An expert in judicial ethics in Pennsylvania said that the entire evidentiary hearing on former Allegheny County Councilman Chuck McCullough’s petition to remove the judge on his case was handled improperly.
“All I can tell you is — wow. If that’s how they conduct business in Pittsburgh, that’s not how it’s done in the other Pennsylvania counties,” said Sam Stretton, who practices in West Chester and Philadelphia and writes and lectures on legal ethics. “I have never heard of anything like that before in my life.”
In the first place, Mr. Stretton said, Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning should not have presided over the evidentiary hearing involving his friend and colleague, Common Pleas Senior Judge Lester G. Nauhaus.
“It doesn’t sound right. It has the appearance that something was amiss written all over it,” he said. “It would have been better to call in an out-of-county judge. I would have recused myself on my own.”
Further, he said, Judge Nauhaus should have been ordered to testify — not as the sitting judge on Mr. McCullough’s case but as a fact witness.
“I don’t know any rule that would prohibit a judge from testifying regarding [alleged] illegal conduct,” Mr. Stretton said.
Read More
Regarding lawyer Jon Pushinsky refusing to testify without a full waiver of attorney-client privilege by Mr. McCullough, Mr. Stretton said that waiver was not necessary.
If Mr. Pushinsky had conversations with Judge Nauhaus, “that would not be privileged, plus it would be illegal, so there's no privilege whatsoever.”
As for questions between Mr. Pushinsky and Mr. McCullough, they could have been asked one by one to establish if privilege applied.
Mr. Stretton also said that it was “ridiculous” that Judge Manning permitted Martin Schmotzer, who was called as a witness to answer the question of who provided him information about alleged conversations between Judge Nauhaus and his secretary, not to answer.
“He’s got to answer it,” he said. If not, he should have been found to be in contempt of court.
“The DA is dropping the ball by not forcing the issue,” Mr. Stretton said.
But he also noted that Mr. McCullough and his attorney failed to push the issues with the court or present any other evidence, including calling Judge Nauhaus’ secretary, who was sworn in at the beginning of the hearing.
“Why they didn’t call the secretary is beyond me.”


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.