Eat‘n Park has been a go-to dining destination for generations of Pittsburghers thanks, in part, to the popularity of two beloved food items: the seasonal, glazed strawberry pie it introduced in 1954 (weighing 3 pounds!) and its shredded lettuce-topped double-decker Superburger, added to the menu 20 years later.

Yet it’s the white-iced sugar cookie with the cheek-to-cheek smile the restaurant chain introduced in 1986 that has really captured the heart of customers.

Smiley, as the treat is known, is almost a rite of passage in Pittsburgh.

Every child who dines at an Eat’n Park restaurant gets a free Smiley with each meal. And they’re available by the boxed dozen both on-site and online at smileycookie.com — where they can be customized to your favorite shape and color combinations. Millions have been offered one or more as a sweet treat at graduations and birthday parties, weddings, holidays and other special events.

Advertise with us

The cookie is also handed out at around 250 community events each year — it’s the official cookie of the Pittsburgh Marathon, for example  — and more than 200,000 Smileys are donated each year to worthy causes through nonprofit organizations.

“And it’s not just a Pittsburgh thing,” says Kayla Frattini, director of brand marketing for Eat’n Park Hospitality Group, the restaurant chain’s parent. “They go to all 50 states.”

The cookie, which was brought to life by former owner Jim Broadhurst in 1986, actually has pretty humble beginnings.

As a child growing up in Titusville, Broadhurst would walk past Warner’s Bakery every day after school, and use the nickel his mother gave him to buy a smiley face cookie. It gave him so much joy that, when he began growing Eat’n Park into a family brand, he asked: How can we bring that into the restaurant?

Broadhurst worked with Ellsworth Warner to get permission to create a cookie similar to his favorite childhood snack, without being an exact replica.

Advertise with us

Baked and iced in-house with a colored smile, the cookies took off, says Frattini, “and they became a really big asset to the restaurant.”

Cliff Miller, who worked at the advertising agencies Creamer Dickson Basford and Ketchum before joining the Eat‘n Park family as an employee in 1997, turned Smiley from a supporting player into an outright superstar.

One day in 1990, while eating breakfast at a Robinson restaurant with Basil Cox (then-president of the regional chain), Miller noticed tiny type promising a free Smiley to any child visiting the restaurant. Recognizing the 4-inch sugar cookie as the chain’s “advertising critter”— a marketing personality like Tony the Tiger   — he vowed to make Smiley as famous as Mickey Mouse.

A year later, Miller and his team at Ketchum created the restaurant’s famous tagline: “Eat’n Park’s the place for smiles.” And the rest, as they say, is history.

The cookie made its debut in the national spotlight in 2006, when the Pittsburgh Steelers faced off against the Seattle Seahawks in Super Bowl XL.

Advertise with us

“We got Pittsburgh Mayor [Bob] O’Connor and Pennsylvania Governor [Ed] Rendell to include Smiley Cookies in the bets against their Seattle counterparts. It generated a lot of publicity,” Kevin O’Connell, former chief marketing officer of Eat'n Park, says in “Eat'n Park: The Story Behind the Smile” by Lynn McMahon.

Or as Frattini notes, “We wanted to bring black-and-gold to fans across the country.”

New software allowed fans to order Smiley on the restaurant’s website. Fans responded by ordering 350,000 cookies, jump-starting Eat’n Park’s e-commerce business.

There was such continuous demand after the Steelers’ victory that the company built a separate bakery and distribution center on Campbell’s Run Road in Robinson and began selling the cookies on a more robust, dedicated website with an easy-to-remember name: smileycookie.com.

Smileys baked there by upwards of 20 staff members, depending on the season, have exactly the same flavor profile as those served at restaurants. But because they can be individualized, they are available in a lot more shapes, color combinations and sizes. You can even get them without icing, or opt to do the decorating yourself with a Smiley Cookie Decorating Kit. The cookies are certified nut free and kosher.

Advertise with us

To date, “smile makers” at the factory and in the chain’s restaurant kitchen make about 6.4 million cookies for fans across the country each year.

Over the years, as Smiley’s fame grew, so did customers’ choices with the introduction of seasonal and holiday designs. Since 1986, the cookie’s family tree has evolved to include everything from pink-iced, heart shaped cookies for Valentine’s Day; to Christmas trees, snowmen and reindeer cookies for Christmas; Frankenstein and Mummy Smileys for Halloween; and mortar board-wearing Smileys for graduates. This spring there were even full-size neon, sunglass-wearing Smileys to celebrate the solar eclipse on April 8.

Local celebrities and sports figures have also been immortalized in icing. In 2015, Rick Sebak followed Pittsburgh Dad and former Steeler Brett Keisel as Eat’n Park Pittsburgh celebrity Smiley Cookies. This June, a yellow-iced cookie with a black icing mustache — dubbed the Bucco ‘Stache Smiley Cookie — welcomed rookie Pirates pitcher Paul Skenes to the city.

“We are always looking to seek innovation to hit the next trend that people might be out there for and hit guests with what resonates with them,” says Frattini.

Then again, there really hasn’t been anything that hasn’t resonated with guests.

“How can you not be happy” with a Smiley Cookie? she asks. “It’s friendly, engaging and brings a smile to your face. It’s just happy, and who doesn’t like a great dessert?”