Five months after an O’Hara developer challenged a city zoning ruling that blocked plans for a six-story apartment building and grocery in Bloomfield, a settlement could be in the works.

Disclosure of a possible resolution came in an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court consent motion related to the appeal Echo Realty filed after the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment rejected the variances it needed for the project.

The motion involved a request to extend the deadlines to file briefs in the appeal. They were due May 6.

In making the request, Brittany M. Bloam, an attorney for Echo, stated that the parties “continue to engage in negotiations to resolve this appeal.” She did not elaborate.

Advertise with us

Neither she nor Kevin McKeegan, another Echo attorney, could be reached for comment Monday. Daniel P. Craig, attorney for Bloomfield Development Corporation, which intervened in the appeal, declined comment, saying he was not authorized to speak. The community group supported the development with conditions. Also involved is the city law department, acting on behalf of the zoning board and the city.

It’s not known whether the negotiations involved a change in the size of the project, which opponents maintained was too big, or some other type of settlement.

Echo proposed building a six-story structure with 248 apartments at the former Shursave site on Liberty Avenue near the Bloomfield Bridge. The complex also was to include a 28,000-square-foot Giant Eagle, 10,000 square feet of retail and a 318-space parking garage.

The project required variances related to size, specifically to build to 75 feet and six stories in a Local Neighborhood Commercial zoning district where the maximum height allowed is 45 feet and three stories.

Echo Realty proposed a 28,000-square-foot grocery, 248 apartments, and more than 300 parking spaces at the former Shursave site in Bloomfield. (AE7)

In rejecting the relief last November, the three-member zoning board ruled that Echo had “not presented sufficient, substantial or credible evidence to meet its burden with respect to” the variances it was requesting.

Advertise with us

While Echo maintained that the size of the development was needed to generate a single-digit return and to make the project economically viable, the zoning board was not persuaded.

It stated in its ruling that any asserted hardship and costs appeared to be related “more directly to the magnitude of the development proposed and less to any unique conditions of the subject property.”

In its appeal, Echo contended that it needed the relief because of “additional and extraordinary construction costs” related to the “unique topographic and subsurface conditions” at the site.

It also cited the neighborhood’s exclusionary zoning requirement that 10% of the residential units — 25 total — be set aside for households at or below 50% of the area median income.

During the zoning board hearing, one Echo representative testified that the affordable units would cost the developer nearly $8.6 million and that it had to increase the number of market-rate units to make up for that.

Advertise with us

On the other hand, several residents who lived near the site and opposed the development maintained that Echo could still do a viable project without the need for a height variance.

Bloomfield Development, meanwhile, tied its support to conditions, one being a commitment by Echo to accept housing choice vouchers.

The former Shursave site currently houses a Community Supermarket.

In response to the Echo consent motion, Common Pleas Judge Mary C. McGinley gave all of the parties involved until June 6 to file briefs, provided that the city files a certified record related to the appeal by May 20.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.