The prosecutor warned the families of Jonathan Tourney and Taylor Orlowski before the hearing even started.
One of the first things he’d do, Allegheny County Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray told them quietly on Friday, was read the autopsy reports.
After a beat, most chose to leave the room.
Those who stayed wept quietly as Mr. Kiray read aloud the litany of injuries that ultimately killed the two teens, both of whom were thrown from a car during a violent crash in North Park last year.
In the front of the courtroom in Pittsburgh Municipal Court on Friday, Aiden Saber, the 18-year-old driver of the car, stood quietly next to his attorney.
“He just seems lost — he’s just a deer in the headlights,” defense attorney Casey White said of his client, who has pleaded not guilty. “He’s depressed. He’s scared. He’s nervous. I’m not sure what adjectives to use but I mean, he’s an 18-year-old young man that’s sitting in the Allegheny County Jail. His best friend’s younger brother passed away and another young lady passed away.
Read More
“He’s just an emotional wreck,” he said.
Jonathan, 14, and Taylor, 18, didn’t know each other before that night. Taylor had only just met the group of teenage boys, all of whom attended or recently graduated from Pine-Richland. The happenstance of a typical teenage Friday night put them both in Mr. Saber’s SUV about 3:20 a.m.
Mr. Saber is charged with homicide by vehicle and involuntary manslaughter in connection with their deaths. He’s also charged with aggravated assault charges for the injuries his other friends suffered when the Land Rover he was driving careened around a bend in North Park.
At the preliminary hearing Friday, Mr. Kiray moved to withdraw one of those aggravated assault charges. Jeffrey Tourney, one of Mr. Saber’s best friends, suffered only some cuts and bruises in the crash — injuries not sufficient to rise to aggravated assault.
Mr. Tourney testified for the prosecution during Mr. Saber’s preliminary hearing. He told District Judge Lisa V. Caulfield that he’d known Mr. Saber for most of his life, but they’d only become close in high school
The drive to North Park likely took less than 15 minutes from the Tourney home in Richland, where the teens were gathered. They were headed specifically toward Irwin Road, a short offshoot from Babcock Boulevard that leads into North Park. It eventually dead-ends and becomes a trail about a half-mile up the hill.
Mr. Tourney said the group went to try to give Taylor, who lived in Baden, a little scare. Urban legends vary — some say Irwin Road itself is haunted, and others say there are haunted houses along the trail.
Regardless, they’d all piled into Mr. Saber’s Land Rover in the middle of the night Dec. 23 to walk the trails. It was relatively warm — about 43 degrees around 3 a.m. It hadn’t snowed in days.
They’d only met Taylor earlier that night, just a few hours before the deadly crash.
The boys had been hanging out in the parking lot of the Sheetz in Wexford. Matthew Nicely had driven them there in his Chevy Silverado, Mr. Tourney said. Mr. Saber was there, too. They got to Sheetz about 10:30 p.m. after they’d picked up their little brothers from a nearby skating rink. Zach Nicely and Jonathan Tourney were both 14. They played football together.
Taylor, too, was hanging with friends at Sheetz. She was a talented equestrian. She’d graduated from Ambridge High School where she’d taken online classes.
The boys from Pine-Richland exchanged numbers with Taylor before they headed back to the Tourney home about midnight, Mr. Tourney told the judge. One of them texted Taylor to come over. She did, and they hung out in the garage, drinking and listening to music — but not too loudly, Mr. Tourney said.
He said Mr. Saber had two Busch Lights, but he didn’t seem intoxicated — “not at all,” he testified. In fact, none of his friends seemed drunk, he said, and Taylor didn’t have anything to drink.
Investigators said blood drawn from Mr. Saber when he was taken to Allegheny General Hospital after the crash showed a blood-alcohol content of .047%: about half the legal limit if he’d been over 21, but more than twice the legal limit of .02% allowable for anyone under 21.
Mr. Tourney said they parked as far up Irwin Road as they could drive and then piled out and onto the trail. He said they walked for about 45 minutes without finding the haunted house they were looking for, and so they headed back to the car.
Mr. Saber drove them to the trail with no problem, Mr. Tourney said, and Mr. Saber was going to drive them back. Mr. Tourney said that as soon as his friend pulled onto the road, he started speeding.
“I felt that I was in danger,” he testified.
He told him to, “slow down, slow down,” but Mr. Saber kept telling him, “I got it, I got.”
Seconds later, the relatively straight road turned into a bend, Mr. Tourney said. His friend couldn’t make the turn, and the car slammed into an oak tree and then rolled at least once before it landed right-side up on the other side of the road.
He said the impact basically tore the car in half.
An accident reconstruction expert from the Allegheny County Police Department who testified after Mr. Tourney confirmed the damage to the car. Detective Alexander Durrani said the front end of the SUV was perpendicular to Irwin Road. The rear end, all but detached from the rest of the car, was parallel to the road.
County police Officer David Hyland was among the first officers on the scene. He said it initially looked like there were multiple vehicles involved. The Land Rover was “pretty messed up,” he said.
It was a chaotic scene, Officer Hyland said. Taylor was on the ground about 10 yards from what remained of the SUV. A teen that Mr. Tourney later identified as Zach Nicely was on the ground by her. He was conscious and breathing, the officer said. Taylor was not.
By that point, Mr. Tourney, too, had checked on Taylor and the younger Nicely, he said. He said he checked Taylor for a pulse. He couldn’t find one.
“She didn’t seem like she was breathing,” he said. “I knew I had to move on and check on Zach.”
Finding Zach alive but in pain, Mr. Tourney told him: “Stay there, keep breathing and keep talking.” Then, he went to look for his brother.
He found him about 20 yards away on the hillside next to the road. He was still alive.
“I set him on my lap and held him and told him it was going to be OK,” Mr. Tourney said.
The teen died on the medical helicopter on the way to Children’s Hospital.
Detective Duranni said yaw marks on the road painted a picture of an SUV that was speeding and lost control. Yaw marks are tire tracks left when a tire is still rolling but also sliding at the same time. The detective’s analysis of the yaw marks indicated that the Land Rover was going at minimum 72 mph as it made the first yaw marks.
There is no posted speed limit on Irwin Road. State law dictates that, since it’s in a residential area, the speed limit is automatically 25 mph.
Patrick Kinavy, the lead detective in the case, said the road was littered with gouge marks.
“It was one of the most unique scenes that I’ve seen,” he said.
Aside from the withdrawn aggravated assault charge, Judge Caulfield held all other charges for trial. Mr. Saber has been held without bail since his March 11 arrest. Mr. White said he plans to try to get a judge to set bail for the teen.
“It’s another sad chapter in this sad, tragic story — the loss of two young lives and another young man is in the Allegheny County Jail,” Mr. White said after the hearing. “There are no victories. Even though there’s a charge withdrawn, still, there are no victories.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.