A federal judge in Pittsburgh rebuked a National Labor Relations Board attorney at a court hearing Monday and then set a November date to continue arguments on a request for a preliminary injunction that could force the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and its striking unions back to the bargaining table.

Members of several production unions struck the newspaper two years ago over a change moving them to a high-deductible health insurance plan in place for other employees of Block Communications Inc., the newspaper’s Toledo, Ohio-based corporate parent.

The newspaper settled with one of the unions, the Teamsters, earlier this year.

The Newspaper Guild of Pittsburgh, which represents newsroom employees, joined the strike several days after the initial walkout. It is not part of the injunction request under consideration in Monday’s hearing.

Advertise with us

Earlier this year, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the NLRB must meet four criteria to obtain a preliminary injunction, including that the plaintiff is likely to suffer irreparable harm without preliminary relief.

The NLRB was to focus testimony Monday on meeting those factors.

Judge Cathy Bissoon, of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, said it has not met that requirement yet.

“My problem is you’ve giving me nothing to assess in this hearing,” she told NLRB field attorney Anne E. Tewksbury as the attorney was reading her closing argument following nearly three hours of testimony.

The judge called a brief recess to allow Ms. Tewksbury time to organize her arguments, but after the break, the attorney asked to postpone the proceeding until Tuesday so she could call another witness.

Advertise with us

Judge Bissoon instead continued the hearing until Nov. 20.

In addition to a preliminary injunction, Ms. Tewksbury said the NLRB is seeking reimbursement of medical expenses for union members while they are on strike.

The Post-Gazette’s contracts with union workers expired in 2017. The strike began in October 2022.

Six employees testified about health problems and out-of-pocket medical, dental and vision expenses they had incurred, including an official in the mailers union who said his expenses have exceeded $15,000.

Post-Gazette attorney Brian Hentosz, from the Downtown firm of Littler Mendelson P.C., told the court that the employees would’ve had health insurance had they not walked off the job.

Advertise with us

Both sides accuse the other of failing to bargain in good faith, with Post-Gazette Director of Operations Robert Weber testifying on Monday that the unions had not requested to negotiate in all of 2021. The unions have also not asked to meet following the newspaper’s announcement in June that it was closing print operations in Clinton before July 2025, he said.

“We’ve requested effects bargaining and they have not reached out,” he testified.

In July, an NLRB administrative law judge ruled the Post-Gazette had bargained in bad faith with the typographical union, but said there was no evidence it improperly implemented the new health insurance plan.