An attorney for Dollar Bank on Friday urged an Allegheny County judge not to forestall the possible sale of the August Wilson Center for African American Culture any longer.

Dollar Bank holds a $7.9 million mortgage on the building, and total debt on the property approaches $9.5 million.

The center defaulted on its loan 20 months ago, and court-appointed conservator Judith Fitzgerald recommended putting the property up for sale.

The highest bid was for $9.5 million from 980 Liberty Partners, which wants to build a hotel on top of the center. A competing group, including the Pittsburgh Foundation, the Heinz Endowments and the Richard King Mellon Foundation, wants to continue operations only as a cultural center and has offered $7.2 million. City and county officials and the Urban Redevelopment Authority backed that bid.

Advertise with us

A trial is scheduled for Sept. 29 to determine whether existing covenants in place on the property require it only to be used for African-American cultural events, which would prohibit the construction of a hotel on top.

If Common Pleas Judge Lawrence O’Toole determines the covenants prohibit the proposed hotel, 980 Liberty will not buy the property, and it will be slated for sheriff’s sale Oct. 6.

Beverly Weiss Manne, who represents the conservator, argued that the sheriff's sale should be delayed at least 35 days, allowing Judge O’Toole to issue his decision on the covenants and provide time for any appeals to be filed before the property goes up for auction.

She also asked the court to extend the time period for due diligence on the sale of the property to 980 Liberty that now expires Sept. 24.

If the time period ends before a decision on the covenants, 980 Liberty will have to risk buying a property that it might not be able to build on, or pull entirely out of the deal.

Advertise with us

“They need the court’s ruling one way or another,” Ms. Manne said. “We are sincerely hoping the sale to 980 can proceed.”

Eric Schaffer, who represents Dollar Bank, argued against any more delays. He spoke extensively at the hearing about the many ways Dollar Bank has attempted to support the center since its construction, including waiting months before taking any action on the defaulted mortgage. Since then, Dollar Bank has been forced to pay insurance on the property, including $19,000 in the past week.

“It’s only the bank that’s supported this process,” Mr. Schaffer said. “The attorney general is not offering to underwrite any of the expenses here.

“Everybody is happy for us to advance money, but nobody seems to care if we ever get paid.”

Under the law, Mr. Schaffer said there is no right to deprive the bank of its right to foreclose on the property, and he has accused the URA of being obstructionist in blocking the sale. While Dollar Bank wants the 980 Liberty property sale to go through, “At some point, it has to stop, and that’s Oct. 6,” he said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Manne said the conservator also wants the property to be sold and that the best option is 980 Liberty, which would allow the center to continue its mission, create 200 jobs in the hotel and put the property back on the tax rolls.

Mark Nowak, who represents the URA, said he objected to Dollar Bank making the URA out to look like “a bad guy.”

Instead, he said his agency does not oppose the idea of a hotel on the property.

Judge O’Toole took the issue under advisement and did not indicate when he would make a decision.