A former Pittsburgh police sergeant on trial on charges of assaulting an intoxicated 19-year-old outside Heinz Field in 2015 said Wednesday that he shoved the man to the ground because he felt he was about to be attacked.
Testifying in his own defense in his federal civil rights trial, Stephen Matakovich said Gabriel Despres fixed him with a “thousand-yard stare,” tucked in his chin, turned slightly sideways and curled his fingers into a fist, all indications that he was about to fight.
“He shifted from his heels to the balls of his feet,” said Mr. Matakovich in answering questions from his lawyer, Tina Miller. “I believed that I needed to protect myself. I was afraid he was going to sucker punch me.”
He said Mr. Despres got back up after the shove, said “what the [expletive]” and came toward him, so he shoved him again. He said Mr. Despres then reached toward the officer’s belt, where he keeps his weapons, and he punched him in the head to protect himself. The two then grappled, during which he said he punched Mr. Despres repeatedly to make him let go of the lapels of his jacket because he said Mr. Despres was trying to choke him.
After the incident was over and Mr. Despres was handcuffed, he said Mr. Despres complained about being struck.
“I said, ‘I thought you were going to hit me,’” Mr. Matakovich testified.
Read More
Surveillance footage from Heinz Field
The former sergeant, 48, is on trial in U.S. District Court on charges of depriving Mr. Despres of his civil rights and filing a false report justifying his use of force outside Heinz Field during high school football playoffs in November 2015.
The incident was recorded on video surveillance. Part of the government’s case is trying to prove that Mr. Matakovich deliberately tailored his report and an affidavit for Mr. Despres’s arrest on aggravated assault charges after watching the video in the Heinz Field control center.
Asked by his lawyer whether he intended to obstruct justice by filing a false report, Mr. Matakovich said, “I did not.”
Earlier in the trial Sean Oates, a manager for Landmark Security, said he told Mr. Matakovich “that’s enough” during the encounter and that later Mr. Matakovich approached him to say, “You seem to have a problem with what happened.”
Prosecutors say it was then that Mr. Matakovich went to the control room and reviewed the tape several times because, according to the government, he knew what he’d done was wrong and needed to see the video before he drafted his report.
But Mr. Matakovich said he did not recall Mr. Oates saying “that’s enough” and denied that he viewed the tape after speaking with Mr. Oates. He said he watched the video to see how it matched his memory of what happened.
“I wanted to get a count of how many times I struck Mr. Despres,” he said.
Earlier in the day the government rested its case without calling Mr. Despres.
The U.S. attorney’s office has instead relied on the surveillance video and testimony from numerous security personnel, all of whom said Mr. Matakovich was the aggressor during the incident.
The last government witness Wednesday was Sean Jackson, a guard for Landmark Security, who said he did not see Mr. Despres do anything threatening before Mr. Matakovich took action.
“I saw the cop shove the kid,” he said. “He [Despres] was defensive. He was in a panic.”
On Tuesday several guards and security managers working that night made similar statements, refuting Mr. Matakovich’s report in which he wrote that Mr. Despres turned sideways, made a fist and rocked onto the balls of his feet as if preparing to attack.
The government witnesses all said Mr. Despres was drunk and mouthy, but none said he made a fist or took an aggressive stance.
The trial will continue Thursday before U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon with Mr. Matakovich back on the stand.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-944-6551.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.