An O’Hara developer isn’t giving up its bid to build a large six-story apartment building and grocery at the former Shursave site in Bloomfield after it was rejected by the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment.

Echo Realty is appealing to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court the zoning board’s Nov. 6 ruling denying the variances it needed to move forward with the project.

In an eight-page appeal filed Monday, Echo affiliate Bloomfield Bridge Associates described the decision as “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, not supported by substantial evidence, and contrary to law.”

It is asking a judge to reverse the zoning board and to issue an order “directing that the project be approved as depicted in the plans and exhibits.”

Advertise with us

Echo proposed building a six-story building at the Liberty Avenue site near the Bloomfield Bridge featuring 248 apartments, a 28,000-square-foot Giant Eagle, a 318-space underground parking garage and 10,000 square feet of retail and restaurant space.

But to do so, it needed variances related to size, specifically to build to 75 feet and six stories in a Local Neighborhood Commercial zoning district where the maximum height allowed is 45 feet and three stories.

Echo Realty proposed a 28,000-square-foot grocery, 248 apartments and more than 300 parking spaces at the former Shursave site in Bloomfield.

While Echo had argued that the additional height was needed for the project to be financially feasible given an affordable housing mandate and topography challenges, the board wasn’t convinced. It stated in its ruling that it appeared “any asserted hardship and costs relate more directly to the magnitude of the development proposed and less to any unique conditions of the subject property.”

Echo took exception to that assertion in its appeal.

The developer maintained that it presented “credible and unrefuted evidence” that the variances “were the minimum that would allow for the economically feasible development of the property, due to the additional and extraordinary construction costs necessary to address the unique topographic and subsurface conditions at the property.”

Advertise with us

It likewise argued that those financial hardships were aggravated by the neighborhood’s inclusionary zoning requirement that 10% of the residential units — 25 in all — be set aside for households at or below 50% of the area median income.

During the August 10 zoning board hearing, Phil Bishop, Echo’s senior vice president of design and development, testified that the affordable units would cost the developer nearly $8.6 million. To make up for that, he stated, it had to increase the number of market rate units.

Echo, in its appeal, contended that the zoning board erred in not taking into account the financial hardship it would incur because of the affordable housing mandate. The board, in its decision, found that the requirement didn’t constitute an “unnecessary hardship” that necessitated relief.

The developer also asserted in the appeal that it had presented “credible and unrefuted evidence” that the variances would not adversely affect the neighborhood’s character or the public welfare.

“The project will not result in adverse traffic impacts and sufficient parking will be available onsite. [Echo] also presented evidence that the building design follows the surrounding built environment, and comports with the neighborhood’s expressed desires and plans for development of this gateway to Bloomfield,” it stated.

Advertise with us

It claimed that with variances involving height, zoning boards can consider factors like financial hardships created by the work needed to comply with zoning requirements and the characteristics of the surrounding neighborhood.

“The zoning board erred in finding that [Echo] failed to sustain its burden to present sufficient evidence supporting the elements of a variance,” it added.

Echo representatives could not be reached for comment Tuesday. Kevin McKeegan, the company’s attorney, declined comment.

The Bloomfield Development Corporation, the neighborhood's registered community organization, supported the project with conditions, including a commitment by Echo to accept housing choice vouchers.

On the other hand, several residents near the site testified against it, arguing that it was too big while maintaining that Echo could still do a viable project without the need for height variances.

Advertise with us

The site currently houses a 36,000-square-foot Community Supermarket.

In its appeal, Echo maintained that the zoning board erred in applying legal standards to its variance requests related to height “that are different from those applied by the ZBA to dimensional variances requests for development projects” similar to Echo’s project.

The developer did not specifically cite such an instance. But at the zoning board hearing, it noted that members had granted height variances for a 10-story apartment building on South Aiken Avenue in Shadyside.

In its ruling, the board countered that “each property is unique” and that “no zoning case can be viewed as ‘precedential’ with respect to another.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com