The new attorney for former Allegheny County councilman Chuck McCullough, who was found guilty of 10 criminal counts over the summer, accused the judge in the case of making improper statements and has asked him to remove himself.

Megan Will’s motion, filed Friday, delayed Mr. McCullough’s sentencing scheduled for today. It is now slated for Dec. 17.

The prosecution has asked Common Pleas Judge Lester G. Nauhaus to sentence Mr. McCullough to five to 10 years in prison, although sentencing guidelines in the standard range call for either probation or up to nine to 18 months incarceration. The district attorney’s sentencing memorandum suggests that Mr. McCullough ought to be given consecutive sentences for each count because of the nature of his offense -- taking money from an elderly, widowed client, and giving it to campaign funds.

The defense is seeking recusal and if granted, a sentencing hearing before a different judge.

Advertise with us

Ms. Will, who joined the defense case on Nov. 3, accused Judge Nauhaus of having two improper, ex-parte communications regarding Mr. McCullough’s charges in the past — both prior to trial and during it.

An ex parte conversation, which is prohibited, is one in which one party to the case is not present.

Ms. Will included one claim that the judge called Mr. McCullough's trial attorney, Jon Pushinsky, on Dec. 29 and scolded him for filing a court petition; and another claim that the judge told a mutual friend of the defense attorney, "tell Pushinsky to go non-jury," in Mr. McCullough's case.

Mr. Pushinsky declined comment. Ms. Will said in her motion that Mr. Pushinsky would not identify the mutual friend but would if called to testify.

Ms. Will wrote that her client never wanted to give up his right to a jury trial, but that he feared repercussions from Judge Nauhaus if he didn’t follow what he said.

Advertise with us

In addition, Ms. Will wrote that before the defense began presenting evidence in its case, an acquaintance of Mr. McCullough, who is familiar with courthouse staff, said that he spoke with someone in the courthouse who knows Judge Nauhaus' secretary and that the judge "was of the mind that the case was not proven by the prosecution, but after a conversation between he and his secretary, they agreed that a conviction of the five counts dealing with the checks had to occur."

Ms. Will did not identify the acquaintance in her motion, but wrote that if forced to testify, the acquaintance would identify the source of his information.

Mr. McCullough was convicted on 10 counts, including theft and misapplication of funds, but.Judge Nauhaus found him not guilty of eight other counts and dismissed six more.

During the brief hearing Monday morning, Judge Nauhaus asked Ms. Will to explain how the examples she cited were ex parte, given that assistant district attorney John Fitzgerald was not complaining about them.

"He's the party that should be complaining," the judge said.

Advertise with us

"I believe they were materially impacting this case," Ms. Will said. "Your honor, this was occurring while trial was ongoing."

After the hearing, district attorney’s spokesman Mike Manko issued a statement on the matter, saying the defense motion raises “serious legal implications for the judge, the defendant's former attorney and the defendant, himself.

“A fair reading of the arguments, if true, as alleged by the defendant, establishes that the people of this commonwealth were to be denied a fair and objective forum to determine the accused’s criminal culpability in such a serious matter — the financial exploitation and abuse of a 90 year old woman.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.