An O’Hara developer appears to have abandoned plans for a six-story apartment building and grocery in Bloomfield, eight months after the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment rejected the relief it needed for the project.

Echo Realty’s decision came in the form of an announcement Thursday by Giant Eagle that it had reached an agreement with the developer to “transition ownership of the property” at 4401 Liberty Ave. now occupied by Community Supermarket.

“After careful consideration of the many factors contributing to the site’s redevelopment, we were pleased to come to an agreement that ensures that the Community Market continues to meet its customers’ needs without interruption,” Dan Donovan, Giant Eagle senior director of public relations, said in a statement.

He declined further comment. A spokeswoman for Echo Realty could not immediately be reached for comment. Daniel P. Craig, attorney for the Bloomfield Development Corp., which gave conditional support to the venture, had no comment.

Advertise with us

However, two sources close to the proposed project confirmed that Echo had dropped plans for the development, which included 248 apartments, a 28,000-square-foot Giant Eagle, 10,000 square feet of retail, and a 318-space parking garage.

In November, the zoning board rejected the variances related to size needed by Echo to move forward with the development, leaving the project in limbo.

The developer sought the relief so it could build to 75 feet and six stories in a Local Neighborhood Commercial zoning district. The maximum height allowed is 45 feet and three stories.

In rejecting the request, the three-member zoning board stated that Echo had “not presented sufficient, substantial or credible evidence to meet its burden with respect to” the variances it was requesting.

It also was unpersuaded by Echo’s argument that the developer needed the height and the number of stories to generate a single-digit return and make the project economically viable.

Advertise with us

In its ruling, the board maintained that any asserted hardship and costs appeared to be related “more directly to the magnitude of the development proposed and less to any unique conditions of the subject property.”

Echo, an affiliate of Giant Eagle, appealed the decision to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, where the case is still pending. At one point, it appeared that a settlement might be in the works but nothing came of that.

In its appeal, Echo argued that it needed the zoning relief in part because of “additional and extraordinary construction costs” related to the site’s “unique topographic and subsurface conditions.”

It also cited Bloomfield’s exclusionary zoning requirements that 10% of the units be set aside for households at or below 50% of the area median income. Echo had said that the affordable component would cost it nearly $8.6 million, requiring an increase in the number of market rate units to make up for that.

While the Bloomfield Development Corporation backed the project with conditions, several residents who lived near the site opposed it. They maintained that Echo could do a viable project without the need for a height variance.

Advertise with us

Located across from the Bloomfield Bridge, the site has housed the Community Supermarket since 2020. According to Giant Eagle, the store employs 28 people. Before Community Supermarket, the site was home to a Shursave.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.