A court-appointed conservator won’t give up the August Wilson Center for African American Culture without a fight.

Judith Fitzgerald is trying to block Dollar Bank from foreclosing on the Downtown property on Oct. 6 if it is not sold to New York developer 980 Liberty Partners by then.

In a motion, Ms. Fitzgerald urged Judge Lawrence O’Toole of Allegheny County Common Pleas Orphans’ Court to set aside or stay execution of the sheriff sale on legal and practical grounds.

She said the proposed sale to 980 Liberty, the subject of a sales agreement she negotiated, is proceeding but probably won’t be completed until November, making an October sheriff sale “premature and unwarranted.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Fitzgerald, in the motion, also stated that if 980 Liberty decides not to close, she intends to auction off the property herself. In such a judicial sale, Dollar can bid the $7.9 million it is owed in the mortgage default to protect its interests, she said.

Further, the sale to 980 Liberty likely will bring more to creditors than a foreclosure, she said. The developer is offering to buy the building for $9.5 million, out of which Dollar would be repaid $7.9 million. A sheriff sale is unlikely to generate more than the money owed to the bank, she argued.

“The pending sale to 980 would pay Dollar Bank in full and provide a more meaningful recovery to creditors than would result from a foreclosure sale and thus the court should set aside or stay the writs of execution,” Ms. Fitzgerald wrote.

As an added practical matter, she noted that Judge O’Toole has scheduled a trial Sept. 29 to decide whether deed covenants involving the center would apply in the proposed sale.

It is “presumptuous to assume” that the judge will have issued an opinion and that all appeals will have been waived before Oct. 6, she said.

Advertise with us

The city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority has argued that those covenants require the building to be used solely for African American arts and culture and prevent any changes to the exterior without its consent.

If the covenants are upheld, it likely will kill the deal with 980 Liberty — which wants to build a 200-room luxury hotel on top of the building, while retaining part of it for the August Wilson Center organization — and push the building closer to foreclosure.

As a legal matter, Ms. Fitzgerald maintained that the property is in custody of the law and as such is immune from sheriff sale.

Eric Schaffer, Dollar’s attorney, declined comment, saying the bank would file its own response with the court. Judge O’Toole will hear arguments on the request for a stay Friday.

In a separate motion to establish procedures for an auction if 980 Liberty does not buy the property, Ms. Fitzgerald said that prospective buyers would have to bid at least $7.5 million for the property.

Advertise with us

The city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority, Mayor Bill Peduto and county Executive Rich Fitzgerald have been fighting the proposed sale to 980 Liberty.

They favor a lower $7.2 million bid advanced by the Pittsburgh Foundation, the Heinz Endowments, and the Richard King Mellon Foundation with the intent of fully maintaining the August Wilson Center. The $7.2 million includes $1.2 million from the URA and $1 million from a yet-defined county-related entity.

Dollar moved to foreclose last year after the August Wilson Center organization defaulted on its mortgage.

In another filing Wednesday, the bank stated that because of the URA’s efforts to block the sale, it’s now uncertain whether 980 Liberty’s $9.5 million will be enough to make it whole, particularly given that legal fees to Ms. Fitzgerald and her advisers now top $700,000. The conservator and the others would be paid out of the proceeds of the sale.

Dollar intends to seek damages against the URA if the agency succeeds in blocking the sale and the bank is unable to recover the $7.9 million it is owed. It wants to separate that issue from the trial on the covenants.