An O’Hara developer pressed its case Thursday to build a massive grocery and apartment complex at a key entrance into Bloomfield, arguing that the size is required to make the project economically viable.

During a hearing before the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment, Echo Realty maintained that the scale, nearly twice as high as that permitted, is a must to generate the single-digit return it needs for such a development.

Echo is proposing a complex of up to six stories that would feature a Giant Eagle, 248 apartments and a 318-space underground parking garage on the Liberty Avenue site just off the Bloomfield Bridge that now houses a Community Supermarket and a former Shursave IGA.

It is seeking a variance from the three-member zoning board to allow it to build to 75 feet and six stories in a district where the maximum height permitted is 45 feet and three stories.

Advertise with us

Phil Bishop, Echo’s senior vice president of design and development, told the zoning board that the developer looked at doing retail only as well as a mixed-use project featuring about 190 apartments that it could build at the allowed height but found them and other alternatives lacking.

“We nipped. We tucked. We cut. We shaved. We got to where we are today, not just to increase our bottom line” but to get “what we could” within the constraints of the site, he said.

Mr. Bishop said soil conditions, as well as the plans for 25 affordable apartment units and the garage, conspired to drive up the cost of the development.

Because of the soil conditions, caissons will have to be driven 30 to 50 feet into the ground as part of the foundation, regardless of what is built.

The construction method plus the underground garage will add $7.3 million to the cost of the development, bringing the total price to about $84 million, compared to $62 million for the 190-unit by-right development.

Advertise with us

But the per unit for the 190 apartments would be $360,829 compared to $300,932 for the 248, Mr. Bishop said. He added that a “good goal” in trying to determine whether an apartment project is financially viable is a per-unit cost of about $300,000.

Based on that standard, a 190-unit complex would not be viable in today’s residential market, he asserted.

Adding to the financial challenges is that the affordable units will cost Echo nearly $8.6 million, Mr. Bishop said. To make up for the loss, it had to increase the number of market rate units, he explained.

“In order to support that lost income, we needed to build into our design approximately 28 more units, thus increasing the height, thus asking for the variance we’re asking for today to offset the affordability requirement.

Echo, which is affiliated with Giant Eagle, has offered to make 25 units available to households at or below 50% of the area median income. Those units will rent for an average of $823 a month compared to average rents of $2,250 a month for the market-rate apartments.

Advertise with us

While the complex will dwarf the mainly residential area immediately surrounding it, Kevin McKeegan, Echo’s attorney, argued that it is actually not that much out of context with buildings farther up Liberty Avenue because of a 35-foot change in grade.

“What we’re trying to show here is that because of the slope conditions on Liberty going downhill ... that the buildings are not dramatically different, not out of context with what already is in the neighborhood,” he said.

But zoning board chairwoman Alice Mitinger doesn’t seem to buy the argument.

“The height limitation is the height limitation. The height limitation doesn’t say that if you have a lower site you get to go as high as the highest elevation up the street,” she said. “You’re proposing a building that’s twice the height that’s permitted.”

The Giant Eagle being proposed at the site will be 26,000 to 28,000 square feet, smaller than the 36,000-square-foot Community Supermarket. But, with efficiencies in grocery operations, the difference will be “irrelevant,” Mr. Bishop said,

Advertise with us

Echo also is proposing another 10,000 square feet of retail on the east side of the complex near Ella Street. Of the apartments, 56 will be studios, 127 one-bedroom, and 65 two-bedroom.

The Bloomfield Development Corporation, the registered neighborhood group, has backed the project with conditions, including a commitment by Echo to accept housing choice vouchers.

“We’ve been working on this for about 2½ years with them and they have consistently moved toward a community reflective project,” Executive Director Christina Howell said.

However, several Bloomfield residents testified against the increased height of the development, including Amy Burris, who lives on Gangwish Street adjacent to the site.

“I will be literally surrounded by brick walls in my house,” she said.

Advertise with us

She added the height is “quite exceptional,” pointing out that there are no other buildings that tall on Liberty in Bloomfield.

“I believe that your zoning rules are there for a reason and I think they ought to be respected in this case,” she said.

Likewise, Alan Guenther, who lives on Ella Street, argued that Echo can do a viable project without any variances for height. He said the developer can generate another $2 million in rents through the additional units it is seeking through the zoning relief.

“We think this project should be weed whacked back so that it doesn’t overburden the narrow, spindly streets in this area,” he said, insisting that the development can be redesigned to better serve the community.

In rebuttal, Mr. McKeegan said the earlier plan for 190 units was conceptual in nature and did not take into account the added costs associated with the soil conditions or the affordable housing.

Advertise with us

In addition to the height variance, Echo is seeking a special exception to build the Giant Eagle. While groceries are a permitted use in the district, they still need approval from the zoning board.

The board gave no timetable for making a decision.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com