Even before the May 4 opening of walleye season, anglers were releasing big ′eyes taken in winter feeding waters on the Middle Allegheny River.
Sixty-five miles north at Lake Erie, aquatics biologists are anticipating another spectacular season of walleye fishing. Last year the angler harvest was three times higher than the 30-year average.
But they’re not the same fish. Great Lakes and river walleye have been genetically separated for thousands of years
“There are different genetic strains in Lake Erie and the Ohio River,” said Tim Wilson, an aquatics biologist for the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission. “It’s actually a very complicated [issue].”
Multiple studies show walleye were genetically separated by the same glacial activity that reversed the Allegheny’s formerly northward flow, formed the Ohio River from the spillway of a giant ice-dam lake that no longer exists and gouged out and filled the Great Lakes with freshwater.
They look the same — toothy mouth, prehistoric spiny dorsal and clouded eyes built for seeing in deep dark water — but a 2014 study from the University of Toledo found that at the DNA level, the fish show “considerable genetic divergence and substantial diversity across their range.... The most pronounced divergences distinguish three geographic regions.”
Read More
Walleye living in the Great Lakes show the greatest genetic diversity, suggesting that over the ages fish intermingled in all parts of the freshwater inland sea. Walleye grow more genetically isolated the farther south they range from the Great Lakes.
One West Virginia waterway in the Ohio River system, the deceptively named New River, is a rare northern-flowing river that is actually one of the oldest rivers on Earth. Walleye were found to be the most distantly related to the rest of the population in the New River’s southern extremes and the North River, a southeast-flowing tributary of the Cacapon River in the Potomac River and Chesapeake Bay watersheds.
Biologists had believed that the walleye spawn is triggered by water temperature, but discovery of distinct strains has some wondering if genetics is involved, too. Southern walleye drop their half-million eggs when water temperatures reach 48-50 degrees. At Lake Erie’s latitude and farther north spawning occurs at night when the water hits 44-47 degrees.
Research into walleye diversity is complicated by widespread stocking in impoundments and rivers, which initially didn’t distinguish between then-unknown strains. On Pennsylvania waters including Lake Wilhelm and Conneaut Lake, walleye are stocked by the state Fish and Boat Commission to reduce populations of invasive prey species. The success of river stocking is uncertain. It has not been conclusively established whether inter-species walleye spawning occurs.
Separate research is underway by several Lake Erie states including Pennsylvania to chart genetic differences among resident nearshore walleye and those that migrate hundreds of miles per year. The Lake Erie bite has not yet begun. The migration from the western basin is expected to start in late May and June.
On the Allegheny River, Eastern Highland walleye have been taking baits all winter.
“It’s essentially two separate systems -- 70 miles of impounded waters and the free-flowing Allegheny from East Brady north,” said Jeffrey Knapp, who coaches fishing clients through his Keystone Connection Guide Service.
In currently cold waters, walleye are fattening up following a grueling April spawn.
“They’re particularly aggressive in spring and early summer and actively feeding in the current in 3-5 feet of water,” he said. “There were more nice walleye during the fall, winter and so far this spring than in recent years on the lower parts of the Middle Allegheny.”
He’s catching them on swim baits and suspended jerk baits. Genetics, he said, has nothing to do with it.
“We’ve had good reproductive years. 2018 was a good spawn for river walleye,” said Mr. Knapp.
Closer to Pittsburgh, where deeper 15- to 25-foot holes are common, he recommends walleye anglers target creek mouths and tailraces.
“[There] it’s more of a jig thing,” he said. “The holes are too small for trolling, so it’s vertical jigging and fishing the drift with minnows, crawlers or leeches, or throwing blade baits or a silver Lucky.”
If you want river walleye, get on them now.
“They’re still fairly close to the areas where they hunt,” he said. “When the water warms, they disperse.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.