They’re coming down.
Three years after rejecting a developer’s bid to demolish four Downtown buildings, the Pittsburgh Planning Commission reversed course Tuesday and granted its consent — despite pleas by local preservationists to save the structures.
Barring an appeal, developer Michael Troiani will be able to raze the three dilapidated buildings on Market Street, including the former Froggy’s restaurant, and another at 209 First Ave., and install four bocce courts in their place.
The commission’s 5-0 vote is the latest turn in Mr. Troiani’s four-year battle, waged mainly in the courts, to tear down the buildings.
A year ago, it appeared as if he had lost after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court declined to review two Commonwealth Court rulings barring him from razing the structures. That came after the Planning Commission, in 2020, rebuffed his request to take down the buildings because they are part of the Firstside Historic District listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
But it also left the door open for Mr. Troiani to return with a formal development plan for the site, because such a proposal is needed as part of any proposed demolition.
Read More
In the fall, Mr. Troiani did just that — tying the demolitions to a development plan calling for the installation of the bocce courts as well as a possible pickleball court in a later phase.
That’s nowhere near as elaborate as what he was contemplating more than three years ago when he first wanted to demolish the buildings: a 30-story tower that would have featured offices, residences, retail and parking.
Complicating the situation was that the city, while seeking to preserve the Market Street buildings even though it had condemned them as unsafe, has been pressing Mr. Troiani to demolish 209 First. But the developer has argued that for safety reasons he can’t tear down that building without first razing those on Market.
During Tuesday’s hearing, the main concerns of the commission, whose makeup has changed some since the 2020 vote, had more to do with aesthetic aspects of the bocce court proposal, such as the fencing surrounding it, than the building demolitions. That’s even though representatives for Preservation Pittsburgh and the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation urged the commission to once again block the demolitions during their testimony.
Melissa McSwigan of Preservation Pittsburgh said the demolitions would wipe out a large swath of historic buildings in the national Firstside district. She argued that it may be possible to save the buildings while at the same time installing bocce courts around them.
“This possibility should be explored before rushing into demolition,” she testified. “It would be a shame to see a historic Downtown block erased because there hasn’t been the stewardship or a creative approach taken.”
Karamagi Rujumba, of the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation, said the buildings are “significant” and reflect the historic scale of real estate in the district. He stressed that foundation officials “fundamentally disagree” with Mr. Troiani’s contention that the structures are unsound, adding they have even offered a way for him to adapt the buildings for reuse.
Mr. Rujumba said the developer got emergency approval in 2020 to raze 209 First because of safety concerns and that it’s still standing three years later. The building, he said, is still “strong and sound.”
“If there’s a contention that these buildings are a public nuisance, they are only a public nuisance because their owner has allowed them to become a public nuisance,” he said.
Jay Green, an adjacent property owner on Boulevard of the Allies, agreed with Mr. Rujumba, arguing that Mr. Troiani has allowed the buildings to deteriorate.
“What this is is a sham. It’s a precedent for disaster. It’s a clever sidestep,” he said. “But do we need this to be a precedent in the city for anyone who wants to tear down a building and doesn’t have a viable option ... that they can just say they’re going to build a bocce court or a public nuisance pickleball court and be allowed to tear it down?”
However, the proposal won the backing of James Moritz, president of the homeowners association at the 151 First Side condominium tower near Market Street. He said bricks, glass and roofing materials fall from the Troiani buildings and pose a danger to people. Rats, pigeons and other “vermin” also create health issues, he told the commission.
“This is a health and safety issue, clearly. These buildings represent a danger. Someone is either going to get hurt or killed or have property damage done. The buildings need to come down. It’s really that fundamental,” he said.
In approving the demolitions, the commission conditioned them on Mr. Troiani first getting approval from zoning officials for the bocce court redevelopment.
Asked by one commission member how long he plans to keep the bocce courts in place before considering another development, Mr. Troiani said he didn’t know.
“I don’t have a glass ball to predict the future. I think this use is going to be awesome,” he said, adding he hopes “it has a long and successful run.”
Steve Regan, Mr. Troiani’s attorney, said afterward that the developer plans to start the demolitions this winter when there’s less vehicular and pedestrian traffic.
“If there are no appeals, we intend to proceed in earnest and get this done as soon as possible,” he said.
When asked about claims that Mr. Troiani allowed the structures to deteriorate, Mr. Regan replied that the developer has been putting forth proposals for years and all “have been opposed tooth and nail from day one.”
“That’s the reason why there has been such a significant delay,” he said.
Also Tuesday, the commission was briefed on plans for a six-story, 211-unit apartment complex at 1625 Forbes Ave. in Uptown dubbed the Phoenix on Forbes. The project would include a commitment to designate 10% of the units as affordable to households at 60% of the area median income.
Proposed by GSX Ventures, one unique aspect is to cover the Forbes Avenue facade with 10 panels of public art created by local artists. The artwork could be changed every five to 10 years.
The plan got some pushback from the commission, with chairwoman LaShawn Burton-Faulk asking for more detail on how artists would be selected, the art’s durability, and whether it would ever be turned into advertising.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.