Former Allegheny County Councilman Chuck McCullough arrived at Pittsburgh Municipal Court about 10:45 Friday morning to be arraigned on seven criminal counts.

The new charges, which include false swearing, obstruction of justice, unsworn falsification and perjury, stem from Mr. McCullough’s waiver of a jury trial given April 13 before Common Pleas Judge Lester G. Nauhaus. Mr. McCullough had said no “promises or threats” were made to him to waive that right and proceed with a bench trial.

According to a partial transcript of the proceedings included in the new criminal complaint, Mr. McCullough said his signed jury trial waiver was a “product of [his] own free will.”

Later, Judge Nauhaus asked him, “Have there been any promises or threats made to you in order to have you waive your right to a jury trial?”

Advertise with us

“No, your honor,” Mr. McCullough answered.

Using that waiver as the basis for the new charges, the criminal complaint alleges that Mr. McCullough's motion to recuse Judge Nauhaus, filed Nov. 6, refutes his earlier sworn statements.

In the motion to recuse, Mr. McCullough alleged that Judge Nauhaus relayed through a mutual friend of Mr. McCullough’s former defense attorney Jon Pushinsky “to go nonjury.”

Mr. McCullough claimed he wanted a jury trial but relented for fear of reprisal from the judge. After the bench trial, he was found guilty of 10 of 24 charges related to the theft and misapplication of entrusted property of a woman he represented and is to be sentenced by Judge Nauhaus Dec. 17.

In his recusal petition, Mr. McCullough signed a verification page that said he declared the statements and documents “are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief and are made subject to the penalties related to unsworn falsifications to authorities.”

Advertise with us

Mr. McCullough is scheduled to have a preliminary hearing Dec. 3. The two counts of perjury are felonies; the others are misdemeanors.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.