Ten months after striking out before the state Supreme Court in his battle to tear down three Downtown buildings, a developer has turned to another type of court to get what he wants — a bocce court, to be exact.
Michael Troiani is proposing to demolish three dilapidated buildings at 100-106 Market Street and another on First Avenue and replace them with four bocce courts in what is being billed as an entertainment and recreational venue. If that works out, Mr. Troiani said, he may even add a pickleball court on part of the site closest to the Boulevard of the Allies.
The bocce court proposal is the latest twist in Mr. Troiani’s four-year battle with the city to raze the Market Street buildings, including the old Froggy’s restaurant.
In December, the state’s high court all but slammed the door on the demolitions, declining to review two Commonwealth Court rulings that barred Mr. Troiani from taking down the structures, all of which he owns. Compounding the situation is that the city, while seeking to preserve the Market Street buildings even after condemning them as unsafe, has been pressing Mr. Troiani to raze another he owns at 209 First Avenue. While Mr. Troiani agrees that that building should go, he maintains he can’t bring it down without first demolishing those on Market.
His latest bid to bring down the buildings involves the bocce court proposal.
During a development activities meeting before the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, Mr. Troiani said bocce courts are permitted as a matter of right in the Golden Triangle zoning district.
Read More
“This bocce court is a gift to the city to stabilize this site and to create a use that will engage the city and the neighbors and the guests for years to come,” he said.
Through Troy Development, he has submitted four separate applications to the planning commission to demolish the Market and First Avenue buildings, and another for the development of the bocce courts.
But while the plan may be allowed Downtown, Mr. Troiani may still have some serious courting to do.
In 2020, the planning commission rejected his request to raze the structures involved because they are part of a Firstside Historic District listed on the National Register of Historic Places. At the time, the commission left the door open for the developer to return with a formal project development plan for the site.
Because of that, Mr. Troiani believes he will be able to get the panel’s support for the demolitions and the bocce ball project.
“It’s specifically a full blown development plan and I expect to deliver it to the planning commission with a city planning [department] recommendation,” he said Tuesday.
Before the latest venture, Mr. Troiani had been pitching a plan to build a 30-story high-rise at the site, one that would feature office space, residences, retail, and parking.
But that was before the COVID-19 pandemic drastically altered the office and retail landscape, both Downtown and throughout the country.
In making his case for the courts, Mr. Troiani said that bocce is the third most popular sport in the world and that Pittsburgh is one of ten cities in the U.S. recognized by Major League Bocce. Right now, there are bocce courts in Bloomfield.
“I’m really looking to partner with my neighbors and really the urban village that we have to bring people together and play some games in good society and not worry about bricks falling on peoples’ heads,” he said.
The courts would be open to the public on weekdays, with league play set for Saturdays and Sundays. Special events also are planned. There would be seating for players and spectators as well as picnic benches with umbrellas.
“For those of you who know bocce, it’s a very social activity. Therefore having people sit there to watch it or having the players themselves sit and provide comments and generalized heckling to go along with the game is all part of the fun of it,” said Steven Victor, a representative with Mr Troiani’s development team.
Mr. Troiani, owner of Papa J’s restaurant in the Strip, said he does not plan to serve food or beverages at the site.
“That’s not an income source here. We’re playing bocce,” he said.
And while he controls about 46 to 50 parking spaces in lots around the property, he insisted there was no parking being offered as part of the proposal itself. He plans to continue offering paid parking during the day.
The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership has yet to take a position on the proposal, though it did team with Mr. Troiani for use of the site during Picklesburgh last summer. Mr. Troiani said he would like to continue such collaborations.
Another organization, the Downtown Neighbors Alliance, supports the plan, executive director John Valentine said.
“I think it’s really good. You’re activating an area that’s not activated,” he said.
While bocce courts are far less ambitious than an office and residential tower, Mr. Valentine said he thought Mr. Troiani was being realistic about what he could achieve.
“He spent a lot of money in court to get that done,” he said of the previous proposal. “I think he came to the resignation that it is not going to get done.”
The Market Street buildings have continued to deteriorate since the planning commission rejected the attempt to demolish them, to the point that the city condemned them in 2021 even as Mr. Troiani lobbied to tear them down. One resident of the 151 First Side condominium building near the site said during the PDP meeting that she was “concerned about the potential danger.”
She endorsed the bocce proposal, however.
“I love bocce. When I saw this agenda come out and saw bocce on it, I said, ‘wow, wouldn’t this be nice.’ I have to bring my bocce set back to Pittsburgh with me,” she said.
But not everybody liked the proposal.
Architect Rob Pfaffmann, who has offices Downtown, said he is opposed to the plan.
“I think this is a little bit of a bait and switch,” he said. “We know that a bocce court will not be a long-term sustainable use for a valuable Downtown lot and that the historic preservation value of the building is far more valuable to the long-term viability of Downtown.”
Mr. Pfaffmann predicted that the bocce courts will be gone in five or 10 years.
“I think everybody knows this is not good city planning. It’s not good development for the city,” he argued.
Representatives for Mr. Troiani countered that the proposal is permitted by right.
Mr. Pfaffmann wasn’t impressed.
“Of course, it is. But the zoning code doesn’t make great cities. It is a framework for the development of cities. In this case, it is taking advantage of the situation,” he said. “Those of you who don’t know the reason they can’t expand the parking lot here is because that’s prohibited. They know they have to find an interim use. And so to the extent that this happens and it’s successful, that’s great. But mark my words: It will not happen that way.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.