A federal prosecutor told a jury Monday that a former Pittsburgh police sergeant assaulted an intoxicated man outside Heinz Field in 2015 without cause and then wrote a fake report to justify what he’d done because he knew he’d been videotaped.

“This case is about two abuses of power,” said Assistant U.S. Attorney Cindy Chung in the opening of the government’s civil rights trial against Stephen Matakovich.

First, she said, Mr. Matakovich shoved Gabriel Despres to the ground and punched him repeatedly in an incident captured on surveillance cameras.

Then, she said, he lied, saying Mr. Despres attacked him when the video shows he did not.

Advertise with us

“The defendant further abused his power by trying to cover it up,” she said.

But Mr. Matakovich’s lawyer, Tina Miller, said Mr. Despres was drunk, belligerent, refused to leave and turned to face the officer as if he were was going to attack.

“He positioned himself to fight,” she said. “As he was trained to do, [Matakovich] reacted. A police officer doesn’t have to wait to be attacked.”

The dueling viewpoints marked the start of a relatively rare criminal trial of a police officer in this federal district.

Mr. Matakovich is accused of assaulting Mr. Despres outside the stadium during high school football playoffs in 2015. A surveillance camera recorded him shoving Mr. Despres to the ground twice and punching him in the head repeatedly.

Advertise with us

Mr. Matakovich is charged with deprivation of civil rights and obstructing justice by falsifying his police report to justify his use of force.

The government’s first witness, Sean Oates, a manager for Landmark Security, said Monday afternoon that he did not see Mr. Despres acting aggressively or saying anything aggressive in the encounter with Mr. Matakovich that night.

He said Mr. Despres was extremely intoxicated and was denied entry to the games.

When he wouldn’t leave, police were called.

Mr. Matakovich, who was moonlighting on a security detail, warned Mr. Despres that he would “shove his boot” up Mr. Despres’s rear end so far that he’d “taste the laces” if he didn’t leave, Mr. Oates said.

Advertise with us

He said Mr. Despres turned to walk away but then turned back when Mr. Matakovich told him “this is the big city” and that he wasn’t in Beaver County anymore.

Mr. Despres, who lives in South Park, had wanted to watch a football game in which Aliquippa was playing against Thomas Jefferson.

Mr. Oates said that after Mr. Matakovich made that comment, Mr. Despres turned around. Mr. Matakovich moved toward him. On the video, Mr. Despres’ hands appear to be in his pockets.

Seconds later Mr. Matakovich shoved Mr. Despres violently to the ground, the video shows.

Testimony stopped for the day at that point and the trial will resume Tuesday with Mr. Oates back on the stand.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-944-6551.