Pittsburgh offers a cornucopia of pizza influences. Among them lies a variety deeply rooted in the region: Ohio Valley-style pizza.

One of the oldest local styles in the United States, Ohio Valley pizza was born at DiCarlo’s in Steubenville in 1945, during a time when cities like Detroit, Chicago and St. Louis were developing their takes on the Italian novelty.

Characterized by its crackly crust, tangy sauce and, most notably, room-temperature toppings, this tray pizza became a new sensation in the community. It was such a hit that, a few years later, founder Primo DiCarlo’s brother Galdo opened a second location in Wheeling, W.Va.

Although Steubenville is about 40 miles outside Pittsburgh and Wheeling is 60, the style found a home here, too, when the family’s third location opened in the city in 1951.

Advertise with us

Today, Ohio Valley-style pizza is an iconic food that connects us as a region.

In our new monthly series, Iconic Eats of Western Pa., we’ll explore the greater Pittsburgh area and beyond — even occasional smidges of Ohio and West Virginia — highlighting foods with regional roots. (We see you, Big Mac.)

Though Ohio Valley-style pizza is often derided by haters (most who have never tried it) sharing unappetizing photos online as “gross” or “Lunchable,” the hyper-local style is a revelation when made with the same integrity as the DiCarlo family and others of the era.

The secret is to keep the toppings simple (and avoid should-be-cooked toppings like pepperoni) and let the cheese steam in the box for a minute or two before you eat it. That steam melts the milk fat into a transitional state, kind of like what you’d get in a fantastic mozzarella stick.

Why the cool toppings? Popular lore recalls an idea that DiCarlos’ ovens were too hot for the rustic dough to fully bake with all its toppings and not burn. While there’s no existing evidence to support this theory, today’s Ohio Valley-style pizzas are typically par-baked before a final saucy cook. Some even add a sprinkle of provolone during the second bake for an excellent mix of melted cheese.

Advertise with us
Ohio Valley-style slices are boxed up for takeaway at Pizza House in Ambridge (Joseph Phillippi / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Where to find Ohio Valley-style pizza

Pizza House, also known as Police Station Pizza, at 1007 Merchant St. in Ambridge, serves the best example of this iconic food. The spot, open since 1951, serves beautifully balanced cuts and full trays on crispy, crackly, airy crust.

Some of its spin-offs – D&G Pizza with locations at 1470 Old Brodhead Road, Monaca, and 1818 7th Ave A, Beaver Falls, and Breezy's Pizza, 2314 Sheffield Road in Aliquippa – prepare outstanding Ohio Valley-style pizza, too.

Beto’s, 1473 Banksville Road in Beechview, which also opened in the 1950s, serves an excellent version within the Pittsburgh city limits.