Heather McCandless and Eleanor Tourney can each pinpoint the moments in which their tragedies began — when the two mothers, strangers to each other at the time, each lost a child in the same senseless crash.
Jonathan Tourney, 14, and Taylor Orlowski, 18, both died early Dec. 23, 2023, when they were thrown from a car in a high-speed crash.
The moment Aiden Saber stomped the gas of his mother’s Land Rover as he and five friends left a late-night trip to North Park — and when he ignored a friend’s pleas to slow down, telling him “I got it” — set into motion a tragedy that reached its courtroom conclusion Monday but continues with no end in sight for the family and friends of the teens.
The violent crash that followed tore the SUV in two and threw Taylor and Jonathan from the car. Collision experts estimated the car was going more than 70 mph when Saber lost control on the slight curve on Irwin Road.
Saber, now 19, pleaded guilty Monday to homicide by vehicle and involuntary manslaughter in return for a sentence of 2½ to 5 years in state prison.
Common Pleas Judge Kelly Bigley wept as she listened to family and friends of Taylor and Jonathan describe the pain of the loss, and she wept as she formally sentenced Saber to another four years of probation once he is released from prison.
Read More
“It’s always easier when there’s a bad guy,” she said.
But none of it was that cut and dry, she said.
She called Saber “a stupid 18-year-old kid who made bad decisions that were so catastrophic it is indescribable.”
She continued: “I always feel bad when people ask me to see that justice is served. I don’t know how often I’ve served justice when I’ve sat up here. These two young kids …”
She trailed off and wiped her eyes.
“It’s just so horribly tragic,” Judge Bigley said. “Just knowing I can never bring justice unless I bring your family member home. Nothing I ever do can really be justice. Justice would be that it never happened.”
‘I will never forgive you’
For Ms. McCandless, the moment the tragedy began came as the sun rose Dec. 23. A man in a suit knocked on her door.
“He said, ‘I’m sorry, there has been an accident,’ ” Ms. McCandless said. “And my life forever changed in that moment in time.”
Taylor, an accomplished equestrian, died at the scene.
It began with a late-night phone call for Eleanor Tourney. The first was from a social worker telling her that he older son, Jeffrey, was at Allegheny General Hospital. A second call came: Her younger son, 14-year-old Jonathan, was on his way to Children’s Hospital. As she headed there, yet another call came directing her to UPMC Passavant.
Ms. Tourney said the paramedics outside the emergency department kept their heads low when she asked about her son. She was ushered to a small room where she was eventually met by a doctor.
“He had tears in his eyes,” she said. “All he had to say was, ‘I’m sorry.’ I lost my mind.”
Jonathan, who initially had survived the crash and lay cradled in his big brother’s arms on the North Park hillside until medics arrived, died during the medical helicopter ride to Children’s Hospital.
Ms. Tourney described identifying her son’s body and holding his hand for three hours before she made the difficult decision to donate his organs. He lives on through corneas and heart valves that have brought sight and life to others, she said.
Both mothers described the exact moments the tragedy began for their families. But, each said in her own way, there is no end. There never will be.
“I struggle now knowing that I will never get to see Taylor fall in love, get married, or have children of her own,” Ms. McCandless wept. “I will never get the chance to go wedding dress shopping with her or hold my grandkids.”
Speaking directly to Saber, she told him: “I will never forgive you for taking that opportunity not only from Taylor, but from me as well.”
Ms. Tourney said she’s clung to existence for the sake of her older son, Jeffrey, who survived the crash. Their lives since then, she said, have been unbearable.
“I hope your hear their voices — ‘slow down’ — in your head forever,” she told Saber. “You took two lives and ruined many more.”
Indeed, tragedies don’t remain contained. They ripple outward, in this case evidenced by a courtroom so full the Saber family had to be seated in the jury box. Friends of both teens wrote letters or told Judge Bigley of the pain left in the wake of Taylor’s and Jonathan’s deaths. More than a half-dozen others submitted letters on Saber’s behalf, too.
Taylor was Katie Finley’s first best friend. They met at the stables and they became, in Ms. Findley’s words, like sisters. She said Taylor was the person she “associated with pure joy and excitement.”
“For a while, I did not want to be on Earth without her,” she told Judge Bigley, appearing in the courtroom via video feed.
They talked about being bridesmaids at each other’s weddings, and they had “every conversation under the sun,” Ms. Findley said. She said it pained her to know she would never meet her best friend’s children or watch her fall in love.
Saber’s aunt, Donna Nickel, read a letter on behalf of her family. She said her nephew was always known for his impish grin and his love of family.
“We could not be more proud of how he has handled himself in the aftermath of this terrible accident,” Ms. Nickel told Judge Bigley, saying that he has taken full ownership and responsibility for what happened.
“My nephew would have never intentionally caused anyone harm,” she said.
Saber, too, told the judge he takes responsibility for his actions that night.
“I stand before you today fully aware of the gravity of my actions and the unimaginable pain I have caused,” he read, weeping throughout his statement.
“As I move forward, I want to respect the memory of Jonathan and Taylor by living a life of responsibility, compassion and integrity,” he said. “I know that I can never make up for all the pain and sadness I’ve caused.”
Judge Bigley told Saber that’s the only way he can make something out of the tragedy — to live a life of purpose.
She said she understands the rage felt by the families of Taylor and Jonathan, and she understands that some, in their anger, don’t want Saber to have that kind of life. But she said she thought Taylor and Jonathan might feel otherwise.
“Otherwise,” she said, “this really was nothing but a complete waste.”
“I’ll do what I can to see that justice is served,” Judge Bigley told the families. “In this case, I just don’t know.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.