, befriended Judge Nauhaus more than 15 years ago as part of a group who met for coffee every morning at Oxford Centre.

“I came to see him as a very caring, sensitive person, which was not consistent with what I thought the public perception of his demeanor was.”

The group talks about sports and politics, legal issues and family.

“He could be quick with a barb -- don’t get me wrong.”

Advertise with us

He called Judge Nauhaus a “die-hard Democrat,” who is true to his political faith. Others said that he is devoted to upholding the rights guaranteed in the Constitution.

Judge Nauhaus, who took senior status on the bench when he turned 70, is described as smart and savvy, funny with a dry sense of humor.

“Some of our best judges are characters. They don’t just sit there passively and cerebrally,” Mr. Ledewitz said. “There’s room, especially in criminal court, for judges who impose their personality on the courtroom, and I think our best judges are like that.”

But others question Judge Nauhaus’ temperament, though most declined to comment for this article.

“He’s unpredictable. You never know what’s going to set him off,” said one attorney who asked not to be named for fear of repercussions.

Advertise with us

The judge is supposed to be an umpire — just call balls and strikes --  he said, but Judge Nauhaus doesn’t do that. Defendants leaving the room don’t feel like they’ve received justice.

“He interferes with the lawyers,” he said. “If you have a jury there, you can’t argue with him because you’re always going to be wrong.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.