Drinks are on the house. Froggy’s has won a reprieve.
The Pittsburgh Planning Commission on Tuesday rejected a bid by Troiani Development to demolish buildings at 100-102 and 104-106 Market St., Downtown — including one that housed the old watering hole — to clear the way for a new 30-story office and residential tower.
Its decision saves the buildings for the time being, although Troiani does have the option of returning to the commission with a plan to raze them if it is coupled with a formal proposal to redevelop the site.
In making the decision, commissioners questioned Troiani’s contention that the buildings were beyond repair and that it was financially infeasible to try to salvage them as part of the new development.
Commission Chairwoman Christine Mondor noted that the buildings involved are part of the Firstside Historic District listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
“These are designated as contributing. They face buildings that are contributing. If you have to evaluate buildings that are contributing, ones that have a cluster or are near to other ones, create a sense of urban space,” she said.
Read More
“It’s not just about the building, it’s about the space that’s created between the buildings. So I feel that that strengthens the case that these are contributing buildings for the saving.”
The decision is a blow to Troiani’s efforts to create a footprint large enough to house the proposed tower, which would feature 200,000 square feet of office, 151 residences, 300 parking spaces, and two floors of retail.
Last month, the developer won an emergency bid before the board of appeals in the city’s Department of Permits, Licenses, and Inspections to tear down a vacant six-story building at 209 First Ave. that was in the path of the new development.
But the Market Street structures account for a large part of the proposed footprint. Michael Troiani, president of Troiani Group, could not be reached for comment after the vote. Clifford Levine, the developer’s attorney, declined comment.
In denying the demolitions, the commission left open the door that Troiani could return again with the same request as long as it was coupled with a formal project-development plan for the site.
Although Troiani had submitted renderings and other information about the tower it intended to build there, it was not part of the formal application for demolition.
Before the vote, Mr. Levine argued that requiring Troiani to spend the time and money to come up with a formal plan without having site control was a Catch-22. He said Troiani does have interest from other developers in the project but that no one is going to sign on without the site locked up.
“They’re not going to commit until we say, ‘We have a footprint available, and here’s the design,’” he said.
But local preservationists testified Tuesday that Troiani could still build what he wanted at the site while preserving the buildings it was seeking to demolish, including Froggy’s, a popular haunt for celebrities and locals that closed in 2003.
A study by the IKM architectural firm commissioned by the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation produced about eight different options for preserving all or parts of the structures as part of a broader development.
“We think they work. And we think that Market Street — our most historic street in Downtown Pittsburgh — should be preserved. The scale should be preserved, the buildings should be preserved,” said Arthur Ziegler, PHLF president.
He said the foundation had saved buildings at the other end of Market Street near Market Square that were in far worse shape than Froggy’s. “We think we can save the buildings or part of the buildings. Mr. Troiani can have a new building. We can live congenially,” he added.
“We do not want to sacrifice these buildings for open land where no actual building has been proposed on a feasible basis yet.”
In their presentation two weeks ago, Troiani representatives had argued that the buildings were no longer structurally sound, that they were of marginal historic value, and that reusing them as part of the broader redevelopment was a money-loser.
They pointed to estimates developed as part of the reuse proposals that showed there would be at least a $3 million gap to fill between the cost of renovating the structures and the revenue they could generate.
But in voting against the demolitions, Ms. Mondor said such gaps are common in the early stages of development.
“I do not feel that gap is insurmountable, because almost every project in this kind of circumstances and ones I’ve worked on have gaps,” she said, adding that developers find ways to fund them.
The 30-story tower also likely will have gaps in funding, she continued.
Mr. Levine could not commit that the proposed project would be all privately funded because Troiani has yet to secure tenants.
“That would be the ideal situation,” he said.
In other actions Tuesday, the commission approved:
• A $17 million proposal to build 62 apartments and retail space at the corner of Federal Street and North Avenue in the Garden Theater block of the North Side. The development includes a new five-story building and the rehabilitation of the Morton House. Three studio apartments also are planned on the mezzanine level of the Garden Theater.
• Conversion of the 321,000-square-foot former Sears Outlet in Lawrenceville into high-bay research and development and creative office space.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.