This is the first of a two-part series.
Behind the main kitchen at Eat’n Park’s Waterfront location is a smaller setup. On the back wall of the region’s oldest dining conglomerate’s test kitchen is a line of fryers, flattops and ovens, framed on the other side by two rows of chairs set stadium-style on risers. Here, director of menu development John Frick, a 30-year veteran, spends his days working on new dishes and updating old favorites.
Over the past year, he’s revamped the Superburger, marking the first significant change to the chain's signature hamburger in decades. This fix, using fresh beef instead of frozen, will influence all the other burgers on the menu, too.
Discussions about (and sampling of) the toppings for the Superburger were extensive. Should they keep the shredded iceberg lettuce or switch to the trendy buttercrunch? And what about the sauce — does the original tartar-style still fit?
“With this particular burger, we thought it was a classic that wasn't broken, so let's not make changes to it other than enhancing the beef,” Frick says. “You want to be careful with messing with people’s nostalgia.”
Eat’n Park Hospitality Group, employing nearly 10,000 people across several culinary branches, has a lot of nostalgia to handle. With a 75-year history and ambitions to double it, its commitment to longevity involves walking a tightrope over memory lane while keeping an eye on what’s drawing people to the competition.
Read More
“The only way to stick around for another 75 is to stay relevant to what customers want,” Frick says.
Right now, customers want fresh beef, not frozen, pre-formed patties.
“The brands that don't make it are the ones that refuse to evolve,” says Eat’n Park Hospitality Group CEO Jeff Broadhurst.
Testing, testing
During monthly development meetings, Frick and teams from various parts of the company — district management, marketing, product development, supply chain — review potential menu items and debate their replicability across the restaurants. New or modified items are then tested at half of the locations under each district manager's supervision, with detailed feedback following.
“It's a big undertaking to introduce a new item because we have to teach people across the board how to replicate the dish,” Frick says. “It's a challenge with a company that has such a large footprint. You have to trust folks to carry out the message and execute consistently.”
With the reformatted Superburger, for example, Frick introduced a custom-designed, stainless-steel hamburger press crafted to lightly smash the patties on the griddle to a specific thickness and preserve the meaty texture essential to the Superburger tradition.
Once a dish is finalized, it’s time to roll things out.
“The managers and culinarians [Eat’n Park speak for its cooks] take my message back to the folks at the restaurants,” he says. “And as soon as they leave the test kitchen, we start making training videos and materials that will help them with the process.”
Frick says that the ease of distributing training materials is one of the biggest boosts for the company over the past few decades. Videos, step-by-step graphics and written instructions can be made quickly and inexpensively, then immediately distributed to restaurants with today’s technology.
“If a restaurant is having a challenge with a new item, they can even send a video from their phone to John to ask what they are doing wrong,” Broadhurst says.
Industry trends are the major prompt to make changes. The company aims to anticipate what guests might want six months, a year or three years from now and develop items that will last rather than fade as a fad. That means looking at dietary trends, such as reduced meat consumption and gluten-free diets, without chasing the flavor of the week.
“Change is challenging because inevitably you will make mistakes. That's frustrating and it can be costly, but you have to be unafraid to do it,” Broadhurst says. “The best data set we have is what sells and what doesn't sell.”
So far, so good with the updated burger line, which was introduced earlier this year.
In the test kitchen, the Superburger embodies nostalgia. It's a classic American road-stand burger that might not win over those craving prime steakhouse burgers or smashburgers with deep, lacy-edged umami, but it’s a timeless favorite for most.
“We looked at a lot of different smashburgers and experimented with what we liked and didn't like about them. When they're very smashed they're over-crispy and I think you start to lose that hamburger taste people love. We want a nice sear, but we still want it to be a classic burger,” Frick says.
At Eat'n Park’s Etna and DuBois locations, it sticks the landing. The smash technique works. Both sets of dual patties are meaty with a hint of pink in the center.
Constant refreshment
In the late 1940s, Claire “Larry” Hatch, a manager for Isaly’s, founded Eat’n Park after being inspired by a trending new hamburger, the “Big Boy” at Frisch’s in Cincinnati. The spin: This cheeseburger (created in Southern California) had two thin-ish patties with an extra half-bun in the middle and was garnished with shredded lettuce, tomato, American cheese and a “secret” sauce.
The mascot Hatch saw caught his eye, too — a kid with surfing-wave hair and blue eyes dressed in red and white checkered overalls strolling with that signature hamburger.
Hatch connected with the Big Boy’s creator, Bob Wian, and secured regional rights to franchise the burger and mascot. Unlike later franchise agreements, such as those for McDonald’s and Taco Bell, the 25-year deal didn’t dictate what else Hatch could do with his restaurant. And when the deal expired in 1974, Hatch renamed his Big Boy the Superburger.
In 1949, Hatch opened the first Eat’n Park drive-in restaurant on Saw Mill Run Boulevard in Overbrook.
He expanded quickly, opening a second Eat’n Park in Avalon in the same year. He tried to sell the concept to Isaly’s, but they weren’t interested. So he kept going, building a team to keep the company moving forward.
One member was Jim Broadhurst, then a banker when he joined Eat’n Park in 1973, shortly after longtime company president Bill Peters retired. Eleven years later, Broadhurst and his wife, Suzy, purchased the company.
At its peak, the chain had 72 restaurants across Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia.
Generational change
Their three sons, Jeff, Brooks and Mark, eventually came on board too. The second-generation trifecta helped usher in an era of expansion that touched areas of regional dining from nursing homes to destination restaurants.
In 1996, the brand began diversifying with the addition of Parkhurst Dining, a contract food-service division designed to offer on-site meals for corporate, institutional and educational clients.
“We now have 80-plus Parkhurst locations [across 14 states] with executive chefs who are really good at what they do. They inspire throughout the system because of the way they run their operations and set examples for others,” says Brooks Broadhurst.
In 2006, the now-rebranded Eat’n Park Hospitality Group opened a high-end, ingredient-driven restaurant called Six Penn Kitchen that helped launch Pittsburgh’s restaurant boom the following decade and served as a linchpin of Downtown dining for 13 years.
In 2008, Jeff Broadhurst succeeded his father as CEO. Brooks currently serves as Eat'n Park Hospitality Group's vice president of food systems transformation and Mark as president of Parkhurst Dining.
In 2011, the company launched The Porch, a signature restaurant in Oakland’s Schenley Park that highlights fresh produce and sustainability with a scratch kitchen. It's quick and casual by day and becomes more elegant in the evenings. They're continuing to develop the concept, too. This year, they built a greenhouse next to the original location.
A second location, The Porch at Siena, opened in Upper St. Clair in June 2017, and by next spring, they expect to bolster the menu with some hyper-local ingredients from the greenhouse.
The now-massive company spun off two of the things Eat'n Park was best known for — burgers and salad — into Hello Bistro in 2012, capitalizing on a budding fast-casual marketplace. There are now seven of them in the region.
There's a lot of chatter across divisions, talking about new products and sharing guests’ feedback and needs.
If the company brings in a new ingredient — like bacon jam for a new Bacon Jam Burger introduced as part of Eat'n Park’s return to fresh beef — it aims to use it in multiple ways. The jam also appears in a two-cheese grilled cheese sandwich, for example, and might make its way into some of the other brands’ restaurants.
“I don't want to sound like a broken record, but it goes back to innovation,” Broadhurst says.
Next week, part two will look at how Eat’n Park’s evolution paves a way for the future. Alas, we will say goodbye to late night.
Correction (9:30 a.m. Aug. 13, 2024): An earlier version of the story misspelled the name of “Larry” Hatch’s employer pre-Eat’n Park: It was Isaly’s.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.