A developer has struck out again — maybe for the final time — in its bid to tear down an old Downtown night spot and two neighboring buildings on Market Street.
In one-sentence orders issued last week, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court declined to review two Commonwealth Court rulings that barred the Troiani Group from demolishing the three Market Street structures, including one that housed the old Froggy’s restaurant.
The decisions leave Troiani searching for options. It believes the Market Street structures are unsound and should be razed. But the city has fought that effort, even as it has condemned the buildings as unsafe.
“We’re evaluating simply how to proceed because we still have concerns about the buildings,” said Clifford Levine, Troiani’s attorney. “We’re looking for some resolution so that we can move forward with some constructive development in that part of the city.”
Michael Troiani, president of Troiani Group, declined to say what the possible next options could be, though he added, “It will be an exciting new year.”
Mr. Troiani called the decisions by the Supreme Court not to accept the developer’s appeals “awfully unfortunate.”
Read More
He contended that the state Commonwealth Court rulings were flawed and “not very clear at all.”
In the first of two rulings last spring, the court upheld a city planning commission decision rejecting a proposal by Troiani to tear down the three buildings.
The court, in the other, reversed an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court ruling that gave Troiani the right to demolish the structures after a city board of appeals in the Department of Permits, Licenses, and Inspections rejected the request.
Even with the legal appeals exhausted, the long-running saga spanning some three years still shows no signs of ending.
Further complicating the situation is the city is trying to press Troiani through court action to raze a dilapidated building at 209 First Ave. adjacent to the Market Street structures.
While all agree the building must go, the developer maintains it can’t tear it down without first razing the ones on Market.
The city has countered with testimony from a demolition contractor who has stated that the First Avenue structure can be brought down without threatening the others.
Troiani has been trying to meet with city planning officials to clarify what it would take to get permission to demolish all four structures. So far, that effort hasn’t produced an agreement.
“It’s just a sad state of affairs,” Mr. Troiani said.
During a hearing last month before District Judge Oscar Petite Jr., Mr. Levine saw irony in the fact that the city has condemned the Market Street structures as unsafe but won’t allow Troiani to tear them down.
At the time, Judge Petite gave the developer 60 days to meet with the city to try to find a path forward.
Demolition would require another hearing before the city planning commission, which refused in 2020 to grant the request in part because the buildings involved are part of the Firstside Historic District listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
However, the commission left the door open for Troiani to return with the same demolition request as long as it was coupled with a formal project development plan for the site.
But Mr. Levine has argued that trying to put together such a plan without having site control amounts to a Catch-22.
Troiani has wanted to remove the First and Market structures to clear the site for a proposed 30-story development that would feature office space, residences, retail, and parking.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.