After saving for a down payment back in 1977, Robert and Sheila Sellman were thrilled to buy one of the only available homes for sale in the thriving Turtle Creek community — a two-story, three-bedroom brick house, which at the time they thought would be a nice starter home for them and their two young children.

Both of them grew up in Turtle Creek. Everyone they knew and cared about lived there, and Mr. Sellman had a job that felt secure at Westinghouse Electric Co. “When I worked at Westinghouse, they offered me a job in St. Louis, but I turned it down,” said Mr. Sellman, 71. “I refused to relocate. I wasn’t going to leave all my friends and family behind for a strange city. The money wasn’t worth it.”

But when Westinghouse shut down its East Pittsburgh plant in 1987, Mr. Sellman bounced from one job to another over the years. The couple didn’t want to take a chance on a bigger mortgage for a bigger house. After 38 years, the Sellmans still live in the first and only home they ever bought and they have no plans of moving.

PG graphic: Homeowners who stay put

Advertise with us

(Click image for larger version)

“I don’t know which of us will go first, but I told my wife I’m staying here until I die,” Mr. Sellman said.

While the National Association of Realtors found typical homeowners in the U.S. sell their homes after living in them six to 10 years, Pittsburgh-area residents have a reputation for staying in their homes much longer.

According to the latest U.S. Census data, the percentage of people in the city of Pittsburgh and the Pittsburgh metropolitan area who bought their homes before 1969 and still live there is among the highest in the nation.

The national average for people who still live in homes they bought before 1969 stands at 5.2 percent. That percentage is nearly three times higher for the city of Pittsburgh at 14 percent. For the metro area, 12.5 percent of residents still live in homes they bought at least 46 years ago.

Advertise with us

In comparison, 9.3 percent of residents in the Buffalo, N.Y., metro area can make that claim; 4.2 percent of residents in the Columbus, Ohio, metro area; and only 1.4 percent of people living in the Phoenix metro area. The data was compiled as part of the Census Bureau’s 2014 American Community Survey.

“What you have in Pittsburgh is rare,” said Jessica Lautz, director of survey research and communication for the National Association of Realtors in Washington, D.C. “Pittsburgh is an area where you might have a lot of families who wanted to raise their children in those homes. But they also want to retire in those homes as well and have those homes be the place where they want to host Thanksgiving dinners throughout the years.”

Doing well by staying put

Herman Bowser, 70, of West View, also bought his home in 1977 with his wife, Mary, who is now deceased.

The two-bedroom place they had been renting in Millvale was too small for the couple and their twins. A real estate agent helped them locate the three-bedroom, one-bath home on Georgetown Avenue in West View, which they bought for $28,000.

Advertise with us

The 67-year-old house needed a lot of work. Mr. Bowser, a pipe fitter by trade, was up for the task. Over the years, he remodeled every room.

“We wanted to better ourselves so we moved out here,” he said. “We stayed basically because we couldn’t afford to move, and I’m still here for that reason.”

But he also has strong emotional ties to the house where he and his wife raised three children. Two family members died there from illnesses — a daughter in 1984 and his wife in 1992, he said.

“I’m keeping the house in case my daughter and son-in-law want it later,” Mr. Bowser said. “I’m going to try to stay here as long as I can cut the grass and keep up with the yardwork and housework.”

The two-story, 1,462-square-foot, masonry and frame house has proven to be a good investment over time. The mortgage is paid and county property assessment records value the home at $104,300 for tax purposes.

Advertise with us

Homeowners who frequently relocate stand to come out on the losing end in several ways. Every time they go through the buying and selling process, closing costs and broker commissions can easily add up to thousands of dollars.

Also, the way mortgages are structured, homebuyers pay much more interest in the first few years they own a house. Each time they buy, they restart their payments at the highest end of a loan’s amortization schedule.

A sizable number of Pittsburgh homeowners have been able to pay off their mortgages simply by buying a home and staying put.

Zillow, a national real estate online information company, found in a 2013 study that 38.6 percent of all homeowners in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area are free and clear of mortgage debt, which is the highest percentage of outright homeownership the company found in any of the 30 largest metropolitan areas that it tracks.

‘We never really wanted to move’

Advertise with us

Low turnover is only one reason why Pittsburgh tops the list.

The average price of homes in the region — which currently stands at about $170,000 — has for years been below many other parts of the country, and homeowners here did not get caught up in the cash-back refinancing frenzy or the buy-high-and-sell-higher mentality that swept the nation during the real estate boom years.

Daniel Murrer, vice president of RealSTATs, a real estate information service based on the South Side, said Pittsburghers tend to stay in their homes longer because the city has more generational roots.

“You have generations living near one another,” he said. “You’ve got lots of Italians, Slovaks, Germans, Polish and Russian families here, and being close to family is important. Those people also tend to be fiscally conservative. They have a strong work ethic and they save up to buy something.”

Mr. Murrer looked at data for more than 436,000 homes in Allegheny County and found 31 percent of homeowners have owned their homes for at least 20 years and 43 percent for 10 years or less. Areas of the region with more recent construction activity — the west, city and north neighborhoods — have higher percentages of short-term homeowners. The more built-up east and south communities have a higher percentage of long-term homeowners.

Advertise with us

Some of the longest tenured homeowners in the Pittsburgh area reside in a quiet hamlet along the Ohio River just outside of Sewickley known as Haysville.

It is a small, tight-knit community that has not seen much change, other than paved roads and city water, since the 1800s. Many of the same families still live there and everybody looks out for everybody else.

“If a stranger comes around, we find out what he’s up to,” said Lou Paff, 78, who still lives in a home his parents bought 72 years ago, although he did move out in 1959 but moved back 15 years ago with his wife Catherine, 68.

He recalled studying in a one-room schoolhouse at the intersection of River Road and Ohio River Boulevard in the 1940s and going fishing with his good friend Ronnie Karcher, 71, who still lives down the road.

Mr. Karcher was born in the house he lives in, which means it has been his home for 71 years because he has never lived anywhere else.

Advertise with us

Four generations of his family lived in the house on South Avenue, starting with his grandparents — who bought the three-bedroom, two-bath house for $750 in the late 1800s — and continuing with his parents and his two daughters, who were raised there but have since moved out. Mr. Karcher and his wife, Mary, 71, have no mortgage. They get by with the income he brings in doing small construction work and rebuilding houses in the Sewickley area.

“We never really wanted to move,” he said. “Everything is quiet here and we don’t have any crime.

“A lot of my relatives — my granddad and dad — all died here in this house. I think that’s the reason we haven’t sold,” he said. “There’s so many memories here and it’s something you don’t want to sell.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.