Security guards at the scene of a violent altercation at Heinz Field between a former Pittsburgh police sergeant and an intoxicated 19-year-old testified Tuesday that the young man posed no threat to anyone when the officer suddenly shoved him to the ground and delivered a flurry of punches to his head.

“I didn’t feel it was necessary,” said Sean Oates, manager for Landmark Security, on the second day of a civil rights prosecution of Stephen Matakovich in U.S. District Court.

“I would say that Mr. Matakovich was the aggressor towards this kid,” said a Landmark supervisor, William Wise.

Both said Gabriel Despres, the victim, never said or did anything aggressive, nor did he strike or grab the sergeant, as the officer wrote in his report.

Advertise with us

A video of the incident played in court shows Mr. Despres shielding himself as Mr. Matakovich shoves him to the ground twice and punches him repeatedly.

“He was just trying to protect himself as best he could,” said Mr. Oates.

Mr. Matakovich is accused of beating Mr. Despres outside the stadium during high school football playoffs in 2015. He is charged with deprivation of civil rights and obstructing justice by falsifying his report and an affidavit to justify the use of force.

After Mr. Despres was arrested that night, Mr. Oates said Mr. Matakovich walked to the security control room at Heinz Field to watch the video.

Surveillance footage from Heinz Field

Mr. Oates said the sergeant approached him because he said he felt Mr. Oates was uncomfortable with how the officer had handled the situation. At the end of the incident, Mr. Oates said he had told the officer “that’s enough” to get him to stop punching Mr. Despres.

Advertise with us

Mr. Oates told the jury that Mr. Matakovich explained that because of his years as a police officer and his training in mixed martial arts, it was his opinion that Mr. Despres was turning sideways, rocking onto the balls of his feet and clenching his fist as if getting ready to fight.

“He wanted to explain,” said Mr. Oates. “I said, ‘That’s fine, whatever.’”

Mr. Oates helped Mr. Matakovich and others subdue Mr. Despres in order to get him handcuffed but said he was upset over what he’d seen.

In reviewing the officer’s written report for the jury, Mr. Oates said he never saw Mr. Despres turn sideways or “blade” his body, never saw him make a fist and never saw him rise up on the balls of his feet, all descriptions that Mr. Matakovich included.

Mr. Wise, who was within a few feet of the incident, said the same, as did another security guard who was farther away.

Advertise with us

Prosecutors said in their opening statement that Mr. Matakovich lied in the report to justify what he’d done but tailored his narrative after watching the video so it would be more difficult to disprove his claims that Mr. Despres was about to attack.

While the video is relatively clear, viewers cannot see Mr. Despres’s hands because Mr. Matakovich’s body is in the way.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Cindy Chung said the sergeant deliberately wrote his report to say that Mr. Despres had made a fist because he knew the video did not show Mr. Despres’ hands and could not refute his claim.

But Mr. Oates and Mr. Wise said the slightly built Mr. Despres, while drunk and refusing to leave, did not make any threatening moves and had his hands in his pockets when the sergeant shoved him.

While he is being manhandled by the sergeant his arms can be seen flailing, but the witnesses said he was trying to ward off blows rather than fight back and later, on the ground, covered his head with his arms to keep from being struck.

Advertise with us

“He was protecting himself,” said Mr. Wise.

The case will continue Wednesday before U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-944-6551.