A judge on Thursday refused to set bail for a Richland teen facing homicide-by-vehicle charges connected to a violent and deadly crash last year, marking the second time a Common Pleas judge has ruled 18-year-old Aiden Saber should remain behind bars pending trial.
Mr. Saber’s defense attorney, Casey White, and Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray had agreed on bail conditions more than a month ago, but Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski denied the request for bail. At the time, the judge ordered Mr. Saber to undergo a mental health evaluation.
On Thursday, Common Pleas Judge Kelly Bigley cited no substantial changes in the case in her decision to deny bail, despite assurances from Mr. Saber’s mom that she would supervise him if he was let out on electronic monitoring.
The decision came after the court heard testimony from the parents of 14-year-old Jonathan Tourney, Mr. Saber’s best friend’s little brother, and 18-year-old Taylor Orlowski, whom he had only met that night, both of whom were killed in the Dec. 23 crash on the edge of North Park.
Heather McCandless, Taylor’s mother, urged the judge to deny Mr. Saber’s bail and the opportunity for him to return home and be with his family while he awaits trial.
“My daughter no longer has those opportunities,” Ms. McCandless said.
Read More
Ms. McCandless said, in the wake of the fatal crash, she has been writing to her daughter in a journal she has now keeps.
“You took my whole world away from me,” she said to Mr. Saber in court.
Ms. McCandless also read a letter in court penned by Taylor’s father, Donnie Orlowski, who said the news of his daughter’s death left him in shambles.
“It eats me alive everyday,” the letter read.
After the court heard testimony from Taylor’s parents, Jonathan Tourney’s mother, Eleanor Tourney, read a statement to the court she held in a bright green binder adorned with photos of her son, telling the court that both she and her elder son, Jeffrey Tourney — who held his brother while awaiting a LifeFlight helicopter — have struggled with PTSD and flashbacks since the crash.
“Our lives have been unbearable since,” she said.
Following testimony from the victims’ families, Mr. Saber’s mother, Karen Saber, testified that she would supervise her son “24/7” and work from home if he were to be released on electronic monitoring.
She added that her son did not leave the house, except to go to the gym with his brother, in the months between the crash and his arrest, but Judge Bigley ultimately sided with Judge Borkowski’s previous decision to deny bail.
“I’m sitting here and nothing has changed at all,” Judge Bigley said of the circumstances considered in Mr. Saber’s potential release from jail.
The case is scheduled to return to court for a pretrial conference on June 7.
Investigators allege Mr. Saber was doing about 70 mph as he sped down Irwin Road, away from North Park, shortly before 3:30 a.m. When he couldn’t maneuver the car around a bend, the SUV slammed into a tree and threw Taylor and Jonathan from the car.
Taylor was pronounced dead at the scene. Jonathan died en route via LifeFlight to Children’s Hospital.
Three others were also in the car: Matthew Nicely and his younger brother, Zach, and Jonathan’s older brother, Jeffrey.
In his motion requesting bail for his teenage client, Mr. White noted that Mr. Kiray had already said in open court that he could not “in good conscience” ask that the judge continue to deny bail.
Indeed, according to a transcript of the initial bail hearing March 11, Mr. Kiray told the judge that Mr. Saber had known the charges were coming for some time, did not try to flee, and turned himself in within hours of the charges being filed by Allegheny County Police.
“There is no way in good faith I could say to the court I believe he poses a danger of flight,” he said, according to the transcript.
Judge Borkowski denied the bail modification three days later, pointing to the factors involved in the incident: Mr. Saber’s blood alcohol level, his alleged excessive speed and the fact the crash happened at 3:20 a.m. He also noted that the county’s pretrial services — the arm of the court that makes recommendations to judges regarding bond — recommended Mr. Saber remain in the Allegheny County Jail pending trial.
“Defendant consciously disregarded pleas of passengers to slow down, all of which indicate poor judgment by defendant, poor impulse control, and lack of appropriate supervision at the proposed [electronic home monitoring] site,” Judge Borkowski wrote.
But Mr. White argued that the events leading up to the crash — including the alcohol consumption — didn’t happen at Mr. Saber’s home. He said Mr. Saber’s mother would see to it that her son complied with any bail conditions, which Mr. White suggested include a prohibition on driving and on consuming alcohol coupled with electronic monitoring.
“Although this case involves an undeniable and incredibly tragic set of circumstances, even the commonwealth agreed that Mr. Saber should be released pending trial,” Mr. White said. “The high-profile and grave outcome of that day must be placed in the context that this was not an intentional act but was rather the result of a heartbreaking traffic accident.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.