Creating fresh uncertainty for southwestern Pennsylvania’s under-65 health consumers, the state Department of Health is contesting UPMC’s position that nearly all Highmark Health customers should be able to see their UPMC physicians, into 2015 and beyond, for non-serious, “preventive” care issues at in-network prices.
In a letter to the CEOs of UPMC and Highmark, the state sought to tamp down expectations that Highmark customers with workplace-sponsored or individually purchased health plans might be able to maintain relationships with their longtime UPMC physicians over the next several years.
The letter, issued just as the Jan. 1 split between Highmark and UPMC was set to take effect, stems from an ongoing disagreement between the two Pittsburgh health titans about what, precisely, constitutes “continuity of care.”
In the summer 2014 consent decree that governs the breakup of Pittsburgh’s dominant health insurer and its largest hospital network, the two parties agreed that “the continuation of care of a Highmark member in the midst of a course of treatment at UPMC shall be on an in-network basis, at in-network rates.”
How to define a “course of treatment” would be left up to the health network and its physicians, and the patients themselves, the consent decrees said.
In a mid-December email, Steven Shapiro, UPMC chief medical and scientific officer, told all health system physicians that UPMC would soon be “calling Highmark commercial subscribers [to explain that] any Highmark patients under your care, whether it is for preventive, acute or chronic care, have the right to continue in your care at in-network rates. We want to assure that your patients understand their rights under the consent decrees.”
Read More
But the Department of Health, in a Dec. 30 letter to UPMC CEO Jeffery Romoff and Highmark CEO David Holmberg, wrote that UPMC’s position was an overly broad interpretation of the consent decree’s “continuity of care” provision, and the interpretation that isn’t historically supported by the department’s own enforcement practices, or by the National Committee for Quality of Assurance, a nonprofit health care quality and accreditation group.
“The concept of continuity of care has historically been used in the context of allowing for a period of time for the health care subscriber to find a replacement provider [that] is in the insurer’s network,” the letter said. “We generally view the continuity of care provision in the consent decrees as providing a transition period for Highmark subscribers who were in active treatment on or shortly after the Jan. 1, 2015, effective date of the Highmark-UPMC separation,” and the Department of Health will adjudicate Highmark’s appeals to UPMC’s in-network, continuity-of-care claims through that legal understanding.
“Unless Highmark and UPMC come to a different agreement, patients who have simply seen physicians for basic preventive care, non-serious, or non-recurrent illnesses, injuries, etc., would not be eligible for continuity-of-care [treatment] under” the consent decree, the letter said.
That interpretation runs counter to what UPMC told its physicians in its mid-December email, and also runs counter to what some UPMC physicians have been telling their Highmark patients — that existing patients may be able to have UPMC clinical access through mid-2019 — in the weeks since that email was sent. (New Highmark customers, and those who have never used a UPMC physician or have a health plan that specifically carves out UPMC doctors, would still be locked out of UPMC’s Allegheny County network.)
Part of the problem is that continuity of care is hard to define.
The consent decree isn’t specific as to what qualifies as continued care, or what constitutes a course of treatment, except to say that “the need for a continuing course of treatment shall be determined, in the first instance, by the patient's treating physician acting in consultation with and in accordance with the wishes of the patient.”
The Dec. 30 Health Department letter isn’t much clearer: A course of treatment might include any doctor-patient relationship “where a patient has regular visits with a practitioner to monitor the status of an illness or medical condition … this scope of care usually includes clinically related services for the specific condition from the onset of symptoms until the treatment for that diagnosis is complete.”
So if a primary care physician is monitoring your blood pressure, would that qualify as a “medical condition” that allows for continued UPMC care? What about cholesterol levels? Does a weight problem count, or is obesity a “non-serious” and “non-recurrent” condition?
UPMC says all of those conditions could potentially trigger continuity of care protection, should the patient wish it.
But a Highmark spokesman said Monday that the health insurer is siding with the Health Department on the issue.
“We firmly agree with [Department of Health Secretary Michael] Wolf’s perspective on continuity of care,” Aaron Billger said. “It’s consistent with the intent of the consent decree.”
Preventive care, he said, “has not been considered, in the past, a continuity of care issue.” Asked if Highmark intends to vigorously contest instances in which UPMC physicians try to retain a Highmark customer under the continuity of care clause, Mr. Billger said that it’s Highmark’s hope that the health insurer and UPMC can come to an agreement on operational guidelines before it comes to that.
“Highmark’s intent is to not have the patient be in the middle,” he said.
In the letter, Mr. Wolf (along with two co-signatories, Attorney General Kathleen Kane and Insurance Commissioner Michael Consedine) urged Highmark and UPMC to get their act together.
“Disagreement cannot persist over such a critical issue for consumers and patients. If Highmark and UPMC cannot agree on a definition of continuity of care by Friday, Jan. 9, then they shall notify the commonwealth parties and we will move this issue to the formal dispute resolution process as provided under the consent decrees, beginning with mediation.”
UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said Highmark is trying to have it both ways — taking a narrow view of the continuity of care provision while at the same time advertising broad, continued access to UPMC physicians in its own marketing campaign.
“Highmark used [the promise of UPMC access] on all of their marketing materials to entice people to stay with Highmark,” he said. “We intend to hold Highmark to that promise.”
Mr. Wood also said it’s unclear why the Health Department felt compelled to send the warning letters, then issue them publicly, when the consent decree already has a built-in appeals process for handling disagreements between Highmark and UPMC on the continuity of care issue: If Highmark disputes the opinion of the UPMC physician, and disputes that the nature of the patient care is “continuing,” the Department of Health or a designated representative will “review the matter and make a final, non-appealable determination.”
Asked why the Health Department issued the letter, a spokeswoman said that the state agencies “want to ensure the people of Western Pennsylvania understand the continuity of care provision in the consent decrees and what this means to their health care … we want to ensure that the need for clear, simple and understandable rules for patients and their medical providers is understood by both parties.
“It’s critically important that there is not confusion in the marketplace over this issue, as there has been with other issues.”
That confusion has been persistent throughout the slow-motion breakup of UPMC and Highmark. Since early 2011, UPMC has been saying that it didn’t want to sign a new, full-access contract with Highmark, largely because Highmark was contemplating the purchase of the financially distressed West Penn Allegheny Health System, the region’s second-largest health system and a competitor to UPMC.
The 10-year, full-access contract between Highmark and UPMC was set to expire in summer 2012, with a one-year run-out period to July 1, 2013; that contract was then extended to Dec. 31, 2014, after which point Highmark’s non-Medicare, non-Medicaid patients would lose full network access to UPMC.
Last summer, UPMC and Highmark arrived at a settlement that gave Highmark customers access to all of the UPMC hospitals and clinics outside of Allegheny County, plus Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh, UPMC Mercy (until June 2015, with a run-out of one year), and access to UPMC oncology services.
But access to UPMC’s core hospitals, such as Shadyside, Presbyterian, Montefiore, Magee Womens, and UPMC East, and physicians practicing at those facilities, are supposed to be out-of-network for Highmark’s commercial members.
Highmark has about 1.2 million commercial insurance members living in its Western Pennsylvania market and, as of 2013, controlled 43 percent of the Allegheny County market, accounting for about one-fifth of UPMC’s patient revenue base.
Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.