On Sept. 3, David Portnoy, founder of the digital media company Barstool Sports, posted a photo captioned “#Pittsburgh” on X. In the frame of the photograph was the banner for Rockaway Pizzeria, the top-notch White Oak joint that will move to Regent Square later this month.
Portnoy flew to Pittsburgh to appear on a live recording of Barstool’s “PlanBri” at Stage AE. However, the buzz in the local pizza scene wasn’t about the podcast. The photo confirmed what had been circulating through the rumor mill: Portnoy was here to shoot his highly influential “One Bite” pizza reviews.
“He could probably say he’s eaten more pizza, and more of the best pizza, than just about anyone else,” says Rockaway Pizzeria owner/pizzaiolo Josh Sickels.
The PG confirms Portnoy shot at least seven reviews on Sept. 3: Rockaway Pizzeria, A Slice of New York in Murrysville, Pizza Lupo in Upper Lawrenceville, Pizzeria Davide and Bella Notte in the Strip District, Iron Born Pizza in Millvale and Ianni’s Pizzeria in Delmont.
“We didn’t know before the phone call that he was coming here, but we were anticipating that he might. Once the phone rang we knew it was him,” says Sean Jefairjian, owner of A Slice of New York.
(Portnoy calls in his orders from a not-so-secret number and uses the same pseudonym each time, a nod to in-the-know pizza owners that they have about 20 minutes to prepare their best showing.)
Read More
Portnoy made his first One Bite Pizza Review on YouTube in 2013, starting in his native Massachusetts. His spots caught on in earnest in 2017 as he set out to review every pizza joint in New York City. Instead, he expanded his geographic footprint significantly, visiting spots across the country for an audience that reaches millions. He’s posted more than 1,000 reviews on his YouTube channel, which has 1.34 million subscribers.
Word spread quickly that Portnoy was filming in Pittsburgh.
“Our community of pizza makers are amazing. Everyone talks to everyone, so people let other people know he was around,” says Alex Blinn, head pizza maker for Pizzeria Davide.
Portnoy’s reviews follow a familiar script, starting with comments about the pizza box and a quip or two as he exits the establishment. He reveals and inspects the pizza, sometimes offers a prediction about his score, pulls out a slice and comments a bit more.
He’ll blow on the tip of the slice like a wolf at the gate and with a “One bite, everyone knows the rules,” aggressively take a bite, then a second, then a third at the edge of the crust. Portnoy bestows his rating. He is notoriously stingy with his scale, offering only 20 judgments of 9 (out of 10) or higher in his history, and most of those came during the early days of his reviews.
Portnoy first visited Pittsburgh in 2020, trying old-school pizza spots. Fiori’s had the highest ranking on that trip, with a 7.8. Portnoy ate nearly two slices and said the Brookline pizzeria had a “New Haven vibe,” but “it’s a little too greasy to put in the 8s.”
In that clip he quipped about local patois, musing over why Pittsburghers called pizza slices “cuts,” which he initially thought were called “carts” at Beto’s (scored 7.2). In the same review, he expressed bewilderment at Turner’s iced tea being served in paper cartons rather than plastic or glass bottles (and, with a wink, gave the beloved local refresher a 9.2).
He took on the timeless Mineo’s-Aiello’s rivalry, giving a respective 7.1 and 6.1, while dubbing the classic Pittsburgh spots “Minoloh’s and Ayeoohlo’s,” among other mispronunciations of the two establishments.
Portnoy comes back to Pittsburgh with more baggage than a few misnomers in his previous Pittsburgh reviews. In 2022, the New York Times ran a story chronicling a litany of his alleged sexual misconduct and questioned his continued outsize influence. Last year, the Washington Post examined the backlash, spurred by Portnoy’s past behavior, surrounding his One Bite Pizza Festival.
In spite of his controversial past, his ability to drive business to pizza shops remains undeniable, as testified by a follow-up New York Times story about Portnoy in 2023.
“The way I see it, his visit is a vessel to have the craft I’ve been working on for almost nine years be shown alongside pizza makers that I have a lot of respect for and to legends who paved the way for me to do what I do,” says Sickels.
“This is about being recognized nationally and among my peers in the craft pizza scene more than any one person’s opinion.”
Portnoy’s Pittsburgh “One Bite” pizza reviews are expected to begin airing on his YouTube channel as early as this week.
Although the scores are yet to be revealed, the hype is already building. Rockaway sold out of pies at 4:30 p.m. on Saturday, hours before its closing time. Slice of New York’s already robust business has more than doubled.
“It’s been nuts already and it hasn’t even aired yet,” says Jefairjian. “My friends in New York say we’re in for a wild ride once it does.”
Update 9/16/24:
That wild ride is now underway. Jefairjian's Slice of New York was the first spot to drop, launching on Sept. 11. The pizzeria received a first-class 8.2., landing it in the top 10% of all of Portnoy’s reviews.
“We did two Fridays on a Thursday. Insane! One person even drove from Michigan,” Jefairjian said in text message the next day.
Portnoy also dropped reviews for Bella Notte (7.1; a little too doughy for his taste) and Ianni’s (7.7; “Good crust. I liked this more than I thought I was [going to] coming out of the box.”) prior to press time.
Correction (9:38 a.m. 9/10/24): An earlier version of this story noted an incorrect score for Beto’s. It received a 7.2 from Portnoy in 2020.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.