Last year’s Lake Erie walleye harvest was the greatest on record.

Aquatic wildlife agencies suggested that a nexis of favorable weather conditions and a quirk in the walleye’s natural population cycle resulted in average or better egg hatches in three of the last four years. The 2017 walleye catch rate crested three times higher than the 30-year average. In Pennsylvania waters 70-fish days for a pair of boaters were not uncommon and 30-inch footballs were recorded.

The experts expect 2018 to be better. Scientists and fishing guides say thousands of last year’s sublegal throwbacks have matured to legal size, and some walleye from the successful year classes have reached trophy size.

There was just one problem with last year’s Lake Erie walleye. The early season had passed before many anglers realized something spectacular was happening. Those with boats followed the fish, while those without were mostly out of luck.

Advertise with us

This year shore anglers are officially invited to the party. Chuck Murray, Lake Erie fisheries manager for the state Fish and Boat Commission, said that for at least the first six weeks after the season opens May 1, boatless anglers will have the advantage.

“Although many well-equipped walleye anglers fish with downriggers and planer boards in offshore waters, this specialized equipment is not needed in the early season and can actually be a hindrance in shallow waters,” he said in a recent email exchange. “Walleye will be in the nearshore areas through June or later.”

The biggest, toothiest member of the perch family, walleye are among the earliest spawners -- sometimes scattering eggs before ice-out. Waves of walleye schools will approach from western Lake Erie as the water warms, but those that drop eggs in Pennsylvania waters may still be near tributary mouths and nearshore spawning waters. Shore anglers can find them within casting range over rocky or gravelly shoals and shallows.

“Drift fishing with a crawler harness or [spinner] in nearshore waters can be very effective in May and June,” said Murray, a member of the Lake Erie Committee, a consortium of fisheries managers from Michigan, Ohio, Ontario, Pennsylvania and New York. “One of the issues of fishing the nearshore areas is that there are often a lot of ‘non-target’ species such as smallmouth bass, drum and channel catfish. But this keeps the action steady.”

With the walleye population up to about 50 million, the Lake Erie Committee agreed to an increase in ‘total allowable catch’ (TAC) of 7.109 million walleye for 2018, a 20 percent increase over the 2017 TAC of 5.924 million fish. Why were no corresponding regulatory changes made in Pennsylvania waters?

Advertise with us

Murray: Actually there was an estimated 53 million walleye in the [western Lake Erie] TAC zone and an additional 15 million in the eastern basin non-TAC zone in 2017. … The angler effort and recreational harvest of walleye in eastern Lake Erie is insignificant relative to the TAC zone. The need for a TAC is not as pressing as it is in other areas of the lake where walleye exploitation is much higher. For example, in 2017 the combined harvest of walleye in New York (70,000 walleye) and Pennsylvania (163,000 walleye) recreational fisheries was less than 5 percent of total lake-wide harvest (4.91 million walleye).

Walleye that spawned in western waters haven’t arrived off Erie County during the early weeks of the season. So, are we fishing now for post-spawn year-round residents?

Murray: The population estimate in the non-TAQ zone is a mixed stock comprised of eastern basin residents as well as migrants from the western and central basins. So right now, we have walleye that are spawning locally and we will see migration from the west as the lake warms up. Based on telemetry data, walleye start moving out of the western basin towards the end of April, and have pretty much vacated the west basin by the beginning of July. Walleye movement from the west averages about [2.2 miles] per day and it takes an average of about two months to reach the eastern basin, although some fish have been shown to make the trip in as little as two weeks, or [about 10 miles] per day.

Will the spike in walleye population lead to increased walleye predation of steelhead smolts?

Murray: We have no way to specifically quantify walleye predation on steelhead smolts, but being Lake Erie’s primary predator we recognize that they do impact juvenile steelhead survival. In addition to walleye abundance, other factors such as timing of smolt emigration and nearshore residency of post-spawn walleye (or other predators like channel catfish) can also influence the magnitude of juvenile steelhead predation.

Advertise with us

We hope that we have alleviated some of the issues of excessive predation by increasing the size of the smolt the Fish and Boat Commission are stocking. Last year, the smolt were that largest the PFBC has stocked in the last 10 years. The larger smolt should have stronger swimming ability and be able to better evade predators. The impacts of larger smolt appeared to have helped in improving the Pennsylvania steelhead fishery over the last few years. Hopefully this strategy will reduce some of the impacts of smolt mortality we saw a decade ago when walleye were also very abundant.