With the UPMC-Highmark separation now only a week away, the two Pittsburgh health giants are headed to binding arbitration after they were unable to agree to terms on physician contracts.

In a letter Tuesday to UPMC president and CEO Jeffrey Romoff and Highmark president and CEO David Holmberg, top state officials expressed their disappointment at the impasse “in particular given the general agreement of the parties on core underlying principles” in consent decrees reached in June.

Although the letter — signed by Insurance Commissioner Michael Consedine, Health Secretary Michael Wolf and James Donahue III in the state attorney general’s office — does not specify what the disagreements are, the region’s largest health provider and its largest insurer have argued for months about which UPMC physicians will remain in Highmark’s insurance network under what circumstances.

Last month, the state intervened after Highmark abruptly terminated the contracts of 700 UPMC physicians the Pittsburgh insurer said was meant to clarify for members which UPMC physicians would remain in network after the contract expires Dec. 31.

Advertise with us

UPMC soon after announced that Highmark’s Medicare Advantage products would be out-of-network for its physicians and facilities, raising the specter that those in Highmark’s popular plan would face higher costs if they continued to see their UPMC physician.

In a Nov. 26 letter, state officials told both parties to put those moves on hold “until the resolution process has been completed.”

An insurance department spokeswoman declined to elaborate Wednesday on the latest letter or specify what the remaining disagreements are about. Tuesday’s letter said the state will be filing a motion in court to set a status conference.

“Finally, we want to remind the parties that you have agreed to suspend any contract termination,” the letter stated, “and continue to provide treatment for certain Highmark members as in-network pending the resolution of this matter through the dispute resolution process” set out in the consent decrees.

Paul Wood, spokesman for UPMC, said Wednesday, “UPMC, likewise, is disappointed by the failure of the mediation to change Highmark’s mind about terminating the contracts under which UPMC physicians would provide specified services as agreed to under the consent decrees.

Advertise with us

“The real losers, should those contracts be terminated by Highmark, will be the patients and subscribers to whom Highmark has promised those services.”

Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger, meanwhile, said the insurer will “follow the road map set out in the consent decrees” and cooperate with state officials to resolve any disagreement. With about 3 million members in Western Pennsylvania, Highmark has 43 percent of the commercial market in Allegheny County.

Although the state action seemingly keeps the status quo intact, the unresolved dispute probably will add to the unease for Highmark members who see UPMC physicians.

“Physicians and patients continue to hope that Highmark and UPMC will find it possible to reach agreements on the terms of their interactions,” said John Krah, executive director of the Allegheny County Medical Society, the professional organization of local physicians.

“It is unfortunate that they have not been able to and that the state must invoke the binding arbitration process. This contributes to the ongoing anxiety that many are experiencing. Patients deserve to understand what insurance coverage they have.”