The Allegheny County district attorney’s office has asked for a hearing to determine whether improper conversations occurred between former county Councilman Chuck McCullough’s defense attorney and the judge who presided over his criminal case.

In a petition filed Thursday, the prosecution asked that the issue be heard by someone other than Common Pleas Judge Lester G. Nauhaus, who was identified in a defense petition filed last week as having improperly communicated with Mr. McCullough’s former defense attorney, Jon Pushinsky.

“Judge Nauhaus is either a witness as they’ve alleged or he’s complicit in a crime,” District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said. “Either way, he can’t sit as a finder of fact in an evidentiary hearing.”

Two DA investigators attempted to contact Mr. Pushinsky on Thursday to speak with him about the allegations raised by Mr. McCullough’s new defense attorney, Megan Will, but he refused to speak with them, citing attorney-client privilege. He cited the same reason in saying he could not comment for this report. He did say, though, “If I am required to appear as a witness, and there is a full waiver of client privilege, I will be required to answer proper questions.”

Advertise with us

Mr. McCullough, who was accused of taking money from an elderly widow whom he represented, was found guilty on 10 of 24 counts against him in a nonjury trial earlier this year before Judge Nauhaus. He was supposed to have been sentenced Monday, but Ms. Will, who was hired by Mr. McCullough on Nov. 3, has asked Judge Nauhaus to remove himself from the case.

In her petition, she alleged that Judge Nauhaus relayed to Mr. Pushinsky through a mutual friend that Mr. McCullough “should go nonjury” in his trial. Further, Ms. Will wrote that Judge Nauhaus called Mr. Pushinsky and yelled at him after he filed a petition with the court, and that the judge improperly talked about the case with his secretary. In each instance, she claimed, the communication occurred outside of the prosecution’s hearing, making it an ex-parte communication.

Ms. Will said that the judge’s behavior forced Mr. McCullough to give up his right to a jury trial because he feared the repercussions if he did not.

“A reasonable interpretation of the petition was that a crime was going to be committed,” Mr. Zappala said. “They’re alleging that a case was going to be fixed.”

According to the district attorney’s motion, although the commonwealth may have doubts about the allegations, the allegations alone “tend to subject the Allegheny County judiciary to disrepute.” Therefore, a hearing — before a different judge — is necessary.

Advertise with us

The motion contends there is no reason at this time for Judge Nauhaus to recuse himself from Mr. McCullough’s sentencing, particularly if the defense cannot prove the ex-parte communications occurred.

“Assuming that the presiding judge finds no merit to the accusations, this court can then preside over sentencing. A defendant should not be permitted to ‘judge shop’ by making false claims of judicial misconduct,” the motion said.

In addition to asking for an evidentiary hearing, Mr. Zappala said, his office has referred the matter to the state Judicial Conduct Board. A message to the chief counsel there was not returned.

Charles Geyh, an expert in judicial ethics at the Maurer School of Law at Indiana University, said if the communications as alleged in Ms. Will’s petition are true, they were inappropriate.

Improper, one-way conversations outside of the presence of the opponent can reflect bias on the part of the judge, Mr. Geyh said, and could show a judge trying to affect the results of a case behind the scenes.

Advertise with us

“In bad cases, it can reflect corruption where a judge is trying to fix a result,” he said.

Regarding the suggestion that the case go nonjury, Mr. Geyh said, “One is left to wonder why. That creates the perception the judge is more invested in the result than makes sense. That gives rise to speculation of what the judge’s motives are.

“It is something that is concerning.”

During Monday’s hearing, Judge Nauhaus challenged Ms. Will’s assessment of what she considered to be “ex-parte communications,” saying that assistant district attorney John Fitzgerald was not complaining about them.

“He's the party that should be complaining,” the judge said.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Geyh said that whether the party excluded from the communication objects or not is irrelevant.

“The party who doesn’t object may not want to anger the judge by objecting,” Mr. Geyh said.

As for Mr. Pushinsky’s situation, the professor said, had he ignored a judge’s direction to go nonjury, he then is “doing something directly contrary to what the judge has asked, and it could irritate the judge or compromise any jury trial.”

“It forces the lawyer into an awkward situation of confronting the judge who’s deciding his client’s fate. I understand the lawyer’s reticence to buck the judge. The consequences for his client could be adverse.”

Judge Nauhaus, who has a reputation for being unpredictable to both parties before him, recently presided over the criminal trial of former state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin. She was convicted by a jury, and Judge Nauhaus issued the unorthodox sentence of ordering her to be photographed in handcuffs and to send letters of apology to judges across Pennsylvania. She also received three years of house arrest.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania Superior Court overturned the photograph provision of the sentence, finding it was intended to humiliate her, but upheld the requirement to write the apologies.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.