Pittsburgh managed to avoid the housing meltdown that many cities across the nation experienced in the mortgage boom and bust. But a report released Wednesday suggests U.S. home values across the board have fallen since last year, and more than a third of Pittsburgh homes also have lost value.
Before the housing crash leading to the Great Recession, 30.1 percent of Pittsburgh region homes on average were decreasing in value, according to Zillow, an online real estate marketplace based in Seattle. That number now sits at 37.1 percent, higher than before the crash but still down from the January 2009 low point when 65.2 percent were dropping in value.
While some Pittsburgh real estate professionals dispute the assertion that so many homes have fallen in value, Zillow’s data also show that overall home values in the region are increasing. Its August 2015 index found average home values in Pittsburgh at $125,200, up 1.9 percent over the past year.
Still, it appears some of the post-recession momentum that was driving up overall home values is fading.
“When we look at the price trends in many metros across the U.S., home values are slowing down,” said Skylar Olsen, a senior economist at Zillow. “They are still increasing, but slowing down. Pittsburgh falls into that camp. In Pittsburgh, you have different areas of the city still thriving and some areas that have begun to decline.”
Ms. Olsen said it’s not unusual following a housing bubble and crash to see a period of greater volatility. “So a lot of the decline in home values that we see are prices adjusting and returning to normal,” she said.
Read More

(Click image for larger version)
Some cities see big drops
Markets on the East Coast and in the Midwest had the highest share of homes that lost value, according to Zillow. A whopping 48.1 percent of homes in Baltimore fell in value over the past year. Philadelphia saw 43.1 percent fall in value and Washington, D.C. had 41.2 percent lose value.
In hot markets such as San Francisco, Dallas and Denver, only tiny percentages of homes were worth less than a year ago. San Francisco saw 5.2 percent of its homes fall in value; Dallas-Fort Worth had 4 percent decline; and in Denver, only 1.5 percent dropped.
Tom Hosack, owner of Northwoods Realty in McCandless and president of West Penn Multi-List, is not buying Zillow’s claim that 37 percent of homes in the Pittsburgh region have declined in value.
“We see that average sales price has risen considerably over the last year,” Mr. Hosack said. “Homes are selling faster than they did last year. We’re seeing multiple offers on listings in areas that haven’t seen this type of demand since 2006 or 2007.
“The number of foreclosures and distressed properties are down considerably over the last year. We haven’t seen this few distressed properties in years.”
Mr. Hosack said he feels the problem with Zillow’s data stems from how the company determines a property’s value. He said it relies on a lot of tax data and public records, which can be inconsistent.
Dan Murrer, vice president of RealSTATs, a South Side-based real estate information service, said his research confirms the trend that Zillow identified.
Mr. Murrer obtains home price data from recorded sales filed at courthouses, while Zillow reports home value data, which is a calculation of what a property is worth established by analyzing sales information and various features of the property.
Mr. Murrer said he ran statistics for home sales in 431 municipalities in the Pittsburgh region over six counties and found residential home prices had declined in 174 of those municipalities. His data looked at home prices year-over-year for two years.
He found it interesting that home prices fell in solid Pittsburgh communities. For example, the average home price fell 3.5 percent in Shadyside; 2.6 percent in Upper St. Clair; and 8.6 percent in Plum.
Not all neighborhoods saw average home prices fall, according to RealSTATs data. In the city’s 8th Ward, which covers part of Lawrenceville, home prices increased 22.9 percent. The 10th Ward, which also covers part of Lawrenceville, had an increase of 19.5 percent.
Some owners not selling
“The average home price has fallen in roughly 40 percent of the region’s municipalities in the last 24 months and in 25 percent of the region’s municipalities over the last 60 months,” Mr. Murrer said. “This change does not necessarily translate into changes in market value for a given homeowner. It could simply mean that the higher-valued, higher quality real estate is being held by current owners and not offered for sale.”
He said that is especially plausible in light of historically low interest rates since 2010. “Owners may be reluctant to let go of a low mortgage rate,“ he said, noting that Zillow didn’t do market value appraisals on every home across the country but rather relied on a computer model.
“In an area like Pittsburgh where a $40,000 home can be around the corner from a $400,000 home, these computer models fail. Just look at the most recent countywide reassessment and the number of appeals that followed.”
Ms. Olsen at Zillow said the company uses all available information in terms of public records and tax information. She defended the company’s methodology, noting that it can control for the changes in product type that fall in any given month.
“There are a lot of things about an individual home we won’t know about a house, and a local real estate agent might price it better,” she said. “But when looking at the aggregate we really believe in our methodology.“
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.