Perhaps this was UPMC’s end game all along.
Step one: In an effort to fracture Highmark’s historical market share dominance, force tens of thousands of health insurance customers away from Highmark Health by telling customers over a period of months that they are sure to lose access to UPMC doctors come Jan. 1.
Step two: At the final hour, try to keep as many remaining Highmark customers as possible — and try to keep them out of Highmark’s own hospital system, the Allegheny Health Network — by leveraging the access loopholes built into the summer separation agreement between the two Pittsburgh health giants.
Or, perhaps, UPMC simply gambled and lost.
Either way, UPMC now appears willing to allow all Highmark-insured customers now under UPMC care through their doors after Jan. 1, permitting them to see their current doctors and be billed at in-network rates — even at those hospitals and practices that are, technically, out of network starting next year, when the long-term full-access contract between the two finally runs out.
In an email sent out Friday morning, Steven Shapiro, UPMC chief medical and scientific officer, told his health system physicians that starting Thursday, UPMC will launch an outreach campaign in an effort to keep existing Highmark insurance patients under UPMC care. UPMC will be calling patients by phone, informing them of their “continuity of care” rights outlined in the consent decrees, and inviting them in for an appointment to discuss their care options.
Read More
“That UPMC and Highmark would try to solicit patients was an inevitable outcome of the ‘divorce.’ It will continue into the future” despite the Jan. 1 separation date, said Stephen Foreman, associate professor of economics and health administration at Robert Morris University.
“The UPMC letter further muddies the waters. I wonder how many patients really understand their options under the consent decree,” he said.
The options, for under-65 individual and employer-sponsored Highmark customers wishing to see their out-of-network UPMC physician, are these:
• There’s a “safety net” loophole, which says certain UPMC patients who are Highmark subscribers can continue to see UPMC doctors for one more year, so long as they are “unable to find alternative physicians and services in their locality.”
• And there’s a broader “continuity-of-care” provision, which runs the duration of the five-year consent decree, and says that “Highmark and UPMC mutually agree that the continuation of care of a Highmark member in the midst of a course of treatment at UPMC shall be on an in-network basis at in-network rates.”
It appears UPMC wants that continuity-of-care loophole to be as big as possible — Dr. Shapiro’s Friday email to physicians said UPMC “will begin calling Highmark commercial subscribers [to explain that] any Highmark patients under your care, whether it is for preventive, acute, or chronic care, have the right to continue in your care at in-network rates.”
At that point, it’s up to Highmark to contest the claims, if it wishes. If Highmark disputes the opinion of the treating UPMC physician, and disputes that the nature of the care is “continuing,” the Department of Health or a designated representative will “review the matter and make a final, non-appealable determination.”
But after several years of campaigning for full access to the UPMC network — and after making UPMC out to be the villain who was cutting off Highmark access and turning away cash-paying Community Blue customers — it’s doubtful Highmark now wants to play the role of the heavy. And even if Highmark does want to fill beds and still customers at its own Allegheny Health Network, there are still capacity questions at AHN — can it absorb the volume of, say, thousands of obstetrical deliveries defecting from Magee-Women’s Hospital?
In other words: Divorce? What divorce? UPMC wants to keep Highmark patients, even if they are technically out-of-network. Highmark needs a place to park patients, and it has spent the autumn telling individual and corporate clients that about 80 percent of UPMC’s 3,600 employed physicians will be in-network, either because they work at an in-network exception facility, or because the physician splits time between UPMC and in-network community hospitals.
And with just 18 days until the full-access reimbursement contract between Highmark and UPMC expires, meaning Highmark’s under-65 customers won’t have contractual access to most of UPMC’s Allegheny County hospitals, the terms of the breakup are as confusing as ever for Highmark customers — even if, at the end of the day, not much changes for Highmark customers who want to gain access to UPMC’s East End hospitals and clinics.
Not much changes in terms of cost structure, either, supposing Highmark and UPMC can play nice: According to the consent decree, except for certain specialty rates now being negotiated, starting Jan. 1, “rates for all in-network services covered in this consent decree [shall] revert to the last mutually agreed upon rates or fees by UPMC and Highmark.”
Good news all around, right?
“I would like to say this is an opportunity for employers to finally exhale, but I don't think they can do that quite yet,” said Jessica L. Brooks, executive director, Pittsburgh Business Group on Health, an advocacy group with 90 member employers. “On the surface, the UPMC campaign sounds like a great step in the right direction. [But] employers have asked for clarity for months now. They have now made their health plan selections, conducted open enrollment, educated their employees, and now UPMC wants to reach out to them.
“Where were they five months ago? … What does in-network mean [and cost] after Jan. 1?” Ms. Brooks said. “It would be advantageous for UPMC to engage the employer community,” and not just individual patients, to ensure access and clarity for the Pittsburgh region.
Highmark has about 3 million total members in its Western Pennsylvania market and, as of last year, controlled 43 percent of the Allegheny County commercial market, according to a third-party market analysis conducted for UPMC. Is the Friday email evidence that UPMC’s big gamble didn’t pay off — that neither UPMC Health Plan nor the national health carriers were able to peel away as many Highmark customers as the UPMC hospital network had hoped? Or was this UPMC’s plan all along?
“This has been a bait-and-switch on a grand scale,” said state Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, a frequent critic of UPMC who is vocal about health care issues. “What UPMC has been doing is sowing enormous anxiety, to drive as much business as they can to their health plan,” and away from Highmark’s plans.
But “once that enrollment period is over, it doesn’t seem to be in [UPMC’s] best interest to lose Highmark customers now,” he said. Mr. Frankel said the outreach campaign, and the idea that UPMC doctors will be open to seeing Highmark patients long-term, “is a good thing for consumers … but to have put this community through such a tortuous process appears to me to have been a cynical play” at trying to drive down Highmark’s market share while still trying to capture Highmark’s reimbursement dollars.
Mr. Foreman of RMU suggested that the UPMC phone campaign might be a last-ditch attempt by UPMC to assuage its practices and doctors, particularly the Allegheny County physicians who would stand to lose a big chunk of business if all of their Highmark patients disappeared overnight.
In its audited fiscal 2014 financial report, UPMC said that 31 percent of its $6 billion in net patient revenue, or about $1.9 billion, comes from Highmark reimbursement payments. About half of that money, about $1 billion, could be at stake for UPMC if their Highmark customers are forced to go elsewhere.
“What hasn’t been discussed in much detail is what happens to UPMC physicians. If they lose substantial patient volume, what will they do?”
What they’ll do, it turns out, is interpret the continuity-of-care clause quite liberally.
“The Medical Society is pleased that so much attention is being paid to continuity of care,” said John Krah, executive director of the Allegheny County Medical Society, which represents local physicians. But at best, the liberal Highmark access policy “is an extension of our existing situation. At some point, the community needs to know, am I in-network or out-of-network?”
Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.