For a community with a long-standing reputation for having a high rate of mortgage foreclosures and less than stellar home price appreciation over the years, Penn Hills is still attracting more home buyers than any other area of Allegheny County.

Penn Hills was the county’s No. 1 ranked municipality for the number of homes sold in 2014 with a total of 669, followed by Mt. Lebanon where 526 homes were sold, and Ross where 515 houses changed hands, according to data collected by RealSTATs, a South Side-based real estate information service.

While the image of Penn Hills is weighted down with stigma associated with aging houses in disrepair, vacant properties and a sizable rental population, the community — covering 19 square miles — is so enormous and diverse that home shoppers can find properties there priced anywhere from around $10,000 to more than $400,000.

“I had a few listings in Penn Hills in the spring and the summer that sold within a week,” said Margie Churchel, a real estate agent for Berkshire Hathaway. “They were very nice houses. If a house is well-kept, in good shape and priced right, it will sell quickly. You get a lot of house for your money in Penn Hills.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Churchel said one of those properties — a three-bedroom, two-bathroom home — was bought by a single woman for $86,900. Another — three-bedroom, one-bathroom house — was bought by a husband and wife for $105,000.

“People move to Penn Hills looking for a good home for the money,” she said. “Penn Hills is very affordable and also very convenient to the Parkway, the Turnpike, Monroeville and Downtown.”

Foreclosures haven’t waned

Still, with a total of 114 mortgage foreclosures in 2014, Penn Hills continues to top the list of Allegheny County communities where families are losing their homes to the bank.

RealSTATs analyzed where municipalities stood in 2014 compared to 2000. It found that at the start of the new millennium — several years before the historic credit crisis of 2008 — Penn Hills had the highest documented number of foreclosures in the county at 68.

Advertise with us

The only municipality that came close to suffering as many foreclosures in 2000 as Penn Hills was McKeesport, which had 64. In 2014, the number of home foreclosures in McKeesport had fallen to 36, according to RealSTATs.

Real estate professionals who work in the Penn Hills market said house flippers have targeted the community over the years because of its high number of foreclosures. The flippers often make necessary repairs and renovations before reselling the houses. Once they are sold, the homes go back on the tax rolls.

But when foreclosed homes are competing with other properties that homeowners are trying to sell, it tends to drag down values. Penn Hills may be the No. 1 community in terms of number of sales, but when it comes to average home price, houses have been appreciating at a much slower pace than homes in other areas of Allegheny County.

According to RealSTATs, the average price of a home in Penn Hills in 2014 was $73,157. The median price of homes in the community last year was $68,000.

The average price of houses in Penn Hills based on recorded sales data is increasing annually at a rate of less than 1 percent, said Dan Murrer, vice president of RealSTATs. “In terms of appreciation, Penn Hills is underperforming compared to a 3 percent average home price increase countywide,” he said.

Advertise with us

That slow rate of home appreciation and the foreclosure rate is a drag on the community, despite its top ranking in home sales, Mr. Murrer said. “Penn Hills is showing signs of distress.”

On the other end of the spectrum, one municipality that shows no signs of distress is Sewickley Heights Borough, which had the No. 1 average home price in 2000 as well in 2014. The average home price in 2014 registered at $1.15 million. Fifteen homes were sold last year in Sewickley Heights for a total dollar volume of $17.3 million. There were zero foreclosures.

Appealing to buyers

The second largest municipality in Allegheny County outside of the city of Pittsburgh, Penn Hills is an older community built around World War II. Many of its original homeowners are in their 80s and 90s now. Those who have not passed away or moved away to senior living facilities are often on fixed incomes and may not be able to afford to make updates and repairs that would increase their home values.

Younger first-time buyers can often purchase those homes at a discount, said Staci Rullo, a real estate agent with Northwoods Realty, who has lived in Penn Hills for 36 years.

Advertise with us

“We have a lot of first-time buyers because, obviously, we are an affordable area to purchase,” Ms. Rullo said. “But we also do have many, many professionals who are maybe second-time buyers that will come back if they’re being transferred back into the community. Or, they just want to be here because they find it to be the best value for their dollar.”

She said one of the challenges Penn Hills has with price appreciation is that homes here do not have the square footage that many surrounding communities have.

“A 1,000-square-foot home is going to have slight appreciation, but not grandiose appreciation because it can’t expand any more than what it is,” she said. “We can’t make a 1,000-square foot home worth $100,000 if all we’re offering is two-bedrooms, a bathroom, a kitchen and a living room.”

But the community does well on another important factor in real estate.

“People like the closeness of Penn Hills to practically everything in the east,” she said. “We’re not boxed into any one particular corner. We can get to Monroeville, Plum and Downtown Pittsburgh in a very short period of time. We have a lot of UPMC people and University of Pittsburgh people who live out here who know the shortcuts to get into the Oakland area.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.