This is the second of a two-part series.

A few major shifts along the way have helped Pittsburgh’s Eat’n Park restaurants survive and look to the future.

Eat’n Park opened its first dining room in 1955, recognizing that some guests didn’t want to eat in their cars. In the mid-1960s, the brand began phasing out carhop service across the board. And, by the 1970s, people went to its restaurants expecting a full-service dining experience.

By the end of that decade, customers were flocking to a new offering: the soup and salad bar. Salad bars were trending at the time, offering a fresh, customizable option that appealed to an increasingly health-conscious public.

Advertise with us

While they might not be terribly trendy today at most restaurants, they remain the top-selling menu item across the board at Eat’n Park restaurants.

The salad bar's contents are dynamic, with new items occasionally swapped in. A significant constraint is that only so many items can fit on the cooling table.

“We're not going to redesign those,” says Jeff Broadhurst, Eat’n Park Hospitality Group CEO. “So every time we add something new, we have to take something off, and that will make some guests unhappy.”

In the 1980s, the company collaborated with Fred Rogers to make the dining rooms more family-friendly. The legendary television personality and Latrobe native helped design the chain’s first kid’s menus. Working closely with former chairman and CEO Jim Broadhurst, he offered advice on design changes and created “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood”-themed placemats with games to engage young family members during a meal.

“A lot of people don't know about this. He spent a lot of time with my father talking about what's the best way to entertain families,” Jeff Broadhurst says.

Advertise with us
Eat'n Parks' bacon jam burger is topped with slices of bacon and savory-sweet bacon jam. (Courtesy of Eat 'n Park)

Pick-up windows, introduced 12 years ago, are now an amenity at 50 of the 56 Eat’n Park restaurants. Adding them was a significant shift in philosophy, a sort of return to roots for a company that long ago phased out carhops and considers itself a family restaurant rather than a fast-food operation.

The windows weren’t very popular when they launched, but the design change proved fortuitous. As the COVID-19 pandemic stretched on, Eat'n Park gained a ready-made competitive advantage against Denny's and similar chain restaurants.

During that period, Eat’n Park also began utilizing third-party delivery apps for the first time.

“COVID wasn't very good for the restaurant business, as I'm sure is obvious. We thought we were done at one point,” Broadhurst says. “But we were able to take a lot away from what we learned as a result of it.”

Takeout now makes up a significant percentage of business, growing from the low teens in early 2020 to more than a quarter of all sales in 2024. Overall sales are higher now than prior to the pandemic, too.

Advertise with us

Not everything stuck. The company introduced online ordering that allowed customers to schedule when they wanted to eat, show up and have their meal ready on the table.

“You could cut out 10-15 minutes in an environment you might not feel totally comfortable sitting in for a long time during the pandemic, or even now when you just wanted to save some time. I used it all the time. It was great. I think I was the only one who used it, though,” Broadhurst says.

Goodbye, late night

Another post-COVID legacy is significantly less popular among a small but vocal segment of customers.

The pandemic dropped the curtain on 24-hour dining at Eat’n Park restaurants. The decision followed a national trend – CNN, using data from Yelp, noted that “the number of restaurants offering 24-hour service fell 18% from 2020 to 2024” in an April story.

Broadhurst says the company was in the process of rolling back all-night service prior to March 2020. Now, and perhaps forever, closing time is 11 p.m.

Advertise with us

“We were losing a significant amount of money after midnight by keeping it going,” Broadhurst says. “You hear all the time that people miss it. My question is: ‘Where were they when we were open?’”

It was also challenging to find people willing to work regular overnight shifts, a situation that worsened in the post-pandemic era. Consequently, managers and servers might be asked to work schedules that disrupted their lives, working a daytime shift one week and overnight shifts the next.

“That's not fair to our team members. We want them to be happy and we want them to stay that way,” Broadhurst says.

Indeed, employee retention is one of the biggest keys to Eat’n Park’s success.

The company has three team members celebrating 50 years of continuous service this year, which will put the total number in the half-century club at 11. Approximately 300 current employees have worked at Eat’n Park for more than 25 years.

Advertise with us

“When you have that many people who have worked at the same place for all those years, you demonstrate that this is a place where you can have a lifelong career,” Broadhurst says.

Buy local, keep it fresh

Hand-breaded zucchini with marinara sauce is one of Eat'n Park's newer menu introductions. (Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Hand-breaded zucchini, served as a standalone appetizer with marinara a la Pittsburgh's celebrated zucchini planks and as zucchini lasagna, is one of the latest menu introductions. And it’s one with serious potential to become a standard, if seasonal, roster member.

Everything breaded, even those famous Whale of a Cod fish sandwiches on the menu since 1949, is made hands-on at each restaurant. It's a point of distinction from the national chains that share market space with the company.

“These take effort to do it all from scratch instead of buying it pre-made. It's work, but it's absolutely worth it. People love it, and it's been a big success, which is why it's going to stick around,” says Broadhurst.

The dish's seasonality represents another largely unheralded key to Eat’n Park’s longevity in Pittsburgh. Overall, the company expects to spend nearly $30 million this year on regionally grown food — from within a radius of 125 miles of Pittsburgh —  across its divisions. That’s more than any other restaurant/food service business in the regional food economy.

Advertise with us

Eat’n Park launched its FarmSource program in 2002. It allows the company to have a singular supply chain department, with each division having specialists in local sourcing. For example, the individual chefs at Parkhurst Dining have more agency in making menu changes than Eat’n Park or Hello Bistro restaurants.

Longtime employee Jamie Moore works throughout the system as the company’s director of sourcing and sustainability.

“He’s the person out in the field getting to know farmers, what they can grow and what their struggles are,” Broadhurst says.

For its Eat’n Park restaurants, the company uses approximately 200,000 pounds of locally grown fruits and vegetables annually. It partners with other longstanding regional businesses such as Turner Dairy Farms for milk and other dairy products, 5 Generations Baking for grilled stickies and Cellone's Italian Bread Co. for hoagie and burger buns.

Of course, there are limits to local for a company with as many restaurants as Eat’n Park.

Advertise with us

“We can’t grow enough strawberries for us to make strawberry pies. It would be impossible to do that here year-round,” Broadhurst says.

And Eat’n Park diners want their strawberry pies.

Park After Dark

“Park After Dark” is an initiative meant to engage customers after dinner. It might not be all-night dining, but it’s become a central part of the restaurant's strategy in the last couple of years to reflect customers’ new habits.

“We see the opportunity to become the destination place for desserts in Western Pennsylvania,” Broadhurst says. “There’s a big hole in that market right now.”

There are classics like grilled stickies and fresh pies, but also a new whiz-bang line of sundaes. The build nods to modernity; the colorful, over-the-top presentation is built for sharing on social media.

Advertise with us

“What would be a memorable visual, but approachable for our staff to make?” says director of menu development John Frick. “We never decorated the rims of the glass like this, or put an ice cream pop sticking out of the top. We just put ice cream and toppings in a glass.”

There aren’t dedicated dessert areas in the restaurants, nor are there pastry chefs. So it’s up to the servers to assemble the final treat. The test kitchen had to make the final product easily repeatable without adding extra stress to the front-of-house team.

What’s next?

Parkhurst Dining president Mark Broadhurst, left, with Eat'n Park Hospitality Group chairman and CEO Jeff Broadhurst and its vice president of food systems transformation, Brooks Broadhurst. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Similar to the embrace of Fred Rogers helping adapt the chain’s dining rooms in the 1980s, the focus on enhancing the dining experience for families has continued to evolve, with Eat’n Park now testing table-top kiosks at its location in The Waterfront in Homestead.

Much like kid-friendly menus were designed to keep young diners engaged, these kiosks aim to meet the needs of modern families who value convenience and speed. The new tech will allow customers to order, add items to their orders and check out with a few clicks on a screen, as well as offer games to keep the kids entertained.

“Whether we roll it out widely, we have no idea — at least not yet. But guests want technology, so let's try to anticipate their needs, test it and see if they like it,” Broadhurst says.

Advertise with us

He thinks it might catch on with families, who sometimes have to leave in a hot second because of an urgent need. However, it could also distance customers from one of the restaurants' biggest draws: the personal touch of its longtime employees.

“That's a constant conversation,” Broadhurst says. “We'll continue to focus on how we can keep anticipating what a customer is going to want and need. We don't yet know what people are going to crave eating five years from now, 10 years from now. That's what we focus on.”

In the meantime, they’re busy remodeling restaurants:12 last year and another 12 slated for this year. They’re also rebuilding the Bridgeville restaurant from the ground up.

Altogether, it’s a pretty full journey for a brand that started as a business that adopted an iconic hamburger and mascot from California via Cincinnati.

It’s fitting, then, that Eat’n Park is going all-in on the local icon the well-established brand is now most recognized for.

Advertise with us

The Smiley cookie was introduced in 1986 and popularized a few years later with the “Eat’n Park’s the place for smiles” tagline.

In 2011, the mascot received an open-armed 4-foot replica at The Waterfront location to celebrate its 25th anniversary. For the company’s 75th, Smiley statues are rolling into an additional 10 restaurants.

“It started as a cookie,” Broadhurst says. “We've grown it into something that's a real icon that comes back to one thing, which is the purpose of our company:

“How do we create a smile on all the guests that come in here and one on everyone that works for us?”