The Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment has shot down a plan to build a massive apartment complex at the former Shursave site in Bloomfield, leaving the project, which included a Giant Eagle, in limbo.
While the board approved a special exception for the grocery, it rejected the variances sought by developer Echo Realty to erect a six-story building at the site to house 248 apartments, the Giant Eagle, and a 318-space underground parking garage.
Echo needed the variances to build to 75 feet and six stories in a Local Neighborhood Commercial zoning district where the maximum height permitted is 45 feet and three stories. The building would have been nearly twice the size permitted.
In its 11-page decision, the three-member zoning board stated that Echo had “not presented sufficient, substantial or credible evidence to meet its burden with respect to all of the standards for dimensional variances, as required.”
While Echo argued that the scale was needed to generate the single-digit return required to make the project economically viable, the board stated that it was “not persuaded the variances requested are the minimum that could afford relief.”
“The applicant indicated that the additional height proposed is related to addressing the geotechnical costs and providing affordable units. However, it appears that any asserted hardship and costs relate more directly to the magnitude of the development proposed and less to any unique conditions of the subject property,” it stated.
Read More
Kevin McKeegan, Echo’s attorney, declined comment, referring questions to the developer. Phil Bishop, Echo’s senior vice president of design and development, could not be reached for comment.
Asked if the board’s decision would be appealed to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, Mr. McKeegan said that is “to be determined.”
The proposal included a 26,000- to 28,000-square-foot Giant Eagle. Of the 248 apartments, 25 would have been designated for households at or below 50% of the area median income.
Echo, an affiliate of Giant Eagle, also proposed another 10,000 square feet of retail as part of the development. The site, on Liberty Avenue at the entrance to Bloomfield just beyond the Bloomfield Bridge, now hosts a 36,000-square-foot Community Supermarket.
During the August 10 zoning board hearing, Echo stated that it had considered other alternatives for the site, from one involving retail only to a scaled down mixed use project featuring 190 units that could be built at the allowable height, but found them lacking.
Mr. Bishop said soil conditions, the garage, and plans for 25 affordable apartments drove up the cost of the project.
The affordable units, he told the board, would cost Echo nearly $8.6 million. To make that up, the developer had to increase the number of market rate units, he explained.
While appearing to be somewhat sympathetic to the argument, the board noted that the affordable housing requirement applied to all multi-unit residential developments in Bloomfield, which has adopted an inclusionary zoning mandate. As a result, the requirement and the costs associated with it “are not unique to the subject property and do not constitute an ‘unnecessary hardship’” that would necessitate relief, the panel stated.
“The board is also mindful of the challenges associated with developing affordable residential units. However, these challenges require legislative solutions, which are not within the board’s authority,” it stated.
It also concluded that the proposed scale of the development essentially ignored residential compatibility standards that mandate additional height and setback requirements based on the proximity of a residential district.
While the zoning code permits waivers, it does so, the board found, only in instances where a taller structure is located between the proposed development and the residential district, which was not the case with the Echo project.
“The board does not have the authority to disregard these legislative determinations and to alter the code’s height and residential compatibility standards to allow deviations of the order of magnitude proposed here, particularly where the applicant did not present sufficient evidence with respect to all of the variance standards for the substantial variances requested,” it stated.
The project had the backing of the Bloomfield Development Corporation but came under fire from several residents who argued that it was too big.
Though Echo tried to tie its request for relief to the board’s decision to grant a special exception and variances related to height for a 10-story apartment building proposed on S. Aiken Avenue in Shadyside, the panel countered that “each property is unique” and that “no zoning case can be viewed as ‘precedential’ with respect to another.”
It pointed out that in the Shadyside case, the proposed development was located next door to a nonconforming 10-story residential building.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.