If the standing-room-only crowd at the meeting about the fate of the August Wilson Center for African American Culture Saturday is any indication, Allegheny Common Pleas Court Judge Lawrence O’Toole might need a bigger courtroom later this month.

Judge O’Toole has a trial scheduled Sept. 29 to determine the seemingly arcane question of whether deed restrictions placed on the property by the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority will remain once it is sold and continue until 2021

With that decision, Judge O’Toole can decide the fate of African-American cultural programming for the next 50 years in Pittsburgh, if Grant Oliphant, president of the Heinz Endowments, is right.

Mr. Oliphant was one of a group of speakers who addressed the current status of the litigation over the August Wilson Center at a meeting Saturday morning in the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh’s Hill District branch.

Advertise with us

If the judge upholds the URA’s covenants, which state that the building is to be used as an African-American cultural center and that any changes to the building’s exterior have to be approved by the URA, then the building is essentially useless to 980 Liberty Partners, a New York developer with a sales agreement to buy the building for $9.5 million

The August Wilson Center fell under court jurisdiction after it became delinquent on a $7.9 million loan from Dollar Bank. There are other debts on the building as well, including now more than $704,000 owed to Judith Fitzgerald, the court-appointed receiver, Tucker Arensberg, the law firm representing her, and consultant the Meridian Group.

980 Liberty Partners plans to build up from the center to create a 200-room hotel. The developer has offered the center free gallery, office and storage space and the use of the theater in the building for 120 days a year, but would cut the size of the area used for the cultural center to 35 percent of what it is now. Sala Udin, a former city councilman who is now part of the August Wilson Center Recovery Advisory Committee, said that the gallery space would be the hallways outside of the theater.

“We hope the covenants run with the land,” said E.J. Strassburger, an attorney who is a member of the committee.

He explained to the group that running with land means that a new owner would be stuck with the restrictions and could not convert it to a hotel. “That does preserve the vision” of the building as an African-American cultural center, he said.

Advertise with us

If the judge rules that the covenants are to be wiped from the building, he said, the city can appeal that decision, which would tie up the ability of the developers to add to it for years.

In the meeting room yesterday, Mr. Oliphant pointed out that the Downtown garage in which he parks is still referred to as “the Gimbels garage,” despite the fact that the Gimbels there closed in 1986. He then drew the parallel to the August Wilson Center.

“Do you want to spend the next 50 years driving past what ‘used to be the August Wilson Center’?” he asked. He said the closure of that center “will have a ripple effect on what gets funded in the African-American community” for the next 30 years. And beyond that, it will also make a statement to the rest of the country that Pittsburgh does not support African-American culture.

To counter the hotel developer’s offer of $9.5 million, Mr. Oliphant said the Heinz Endowments offered $7.4 million, with $4 million to $4.5 million a year to pay for the management of the center for the next three and a half years, for a total offer of $15 million, which would keep the building as a center for African-American culture.

If Ms. Fitzgerald is unable to sell the building before Oct. 6, it will be sold at sheriff’s sale.

Advertise with us

Mr. Strassburger said the prospect of putting the building up for sheriff’s sale was not necessarily bad, because it would strip the building of its debts so that the center could go forward without the burden of the mortgage.

As part of the process to bring the center to the other side of receivership, the August Wilson Center Recovery Committee developed what it calls “AWC 2.0,” which is a plan for new programming that will use the building for arts events in the evening, for music and live theater, and also during the day as a museum and community resource center.

Janera Solomon, a member of the recovery committee, said “the original vision for the center was a dynamic place. That still matters.”

Ms. Solomon, who is also executive director of the Kelly-Strayhorn Theater, said non-profits and for-profit businesses struggle with finances all the time.

“Non-profits and for-profits alike face organizational challenges. The Heinz History Center, the Pittsburgh Center for the Arts, the Kelly-Strayhorn Theater, these are all organizations that had problems and now they’re relatively stable,” she said.

Advertise with us

In the process of talking about the center, she said “we heard over and over and over that the center needs to be more connected to the community.”

She said the community wants to see the August Wilson Center “as a gathering place. Not only for entertainment, but a place to come together when there is a concern.”

Mr. Oliphant said that if the center does return to the community’s control, there will be two organizations in charge of the center. One will control the building, making sure the roof is leak-free and the heat is on. The other will be in charge of the programming.

Mr. Udin, the former councilman who organized the meeting Saturday as a member of the August Wilson Center Recovery Advisory Committee, told the people assembled they needed to contact Judge O’Toole, Mayor Bill Peduto and county Executive Rich Fitzgerald to express their support for the center.

“Mr. Peduto needs to hear from you,” he said. “The city needs to hold fast.”

“The idea of what the center stands for is an idea we’re still willing to fight for,” Mr. Oliphant said. “It matters. It really matters.”