Testimony wrapped up Tuesday in a hearing on a National Labor Relations Board court petition to force the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette into new contract negotiations, nearly seven years after the last contract expired in 2017.

U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon gave NLRB and Post-Gazette attorneys until Feb. 3 to file final briefs on the preliminary injunction sought by the labor board. A ruling is expected after that.

Four Post-Gazette unions have been on strike for more than two years. The hearing, which stretched over three days between November and January, involve unions representing newspaper pressmen, mailers and advertisers. The Pittsburgh Newspaper Guild, the newspaper’s biggest union, was not part of the NLRB’s petition.

The NLRB is seeking the injunction under Section 10(j) of the National Labor Relations Act to stop alleged unfair labor practices while union filings make their way through the board’s administrative process.

Advertise with us

During the second day of hearings in early January, attorney Joe Pass, who said he has represented the newspaper pressmen since the 1970s, testified that the company had not changed its contract proposal since the last labor agreement expired. “It’s been absolutely futile for eight years, absolutely no movement,” Mr. Pass testified.

NLRB attorney Anne E. Tewksbury argued the Post-Gazette’s contract proposals would’ve given union members “substantially fewer rights and less protection than provided by law without a contract.”

Employee layoffs and recalls, discipline and wages were among the areas where the company’s contract offer was worse than the expired contract, she said, in making her case for allegations of bad-faith bargaining.

Post-Gazette attorneys said proposed contract terms reflected a tough environment for print publications, with many U.S. newspapers operating in the red or closing in recent years. The newspaper lost nearly $20 million in 2019 and suffered significant losses in subsequent years, attorney Richard Lowe testified.

“The business model for the newspaper was broken,” he said. “We were awash in red ink. We made proposals based on what our needs were going to be.”

Advertise with us

The company proposed a three-year contract for pressman at a lower hourly wage than that in the expired contract, Ms. Tewksbury said, with Mr. Lowe countering that the offer was on par with the existing pay because it included an 8% decrease in health insurance premiums.

Post-Gazette attorney Michael Oesterle testified Tuesday that Mr. Pass reneged in 2021 on an agreement for employees to absorb a 5% increase in health insurance premiums. The newspaper offered employees coverage through a company self-insured plan.

Mr. Oesterle said an NLRB administrative law judge later ruled the newspaper had no obligation to cover the premium increase. He also said contract negotiations were complicated by the unions’ slow response to offers.

“This was a union — and I have 36.5 years experience — that absolutely refused to respond to proposals,” he said.