About 12 miles off Long Point, Ontario, at the other end of the glacial sand spit that created the Presque Isle peninsula, walleye are massing over the deepest point in Lake Erie.

The darkness at 200 feet is the realm of 20-to-30-pound lake trout, but this time of year walleye from all parts of the lake converge and suspend over the Long Point Escarpment. Most of the fish are believed to have spawned in the lake’s western basin. Others likely spawned in Pennsylvania, New York and Canadian waters. “The Ditch,” as it is called up north, is another destination in the annual Lake Erie walleye migration.

The end of Erie County’s great walleye summer is has arrived. Anglers are marking migrating fish farther and farther north.

Before noon Thursday, Ron Milavec of Upper St. Clair and Ken Buettner of Beechview phoned in a Fishing Report from glassy waters 7½ miles north of Walnut Creek while trolling over the First Trench.

Advertise with us

“We boated 15 walleye so far and kept seven between 18 and 28 inches,” said Milavec. “We’re out in 75-76 feet of water. Right now there’s a whole line of fish across the screen at 40 to 45 feet.”

An experienced veteran of walleye waters, Milavec hooked the 28-incher trolling a small red, white and blue spoon with a copper back.

“Last year, the fishing lasted into mid-October,” he said. “I imagine there’s still a couple of weeks left before [the walleye] are gone.”

Farther north in Ontario waters, the walleye bite is “outstanding” and getting better. During a landmark season with walleye spread out across Lake Erie, and an angler harvest three times the 30-year average, fishing guide Jim Carrol said his business is having a landmark year.

“I think they’re here because of the colder water. The hotter the summer, the better the fishing is here,” said Carrol, whose Jimmy Riggin’ Fishing Charters moors at Old Cut on Long Point.

Advertise with us

“This year the water is cooler than normal. There’s been no wind — wind pushes the cold water down,” he said. “Usually in July I’ll start fishing at 100 feet. This year, we were catching pickerel at 30 feet, the shallowest we’ve ever fished.”

Pickerel, he explained with a laugh, is Long Point slang for walleye.

“The bigger ones come in first in smaller numbers,” said Carrol. “By now, most of the pickerel that are coming to The Ditch are here, but more are still coming. They’re stacking at different levels between 60 and 70 feet. I don’t know how the schools are formed, whether they’re from Ohio or closer, but they’re here and we’re catching them.”

The Lake Erie walleye explosion was sparked several years ago by the unusual success of several spawning seasons in successive years. It is believed that a confluence of favorable water temperature and availability of forage fish led to the big western-basin spawning seasons. Those year classes have come of age, yielding fish that now range from about 14 inches to more than 30 inches.

Science hasn’t settled on whether “resident” walleye, those caught in the east basin before the annual west-to-east migration, experienced the same levels of spawning success as their west basin cousins. Research has been underway for some time in Ohio and New York, but much about east basin walleye remains a mystery.

Advertise with us

“The theory is they’re all following the water temperature. We know that,” said Jason Robinson, a biologist with the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation’s Lake Erie Fisheries Unit. “Some come all the way from the west basin. Others move only 40 miles from where they spawn.”

In separate studies in New York and Ohio, aquatic wildlife agencies tagged walleye in eastern and western Lake Erie to track their movements. A similar angler-funded study was launched this year by the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission.

“In the east our chief question is, ‘How much do the west basin fish contribute to our local fishery?,” said Robinson. “We still haven’t answered it fully. We’re employing some microchemistry techniques and general techniques to establish that.”

After the spawn, walleye fan out through the entire lake. Most of the fish move, but they don’t follow a common route. West basin walleye occupy the entire lake, said Robinson, “literally up to Lake Huron.”

“[Walleye] that spawn in the east, we believe, tend to stay in the east basin, from the Pennsylvania Ridge [northwest of Presque Isle] to Buffalo.”

Advertise with us

East basin walleye play it safer than their western cousins, he said. Those that travel the shortest distances confront fewer anglers.

“We have a very limited snapshot of what’s happening,” said Robinson. “Over a longer timescale, do I think these migration patterns will hold up? I think they will. Now, in a period of high walleye abundance, would it influence the propensity to migrate? There is some work out there that suggested with a higher concentration of walleye in the west, a higher percentage would come east. Migration may be driven by density.”

If that’s the case, and east basin walleye living among smaller populations travel shorter distances, it could influence fisheries management throughout the lake.

“The big picture, what we’ve learned from this work, is the walleye migration from the west supports most of the fishing in the lake,” said Robinson. “They show up earlier and stay later than we ever thought they did.”

Research is underway at Ohio State University to determine if a genetic divide separates west-spawning walleye and those that spawn in the east.

Advertise with us

The last leg of the west basin walleye migration begins next month. Carrol said the walleye will follow smelt westward beyond Long Point. In November and December they will follow Lake Erie’s northern contour on routes that will return them before spring to the shallow spawning waters off Toledo.